Spoiler commentary and discussion of Ichikei no Karasu (manga, drama, and film).

Ichikei no Karasu is a Japanese legal manga by Rito Asami featuring a judge. It was serialized in Morning from 2018. The main character, Sakama, is assigned to the First Criminal Division of the Musashino District Court, known as "Ichikei." There, he meets an unconventional judge, Michio Iruma. Unlike Sakama, who believes that judges are only supposed to issue rulings, Iruma is the type of judge who visits actual crime scenes and thoroughly examines anything that interests him. In this humanistic legal work, Sakama grows as a judge and as a person as he becomes involved with Iruma, who even considers the life of the defendant.

Contents

Outline of "Ichikei no Karasu"

"Ichikei no Karasu" (The Crow of Ichikei) is a Japanese legal comic based on the trial by Ritsuto ASAMI.
The Morning series ran from the 24th issue in 2018 to the 14th issue in 2019. The book consists of four volumes.
In April 2021, it was adapted into a live-action drama, in which Yutaka TAKENOUCHI played Michio IRUMA. The average audience rating for all 11 episodes was 12.6%. A movie version is scheduled for 2023, which will be set two years after the live-action drama.
The main character, Sakama Shinpei (Shimpei), is a judge assigned to the Musashino District Court's First Criminal Division, commonly known as "Ichikei." Sakama thought that "the job of a judge is only to make judgments," and that "what kind of life the accused will live after that" was outside of work. Daiichi
At that time, Ichikei met Iruma. Iruma iruma is a former lawyer and a very unconventional judge. He not only examined the evidence submitted in the trial, but also went to the scene of the case himself if there was anything he was concerned about and verified whether the testimony of the accused was correct. Then, Iruma considered the rest of the life of the accused and made a decision after thinking through it.
While looking at Iruma's attitude, this is a human legal work in which Sakama grows as a judge and a human being.

Outline and story of "Ichikei no Karasu"

Sakama meets Michio Irima

Sakama, an assistant special judge assigned to the First Criminal Division of the Musashino District Court, commonly known as "Ichikei," meets Iruma, another judge. Iruma was an unconventional judge who listened to the defendant, examined the evidence, and sometimes went to the scene of the crime himself. Sakama could not understand Iruma's behavior, saying that it was "inefficient. He also hears that Yoshio Komazawa, Sakama's boss and a judge, is also being shunned by the court because he has ruled more than 10 cases not guilty.
Meanwhile, Norimichi Tabata, who was arrested on suspicion of indecent assault, was indicted and scheduled for trial. For the first time, Sakama is to stand trial alone with Komazawa and Iruma.
The case outlined that Tabata had committed an indecent act on a female victim in a restroom at night. After hearing the details, Komazawa told Tabata, "The defendant has the right to remain silent. And above all, if you really didn't do it, please say you didn't do it. Sakama was surprised to hear this.
It is his duty to explain the right to remain silent, but Komazawa spoke to the defendant as if it were easy for the defendant to say "I didn't do it. It is unprecedented for a judge to create an environment in which the defendant can easily say "I didn't do it. To Sakama's surprise, Tabata confessed, "I didn't do it...! he confessed. At that moment, Komazawa was laughing, and Sakama asked, "It would be absolutely troublesome for the defendant to deny the crime after coming to the trial, so why is he laughing? Sakama did not understand Komazawa's feelings.

Tabata was a world-renowned writer and was under a lot of stress before his deadline. He went outside for a change of pace and saw a woman enter the restroom at Arashigaoka Station. On a whim, he turned off the light and crept into the women's restroom, touching her breasts from behind and committing other indecent acts. However, he fled when the victim screamed loudly. Later, the victim remembered Tabata's face, leading to his arrest.
The defense pleaded not guilty.
After the trial, Sakama asked Iruma, "Why did Director Komazawa go out of his way to tell the defendant, 'If you didn't do it, please tell me you didn't do it? Is it because the defendant is a world-famous author and is attracting attention?" I ask. Iruma replied, "I had no such intention. Iruma replies, "I didn't intend it that way, but I told the defendant that I thought he was a real person. Sakama was not convinced, saying, "I know that he is a flesh-and-blood human being.

At the second trial, the victim testified that he saw Tabata clearly in the pitch-dark bathroom. The defense attorney told Komazawa, "I will request a new verification.
In other words, he wanted the judge to actually go to the scene of the crime and verify whether he could really see the other party's face in the dark.
After the trial, Sakama opposes the request because he does not feel that verification is necessary. Iruma and Komazawa, however, were in favor of verification, saying, "There are things that cannot be understood without actually trying.
Sakama thought it was a waste of time, but a few days later, Komazawa, Iruma, the defense attorney, the prosecutor, and several staff members similar to Tabata visited the crime scene. The verification consisted of Sakama first entering the bathroom. After turning off the light, one of the staff members resembling Tabata enters and stands behind Sakama. After Sakama turned around and left the restroom, the participants were asked to guess who the staff member was.
After repeated verification not only by Sakama but also by Komazawa and Iruma, they were almost able to guess the staff member. In other words, the victim was not lying and had really seen Tabata's face.
After the verification was over, on the train ride home, Sakama asked Iruma, "Wasn't it still a waste of time?" asked Iruma. Iruma replied, "If we only look at the conclusion, the verification may have been in vain. But the process leading up to the decision is also important.
At that time, public opinion was also thinking that "a famous writer would not commit a crime" because Tabata was a famous writer, and the rumor was spreading that the case was a fabrication by the victim.

After a series of trials, the day finally came to hand down a verdict against Tabata. Based on the evidence presented by the prosecution and defense, the testimonies of the defendant and the victim, and the nighttime bathroom inspection, the three judges found Tabata guilty.
However, public opinion is still saying that Tabata was falsely convicted, and Sakama, seeing these voices on social networking sites, says, "I know that Komazawa and Iruma verified the case to prevent false accusations. However, no matter how much thought we put into the decision, the public still doesn't understand it. Moreover, Tabata did not appeal the verdict. In other words, he was satisfied with the guilty verdict.
Hearing this, Sakama asked, "Did he not appeal because he was actually guilty? Or did he just give up because he was not guilty and the court wouldn't take it up?" He was bewildered.

Sakama's Changing Feelings as a Judge

On one occasion, Sakama decided to observe a trial in which Iruma was the judge.
The case Iruma was in charge of was as follows.
One day, the husband, Yoshiharu Ohki, took his wife to the hospital because she complained of chest pain. The doctor examined her and found nothing wrong, so he went home. A few days later, however, his wife died. Since both Oki and his wife were homeless, Oki felt that the doctor did not examine them properly because they were homeless, so he went to the hospital with a kitchen knife. There, he was arrested for threatening the hospital, saying, "If you don't get me a doctor, I'm going to hurt you.
Iruma listened carefully to Oki's story, and based on the evidence, he sentenced him to a fine of 200,000 yen. He also guided him to a rehabilitation facility and asked the prosecutors to support him so that his life would be better in the future, and the trial was over.
After the trial, Sakama told Iruma, "If it were up to me, I would have this trial suspended instead of fined. Iruma said, "It seems like a high hurdle for Mr. Oki to work seriously without returning to homelessness in the future. If he is placed on probation and commits a second offense during that time, his next one will surely be a prison sentence. To prevent that from happening, we decided to fine him. In response, Sakama clearly expressed his opinion, saying, "Our job is only to pass judgment, and there is nothing we can do if we keep thinking about the defendant's future. Iruma said, "But, for example, Mr. Oki re-offends and goes to jail, and even after he completes his sentence and gets out, he comes back and commits another crime. Don't you think what we did was wrong? Is Mr. Oki's weakness just for Mr. Oki?" I asked. Sakama could not answer that question.
Several years later, a letter arrived from Oki to Iruma. Oki had gone to a rehabilitation facility after the trial and was now working at a peach farm. In the letter, he expressed his gratitude to Iruma for giving him a chance for rehabilitation, saying, "I think my late wife brought me to Judge Iruma at that time.

Sakama was a judge in a shoplifting case. The case was that of Keiko Shiokawa, a shoplifter at a supermarket. Keiko had a previous conviction for shoplifting, and the crime was committed while she was on probation. Keiko's husband, Takuma (Takuma), was working alone, leaving Keiko alone to raise their daughter, Hotaru, and care for her mother-in-law. She suffers from kleptomania, which causes her to shoplift to escape the stress and mild depression she originally suffered from. Keiko's lawyer Tsutsumi (Tsutsumi) wants another suspended sentence so that Keiko can focus on her kleptomania treatment. The prosecution, on the other hand, argued that a sentence of one year and four months in prison was appropriate because of the possibility of a second offense.
At the trial, Keiko said that she felt she had caused trouble for her daughter and that she would continue to treat her kleptomania and depression, but since Keiko's situation had not changed even after the trial, Keiko herself was not confident that she would not reoffend. In the midst of all this, a voice from the hearing room said, "Go for it, Mom! was heard from the audience. Hotaru was there. Hotaru had taken a day off from school and secretly came to watch Keiko's trial. Hotaru said, "Mama will be fine! Hotaru can go to the school! Hotaru is here, so I'll be fine!" She shouted, "I'm okay because Hotaru is here!
After the trial, Keiko saw Hotaru's figure and said to Takuma, "Raising children and caring for them is hard. I want you to help me. Takuma was also moved by Hotaru's concern for Keiko to the point of coming to court alone, saying, "I'm sorry for forcing you to work so hard until now," and began to show understanding for Keiko's kleptomania.
Meanwhile, Sakama was also unsure about the sentence. As a repeat offender on probation, Keiko should be sentenced to prison. However, he does not think it is right for her to be separated from Hotaru. However, it would also be unequal to give her a lighter sentence because she has a child. After much hesitation, Sakama held the trial once more.
Sakama asked Keiko, "What do you think about your daughter coming to court?" Keiko replied, "I am so concerned about my daughter's presence in court. Keiko replied, "I felt that I had worried about my daughter that much. From now on, I want to tell people around me about my limitations and do my best in treatment," she replied with strong determination. Feeling Keiko's unwavering will, Sakama imposed a suspended sentence. Since it was not a prison sentence, Keiko could live her life without being separated from Hotaru.
After the trial, Sakama saw the Ushiohawa family laughing together and still wondered if this verdict was good for the Ushiohawa family, although there is no right answer to the verdict.

Yanagida, a juror in the lay judge trial

A criminal case has been decided to be tried by a judge. In this chapter, the main character is Noriichi YANAGIDA, one of the lay judges, instead of Sakama.
One day, Yanagida is suddenly chosen as a juror for a lay judge trial.
The outline of the case is that the defendant, Shuji OGISHIMA, was indicted after he had a fistfight with the victim, Kiyoshi TSUUI, at a park and caused their deaths.
At a convenience store on the way to the park, Kokishima met Tsunoi, who was littering. When Kokishima gave him a warning, he had an argument and left the place. When Kokishima arrived at the park, Tsunoi chased him. Tsunoi was angry at the warning and told Kokishima, "I'm here to fight with you." Kokishima moved to the field of the park and was beaten by Tsunoi. Tsunoi's fist went into Kokishima's eyeballs, and Kokishima beat back blindly. The shot went into Tsunoi's face and Tsunoi collapsed. Kokishima was worried about Tsunoi, but when Tsunoi shook his hand saying "go away," he left the place.
However, a man named Kazuaki Kawashima Takuya, who was watching the fight between the two, became suspicious of Tsunoi's inability to get up and called an ambulance. Two weeks later, he developed an acute subdural hematoma and died.
Counsel had pleaded not guilty, while prosecutors had argued that innocence was not appropriate and that there should be punishment.
After many discussions, the decision by Yanagita and others was not guilty. There is no solid evidence or conviction that Ogishima' intentionally injured Tsunoi', so the decision was not guilty.
Having experienced being a juror, Yanagida felt that it was very important to judge people, but it was interesting to discuss the truth of the case and the defendant.

Iruma's Past and the Trial of Violent Teachers

Iruma is a former criminal defense lawyer. However, winning the acquittal of a client involved in a false accusation case does not mean that the client's life can be restored. From that moment on, Iruma felt helpless.
One day, he was assigned to defend a client who had run over a high school boy with his car while ignoring a red light. The client insisted that he had never run a red light. Iruma believed him and gathered evidence and approvals again, but the court did not even look at the evidence Iruma had worked so hard to gather, saying, "We dismiss the case because we cannot recognize the necessity. As a result, the client was found guilty.
This made Iruma despair that nothing would change no matter how hard he tried, and he decided to take a break from practicing law for a while.
At that time, his sister asked him to go to a doujinshi because there was a book she really wanted but could not go. Iruma, who had no time to spare, went to the doujin sokai instead.

At one corner of the dojin sokutai, Komazawa was offering a book of his own creation. Komazawa was selling a book titled "Introduction to Litigation Conduct for Judges," which caught Iruma's attention. Iruma looked through the book and found that it was written in a manner similar to his own philosophy.
Iruma deeply sympathized with this book and told Komazawa, "This book is very wonderful. Komazawa also knew Iruma and approached him, saying, "Iruma-sensei, I would be happy if someone like you who knows how it feels to be unreasonable or in a weak position becomes a judge.
Iruma took these words to heart and began his career as a judge.

Komazawa, Iruma, and Sakama were assigned to the trial of a certain criminal case.
Kohei Sarashina, a teacher at Tokyo Metropolitan Samidare High School, is accused of injuring a male student, Yuki Sudo.
Sudo had always been dissatisfied with Sarashina and was planning to remove him as homeroom teacher. He was making a lot of noise in class and disrupting the class. Sarashina, annoyed by this, pulls him by the arm and takes him out into the hallway to take him to the student guidance office. At that time, Soudou resisted. When Sarashina let go of his arm, Soudou fell down with too much momentum. He suffered an injury on his hand that would take three weeks to heal.
A friend of Soudou's took a video of the incident and posted it on a social networking service without permission, and the video even spread. As a result, Sarashina attracted media attention and was instantly labeled a violent teacher.

Although Sodo believes that he was the one who made a fuss to disrupt the class and that his injuries were merely caused by an accident, the media and his parents were quick to denounce Sarashina as a violent teacher. The media and parents were quick to denounce Sarashina as a violent teacher. His friend who uploaded the video on SNS without his permission also shows no remorse, and Sodo is trapped in a corner, unable to tell the truth.

On the day of the trial, Soudou, who had been told by his parents not to tell anyone that he had interfered with the class, testified as discussed with his lawyer. As the trial was about to end, Sakama and Soudou's eyes met. Sakama sensed that Soudou was looking for something to say and asked, "Do you have anything you want to say to the court?" Sakama asked him.
After hearing the formalities, and with the trial about to end, this was the first time Sakama had bothered to sense the defendant's state of mind and ask him a question. It was precisely because he had seen Iruma and his colleagues "listen to the defendant properly" in the trial that these words came out of Sakama's mouth.
Soudou gathered his courage and tearfully explained that the teacher was not to blame, that he was the one who had interfered with the class, and that the injury to his hand was an accident. After hearing the truth from Soudou, the three sentenced Sarashina to a fine of 100,000 yen. Subsequently, Sodo apologized to Sarashina and they made peace.

Sakama was again responding to questions and answers from junior high school students who had come to observe the trial.
One of the junior high school students asked, "Aren't you afraid of being a judge? Judging people..." He was asked. Sakama replied, "It's not so much fear, but the tension of influencing people's lives. The work of a judge does not bring about innovation, nor does it create one from zero. Even so, the job of a judge is interesting," he answered with a laugh.

Characters in "Ichikei no Karasu"

Key person

Shinpei Sakama (Shimpei played by Haru Kuroki)

Sakama is said to have a bird's face in Iruma due to its high nose.

The protagonist of this work. He is an assistant special judge assigned to Ichikei. She has an older sister, but she has been pushed around since she was a child and does not want to get involved with her.
In the live-action drama version, her name is changed to "Sakama Chizuru" (坂間千鶴).

She is a judge who is quite detached from her job as a judge, saying, "A judge only passes judgment, and there is no end to what happens to the defendant's life afterwards.
When he was first assigned to ICHIKEI, he was also very much aware of Iruma's and Komazawa's advice to "thoroughly listen to the defendant's story, sometimes visiting the scene of the crime to verify it, and to think about the defendant's life afterwards. They also consider the defendant's life afterwards when passing judgment." He feels that "I agree that they are trying to avoid false convictions, but they are inefficient.

In the Tabata case, Sakama, together with the defense attorney and the prosecution, was asked to reenact the actual crime scene. Sakama opposes the idea, feeling that it is meaningless. However, Iruma told him that "there are some things you can't understand unless you actually go there," so he reluctantly went along.
He visited the actual crime scene and conducted a series of investigations in a pitch-dark bathroom. The result was that "even in a pitch-dark bathroom, you can see the other person's face. Sakama, on the other hand, thought, "I knew it was just as the victim had testified, and it was a waste of time.
Subsequently, a guilty verdict was rendered against Tabata. Public opinion, however, was not favorable, with some saying, "Would such a famous writer commit a crime? He was falsely accused," and so on. Sakama learned of this through SNS and the mass media, and said, "I understand that Komazawa and Iruma are trying to avoid false accusations. However, no matter how much they examine the case and consider the verdict, the public will not understand it," he complained. Also, when Tabata accepted the verdict and did not appeal, Sakama asked, "Did he admit it because he really did it? Or did the court just give up and say they wouldn't take it up?" The question remained unanswered.

One day, Sakama decided to observe the criminal trial of Ohki, a homeless man whom Iruma was in charge of.
To the defendant, who had given up and was asking for a quick conviction, Iruma said, "In your mind, wouldn't it be better if you let your wife live a little longer?" He said the words. Sakama was surprised that a judge would say something that would appeal to the defendant's heart. Iruma then sat with the defendant, listened to the arguments of the prosecution and the defense, and delivered his verdict on the same day.
And the sentence Iruma issued was "a fine of 200,000 yen. In response, Sakama told Iruma, "If it were me, I would put the defendant on probation again and convict him. Iruma said, "The defendant is homeless and has a criminal record. It would be difficult for him to live without committing another crime. Even with probation, if he commits a crime, he will be sentenced to prison, and if that happens, he will be in and out of prison all over again. Sakama retorted, "It's no use thinking that far, the job of a judge is to pass judgment. Iruma replied, "Yes, but... don't you wonder what we did? Is it only the defendant's fault that he can't live without committing a crime?" asks Sakama. Sakama could not answer because what Iruma was saying was most likely true.

Later, Sakama is assigned to Keiko's trial alone. Keiko has a husband and a child, but she committed a second crime while on probation for shoplifting. This was due to Keiko's kleptomania, a disease, but Sakama was unsure about Keiko's sentence.
A repeat offender on probation is often convicted to a prison sentence. However, a prison sentence for Keiko would separate parent and child.
At that time, Hotaru took a day off from school without telling her parents and came to the trial alone. Seeing her, Sakama feels even more strongly that mother and child should not be separated.
Sakama boldly decides to hold the trial again and hear Keiko's story. Keiko was struck by the fact that Hotaru had come to the court alone, and she wanted to "seriously change herself. When Sakama asked Keiko about her future, Keiko said with strong determination, "I will treat kleptomania. I will never let my daughter come to court again," she declared. Believing her words, Sakama again imposed a suspended sentence. Keiko was relieved with tears in her eyes and hugged Hotaru outside the courthouse. Watching her, Sakama was bothered by the verdict for the first time, wondering if this verdict was good for this father and daughter.

As Sakama watched Komazawa and Iruma's trial style, he gradually came to feel that "the judge's job is to pass judgment, but there is life for the defendant even after the trial is over.
This idea came out strongly during the trial of a high school teacher who was arrested on suspicion of assault. The facts of the case had already been clarified at the trial, and the testimony of the high school boy, Soudou, who was alleged to have been assaulted, had been completed without problems. It was then that Sakama and Soudou's eyes met. As Soudou looked like he wanted to say something, Sakama asked him, "Do you have anything you want to say to the court?" Sakama asked him, "Do you have anything you want to say to the court? Up until now, Sakama would have sought efficiency, saying, "Let's finish the trial in time. However, influenced by Iruma and his colleagues, he decided to "listen to what the witnesses have to say, rather than just taking his time," which is why he said what he did.
In this way, as Sakama worked with Iruma and his colleagues as a judge, he became close to the defendant's life as a judge and came to think of the job of a judge as "an interesting job to think about the defendant's life and make a decision.

Michio Iruma (played by Yutaka Takenouchi)

Irima is characterized by her black hair and Shichi-san (three and-three-tenths), and her glasses are slightly fat.

A 38-year-old former lawyer and mid-level judge. He is characterized by his glasses and fat figure. Local souvenirs and sweets are scattered on his desk. When he walks, his feet make a heavy "boshi" sound.
An attorney who passed the bar examination at the age of 24 and was in charge of defending criminal cases. When he was an attorney, he had been found not guilty in more than a dozen cases. However, even if he is found not guilty, his client loses social trust when he is indicted. Both his company and his family suspect that he may have committed a crime, and even after he is found not guilty, his life does not return. On the other hand, Iruma comes to feel,' What is the purpose of trials?' and' What do lawyers fight for?' He becomes acutely aware of his helplessness in the case with Amamiya, and finally takes a break from his legal activities.
When I returned to my parents' home and had a lot of free time on my hands, my younger sister told me, "There is a book that I want, so please go and buy it at the Dojin-Sokubai." When I went to the venue, I met Komazawa, a judge who was selling "Introduction to Conduct of Cases for Judges" at her own expense. She aimed to become a judge because she deeply sympathized with the book that Komazawa was selling, and Komazawa said, "People like you who know the feelings of people in a weak position and unreasonable things are suitable for judges."
After that, he was recommended by a bar association or passed a difficult interview with the Supreme Court, and became a judge instead of a lawyer.
Even after he became a judge, he continued to follow the same style as when he was an attorney: "Listen to the accused thoroughly, and sometimes go to the scene to see the testimony and evidence." At first, he had a conflict with Sakama, who wanted to be more efficient, but Sakama gradually grew up and started to face the trial with the same attitude as Iruma. He was impressed by his attitude and Sakama admitted that he became a full-fledged judge.

Work-related

Yoshio Komazawa (played by Fumiyo Kohinata)

Komazawa with a calm face.

A 62-year-old senior judge with a calm personality and calm judgment. His hobby is playing smartphone games for free.
He is an unconventional judge who listens carefully to the defendant, examines the evidence, and in some cases visits the scene of the case to find out the truth. Since coming to Ichikei, he has been found not guilty in more than 10 cases, but because of this, he has been shunned from above and is still a judge at the scene.
Most of all, he dislikes false charges, and even if he is looked down upon by those around him, he carefully considers each trial and makes a decision.
"Introduction to Conduct of Cases for Judges," in which he wrote his conviction, was prepared at his own expense and sold for 1,000 yen per book at the Dojin-Sokubai. There, he happened to meet Iruma, and told Iruma, who had known him for a long time, that "a person like you is suitable for a judge." When Sakama asked him, "How do you make many acquittals?", he also sold this booklet.

Bunta ISHIKURA (played by Mackenyu NITTA)

tw-2948897452
tw-2948897452
@tw-2948897452

Contents