Spoiler commentary and discussion of Ichikei no Karasu (manga, drama, and film).

Ichikei no Karasu is a Japanese legal manga by Rito Asami featuring a judge. It was serialized in Morning from 2018. The main character, Sakama, is assigned to the First Criminal Division of the Musashino District Court, known as "Ichikei." There, he meets an unconventional judge, Michio Iruma. Unlike Sakama, who believes that judges are only supposed to issue rulings, Iruma is the type of judge who visits actual crime scenes and thoroughly examines anything that interests him. In this humanistic legal work, Sakama grows as a judge and as a person as he becomes involved with Iruma, who even considers the life of the defendant.

Contents

Persons involved in the case

Tabata no Norimichi

Tabata is a world-class writer.

He is a world-class writer who received the Nobel Prize in Literature. He is a defendant in an indecent assault case.
Tabata, who was busy with the deadline for his work, went out of the night for a change. As he was passing by Arashigaoka Park, he saw a young woman enter the toilet in the park. Wanting to relieve the stress of the deadline, Tabata impulsively comes up with the idea of committing the crime.
When the woman entered the toilet, Tabata also entered the women's toilet. She turned off the light and touched the woman's chest from behind. When the woman shouted, she rushed out of the toilet.
However, the woman looked at Tabata when she looked back, and Tabata was arrested later.
The first trial started, and Komazawa explained to Tabata about his right to remain silent. Then Komazawa told Tabata,' If you haven't done it, please tell me you haven't done it,' and Tabata said,' I haven't done it!' Because of this and because Tabata was a world-famous writer, public opinion came to think that' Tabata was falsely accused' and' Tabata was a poor writer who was arrested by the victim's fabrication.'
As Tabata denied committing the crime and the woman said, "I saw Tabata's face clearly even in the pitch-dark restroom. But I don't remember how Tabata was dressed," the defense counsel, who had pleaded not guilty to Tabata's charges, asked Sakama and others to inspect the scene. Sakama and others went to the restroom in the park, which was the actual site of the crime, and repeated the inspection in the same way as they did at the time of the crime.
First, the Sakama enters the toilet, and when it's dark, a staff member who looks like a farmer stands in the background. The question is whether you can see the staff member's face clearly when the Sakama turns around.
As a result, Tabata was found guilty on the grounds that the victim was not acquainted with Tabata and that there was no reason to deceive Tabata by lying.
Even so, the public was clamoring, "Tabata is falsely accused," and "The prosecutor and the judge are all together." On the other hand, Tabata accepted this ruling and did not appeal. The truth remains unknown because it is not depicted whether it is because he really committed a crime or because he gave up telling the court that nothing he said would change him.

Yoshiharu OKI

Oki has lost his wife and is despairing of life.

An elderly man who is homeless. After graduating from a local junior high school, he became an apprentice carpenter. He worked for a long time, but 23 years ago he became unable to work due to illness. Together with his wife, he makes a living by working as a day laborer. He built a simple house under the riverbed and lives there. He has a previous criminal record and is currently on probation.
One day, his wife complained of chest pain, so he took him to Taguchi General Hospital. There, the doctor diagnosed him as having no problems, and he returned home. However, a few days later, his wife suddenly died.
Upon discovering his wife's diary, Oki finds a description in it that says, "A few days after I went to the hospital, my chest began to hurt again." Because of this, Oki feels, "The doctor made a proper diagnosis because I was homeless. That's why my wife died."
Just before she died, she was cooking, so she wrapped a knife in a towel as her shoulder and took it to Taguchi General Hospital. Oki shouted at the clerk at the hospital, "Give me the doctor at that time." Since the clerk didn't cooperate, he hit the towel on the floor, saying, "You're going to hurt me!" Since the knife came out from there, he called the police. Since he didn't intend to do any harm, he sat quietly in his chair and waited until the police came.
Facing the trial, Oki felt powerless due to the death of his wife and realized that he could not escape a prison sentence for the crime he had committed while on probation, and said to Irima,' Please do not spare time for such an old man and quickly convict me.' However, when Irima said to him,' Why don't you let your wife live a little longer in your life?', he felt that his wife was still alive in his heart and shed tears.
Since then, Iruma was sentenced to a fine of 200000 yen. Also, the number of days of detention was set at 5000 yen per day, and Oki had already reached 200000 yen for the days of his detention, so he did not have to pay any more.
After the ruling, a police officer told him, "I'm glad you got a fine. I'm sure your wife who passed away met with Judge Iruma. Do your best to get back to work." Although he wasn't familiar with the situation at the time, he returned to work at a rehabilitation support facility and was able to work at a peach farm.
At the end of the story, Oki sent a letter of thanks to Iruma, in which he wrote, "I think my late wife saw Judge Iruma. She is an extremely weak person, but I appreciate that you consider it good to be alive."

Keiko 潮川 (played by Marin)

Keiko tears after being abused by her mother-in-law.

A full-time housewife in her 30s, she was on probation for theft by shoplifting.
She suffers from mild depression due to her inability to bear the burden of child-rearing alone, caring for her bedridden mother-in-law, and verbal abuse from her mother-in-law. She also develops Kleptomania as she begins to relieve stress with "the tension and thrill of taking things, and the exhilaration of shoplifting."
She also had a husband, but he was working away from home. She didn't want to worry about her, so she insisted, "I'm fine with my family." However, this stress caused her to shoplift repeatedly.
One day, a shoplifter shoplifted at a nearby supermarket, Copi Mart. The shoplifter saw the shoplifter and called out to him when he left the store.
As she tried to run away in a hurry, a security guard caught Keiko. Keiko panicked and tried to escape by biting the security guard's arms, but she was arrested. She was charged with the crime of shoplifting and assault, both of which were suspended. Sakama was considering detention because of the possibility of shoplifting again and the possibility of leaving Hotaru with her sister and running away, but she was able to go home thanks to Tsutsumi's persuasion.
She was told by the bank to use an online supermarket, but her daily life did not change even after she returned home. She was told by Takuma that she would divorce her husband after the trial. She became distressed and felt the urge to shoplift again. When she went to the store and tried to shoplift, she was found by chance on the bank and stopped. Since she was aware of shoplifting and causing trouble, she apologized to the bank in tears, saying, "I'm sorry for being such a mother. I'm sorry for causing trouble."
In both the last shoplifting trial and this one, she said she wanted to treat Kleptomania, but because she had depression and was too busy with housework, child-rearing and nursing care to be treated, she was not confident that she would not commit the crime again.
At that time, Hotaru came to the trial alone during the trial. When Hotaru was encouraged from the audience by saying, "Mom! It's all right because Hotaru is here!", she reflected on what she had done from the bottom of her heart, saying, "I was making my daughter feel like this." On her return from the trial, she complained to Takuma for the first time, saying, "I can't do it alone." Takuma finally understood Keiko's feelings and decided to support her and concentrate on her treatment together.
At the final trial, Sakama asked Keiko, "What do you think about your daughter coming to the court?" Keiko swore, "I got a heartache thinking that I was making my daughter worried so much. From now on, I will ask my husband and those around me for support and treat Kleptomania." Seeing her like that, Sakama believed her and issued a suspended sentence again.
After the trial was over, he was waiting outside the court and was delighted to take his hand.

潮川 Hotaru (played by Aigetsu TERADA)

Hotaru, a daughter in the lower grades of elementary school.

A girl in the lower grades of elementary school. She loves Keiko.
Takuma could not understand Keiko's Kreptomania, so Takuma said to Keiko,' Let's get divorced after the trial. I'll take care of Hotaru.' Listening to the conversation in secret, Takuma felt that even though he was a child, he would "be separated from Mom."
On the day of Keiko's trial, Hotaru skipped school saying she had a stomachache. When Hiruma went to Keiko's trial, Hotaru sneaked out of the house. She went to a familiar neighborhood store and asked how to get to the court.
When she arrived at the court alone, she met Matsuda, who had come to observe the trial. She was escorted to Keiko's trial, and at the beginning of the trial she sat quietly listening to her.
However, when the prosecutor asked Keiko, "You said you would do your best to treat Kreptomania in the future, but you shoplifted again by saying so last time, didn't you? Don't you feel sorry for your daughter?", she couldn't stand the scene and shouted "Mommy!" to Keiko from the audience seat. She defended Keiko, saying "Hotaru I was able to come here by myself! I can hotaru go shopping! Mom will be fine!" to Keiko who was surprised.
There is no change in the fact that Hotaru was making a fuss, so Sakama orders Hotaru to leave the room saying,' We are in the middle of the trial.' She left the room with Warabi, her lawyer, and after that, she was waiting for Keiko on a chair in the corridor.
After the trial, she fell asleep, probably because she was tired, and returned home with Hiruma on her back. This impulsive behavior of Hotaru left an impression in Sakama's eyes that' it was a child trying to protect his mother,' and became one of the materials to give Keiko a suspended sentence again.

Takuma 潮川 (played by Ryu Morioka)

Takuma is suffering from Keiko's shoplifting.

The husband of Keiko, who is working away from home in Germany.
She regularly asked Keiko if she was OK with her child care and nursing care. She asked Keiko to take care of her family in order for her to answer that she was OK, but she was troubled by her repeated shoplifting.
Also, she could not understand Keiko's feelings about shoplifting, and when she heard from Tsutsumi that "Kreptomania may become a disease that she will have to deal with for the rest of her life," she was perplexed and said, "Will my wife shoplift for the rest of her life." She could not understand Keiko who was suffering from Kreptomania, and she did not participate in the association of the family who suffered from addiction. She thought about her health and asked Keiko to divorce her after the trial.
However, Hotaru came to the court and tried to protect Keiko. After the trial, Keiko asked Hotaru to help her, saying, "It's really hard for me. I want you to help me with childcare and nursing care." She decided to face Keiko's illness and apologized to her, saying, "I'm sorry that I made Keiko say she was okay."
From now on, she showed her will to support her family, child care and nursing care, and Keiko's illness. Partly because of this, Sakama issued a suspended sentence on the expectation that Keiko's environment would improve.

Takuma no Haha (played by Keiko Katsukura)

Takuma's mother takes care of a bedridden person at home.

An elderly bedridden woman living with Keiko and Hotaru.
Whether or not she is also demented, she repeatedly asks the same thing and uses abusive language against Keiko. Hiroko was driven into a corner by the words from her mother, "Where is Takuma?" and "I don't want to eat your garbage."

Shuji OGISHIMA

Ogishima is suspected of beating Tsunoi to death.

After graduating from high school, she got a job and reached retirement age as a section chief. She has a daughter and grandchildren. Since reaching retirement age, she and her husband have been volunteering to pick up trash.
Ogishima goes to the Tsuki-no-Mori Ground twice a week to stay healthy and takes a walk with his wife. Along the way, he meets Tsudoi at a convenience store where he stopped by.
Tsunoi was littering his cigarette from the window of his car. Kokishima, who was volunteering to pick up trash, approached Tsunoi and warned him, "You must not litter." However, Tsunoi did not reflect and said, "Shut up!" in response, so Kokishima left the place thinking there would be an argument.
He got in his car again and headed to the Tsuki-no-Mori Ground. When he arrived at the parking lot of the Tsuki-no-Mori Ground, a car stopped next to him. It was Tsunoi's car. Tsunoi got angry at Kokishima's warning and chased him here from the convenience store.
Tsudoi got out of the car and said, "I came to have a fight with you." Tsudoi was well-mannered, and Ogishima felt that if he continued to fight, he would surely lose. Also, Ogishima suggested to Tsudoi that he should go to the field over there so that he would be okay even if he got injured, because he could not involve his wife. As he walked in front of Tsudoi, Ogishima was afraid that he might be hit from behind.
When he reached the field, he took off his glasses because it was dangerous. Then, he brought his arms to the front of his face as if to guard him. Tsudoi hit Kokishima. One of the bullets hit Kokishima's eyes. This damaged his eyes to the point of causing a retinal hemorrhage. At the same time, Kokishima felt that "he will be killed if this goes on." Kokishima turned down and hit him back desperately. Kokishima's bullet hit Tsudoi's face.
Tsunoi stumbles and falls to the ground. Ogishima was worried about Tsunoi, but when Tsunoi made a hand gesture like "go away", he left. After that, when he returned to his wife, took a walk and was about to return to his car, he noticed that police and ambulances were gathering around Tsunoi. When the police asked him, "Do you know anyone who had a fight with Mr. Tsunoi?" and he came forward, he was arrested.
As a result of the trial, Ogishima was found not guilty, and since there was no firm evidence that he had intentionally caused Tsunoi to die, he was found not guilty.
After the trial, the couple became friends and went on trips.

Kiyoshi Tsuui

Tsunoi takes a fighting pose.

tw-2948897452
tw-2948897452
@tw-2948897452

Contents