Black Butler] A summary of the foreshadowing of the Ciel twins theory! For fans of the original work

This is a compilation of dialogues and scenes that seem to foreshadow the twin theory from the first volume of the original work to the latest episode. There are major spoilers, so please be careful. For fans of the original work. Note that the original story and the anime (1st and 2nd seasons) have different stories and settings. Please read to the end!

Contents

If Ciel is Boy, what is Boy's real name?
Since "Ciel" seems to mean "sky" in French, could it be a counterpart of "Mer (sea)" or "Ter (earth)," or "Astor (star)" or "Etoile (star)" in connection with the sky?

However, at the end of the story, there is a monologue saying, "Until the day the lie turns into the truth", so it might be possible that the story ends without revealing the real name of the young master.

There's more.
"What happened to Ciel and the little boy that day of the Sebus summons?"
"Why did he decide to call himself Ciel?"
"Who other than Tanaka is aware of the turnover?"
"Why doesn't anyone talk about his younger brother?"
"What happened in the two years between the recollections of the 61st and 63rd episodes and the blank space at the beginning of the main story?"
"Are you really the second son?"
And many other mysteries remain.

Contradictions? Or new plots?

Vol. 2, 5:7, "The master of our house, Sir Juan Tom Herr, is the Earl of Yves, the 12-year-old ruler of a vast estate."
Only once in the story is a scene in which Sebastian calls Botchan "Ciel." (* It's narration-like, but if you read the pages before and after, you'll know it's a monologue of Sebastian.) Sebastian can't lie because of the contract with Botchan. Is it safe because it's not mentioned, or is it a mistake at the beginning of the series?
1 volume 2 episodes 57 pages
As for his fiancé Elizabeth, the young master says, "I didn't want to be a different person. I was made to be a fiancé." Since the young master lives as a "ciel" of his own volition, does it feel a bit strange to say, "I was made to be a fiancé of my own volition"?
"Take care of each soul," the profound lines of the 6-volume, 24 episode and 8-volume, 35 episode undertakers.
Is this a foreshadowing of the twin theory or just a piece of advice?
18 volumes, 87 episodes
"If you are not so prepared to offer your soul for your own wish, the devil (us) will not cry out." ". omae" => deep communication between Sebastian and Botchan. What did Botchan start to say?
* 枢先's tweet on August 20, 2017 turned out to be of no particular significance.

About anime (first and second period, "Book of ~" series)

First of all, the media mix (anime adaptation) of Black Butler, as the original author 枢先 Sei and the editor in charge Kuma himself say, is extremely irregular and has a complicated composition that is very difficult to understand for anime-only fans. I think it's better to separate the first and second terms as events in a parallel world that is different from the original. If you are interested in the twin theory, I recommend that you read the original first, and then watch the Book of ~ series that is faithful to the original.
The first period (08): The original episodes of the first to fifth volumes are traced, and the rest are original episodes of anime. There are a lot of anime characters that do not appear in the original. There is no foreshadowing on the twin theory.
Term 2 (10 years): Original complete anime. It may be better to think of it as a completely parallel world that is completely different from the original. Of course, there is no foreshadowing on the twin theory.
Book of Circus (14): A faithful, animated adaptation of the original episode (commonly known as the circus version). (* Note that the first and second periods are not connected.) The plot of the twin theory is also reproduced. Many people may have noticed the twin theory in the recollection of Kelvin in the anime.
OVA Book of Muder (14): A faithful animated adaptation of the original episode (commonly known as "The Holmes"). There is little to say about the twin theory.
Book of the Atlantic Atlantic (17): A nearly faithful animated adaptation of the original episode (The Cruise), in which Lizzy and Sebastian recollected the four graves of the van Tom Herr Eve family (four for the Vincent-Rachel twins), even though there was more than one cut in the dark about the twin theory.

By the way, what are the views of overseas fans?

(* The following is a story before the twin theory was confirmed.)
Black Butler is also very popular abroad, with anime being broadcast in Europe and the United States, comic books being released in various languages, and winning anime awards in German and French. Then, do foreign fans know about this twin theory?
In conclusion, I know. There are various names such as Two Ciel Theroy and Twin Theory, but my personal impression is that there are more deniers. The dual personality theory is more popular. This is because the method of blurring the singular, which is part of the hidden line, is not possible in major foreign languages such as English. For example, in Japanese, you can blur the singular, such as "the body of a child" or "my child" without any discomfort, but in English, you can only blur the singular, either "the bodies of the children" or "my children" (all in the plural) or "the body of the child" or "my child" (all in the singular). Especially in the early days, the translator could not have known about the twin theory, and the translation was based on the assumption that Botchan was an only child, so basically the lines that seem to be hidden lines in foreign translations are mostly in the singular. Because of this, there are many opinions among foreign (European and American) fans that "Ciel is an absolute only child" and "Now that he is a twin, it is a late development".
The magic of 枢先 students' ingenious language. We Japanese can understand it with an "Oh!", but on the other hand, foreign fans seem to have a hard time understanding it because they are blocked by the wall of translation. It's a bit disappointing.

IN FACT, IT'S BEEN AROUND FOR A LONG TIME. WHAT IS THE "SIEL MASTERMIND THEORY"?

The "Ciel Mastermind Theory" has been a topic of conversation since the time the Ciel twin theory first surfaced.
In the 19th episode, Juan Tom Herr looks back on the day the Eve family was attacked.
・ The shadow of the person who stabbed Mr. Tanaka from behind is slightly small.
・ In the first place, Mr. Tanaka, who is a master of swordplay and has high fighting power even though he is old, was stabbed with almost no resistance.
- Leaving the profound words, "You (Master) are too cruel!"
- Facing the criminal and saying "I didn't see the criminal" in the recollection of the 62nd episode even though I saw the criminal's face.
- You survived even though you were stabbed from behind (Did you not have enough strength to stab deeply?)
Based on these facts, it has become possible that Ciel was the perpetrator of the attack. A few years ago, it would have been possible to laugh at Ciel saying, "Of course, there is no such thing, is there?" However, looking at the scary side of Ciel shown in the special bonus comic "That Butler, The Nurse" and the events after the 125th episode, you may not be able to say that it is absolutely impossible.

Source: pbs.twimg.com

WHAT DOES THIS EXPRESSION PLUS THE LINES MEAN?

At that time, when he was seven years old, he had this expression of absolute zero and a profound remark. Even that Vincent, who had been trained to fight 100 battles, was overpowered for a moment by his beloved son, Hyohen, and he unconsciously withdrew his hand that was trying to stroke Ciel.

THE BOY'S "LIES" HAVE FINALLY BEEN REVEALED. WHAT WILL BECOME OF THEM?

So far, I have listed all the parts that seem to be the foreline from the first episode to the 26th volume where the twin theory was confirmed.
How was it, everyone?
I really admire the imagination of the author, Mr. Yana Toboso, who has continued to plot such a clever and complicated plot from the beginning!

References

ameblo.jp

shiann666.blog.fc2.com

tokinokanata2288.blog.fc2.com

go-1126699686594383289821
go-1126699686594383289821
@go-1126699686594383289821

Related Articles

Spoilers and discussion of Black Butler (Cardinal Yana)

Spoilers and discussion of Black Butler (Cardinal Yana)

Kuroshitsuji" is a manga series written by Yana Cardinal and serialized in Monthly G-Fantasy. It is a dark fantasy in which Ciel Phantomhive, a young lord of the prestigious noble Phantomhive Countess family in late 19th century England, and his butler Sebastian Michaelis, a demon contracted with Ciel, try to find out the truth while getting involved in incidents such as Ciel's past and a request from the Queen of England. An animated film "The Luxury Liner Arc" is scheduled to be screened in 2017.

Read Article

A collection of too beautiful crayons drawn by the creator of "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler) [Studio Ghibli].

A collection of too beautiful crayons drawn by the creator of "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler) [Studio Ghibli].

The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana TODO, has created a collection of illustrations that are too beautiful to be called "doodles", which she drew during her work. The illustrations were mainly shown on "Tsunabiy" and became a topic of conversation because they were so good even though they were "doodles". There are many illustrations of his own characters for practice and illustrations of "Sword Dance," "Anna and the Snow Queen," "Studio Ghibli," and many others that we have all seen before.

Read Article

Kiseki's Generation] A compilation of beautiful illustrations of "Captain Levi" and other manga by the creator of "Black Butler" [Kiseki no Generation] [Marching Giants].

Kiseki's Generation] A compilation of beautiful illustrations of "Captain Levi" and other manga by the creator of "Black Butler" [Kiseki no Generation] [Marching Giants].

Illustrations of other manga drawn by Yana TODO, the creator of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler), were compiled. His illustrations of "Kuroko no Basketball" became a topic of conversation for their beauty, and he also drew illustrations of "Shinkou no Kyojin," "Durarara! Inazuma Eleven," "Fate/Zero," "Gintama," "Persona 4," "Valvrave," and many other characters are shown on her blog.

Read Article

[Sword Dance] "Black Butler" author's beautiful rakugo compilation [Twisted Wonderland].

[Sword Dance] "Black Butler" author's beautiful rakugo compilation [Twisted Wonderland].

The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana Tobori, has compiled a collection of "practice illustrations" and "doodles" that she drew in her spare time between jobs, which she showed on Twitter and which have become the talk of the town for their beautiful illustrations. She draws rough sketches and settings of her precious works, her own characters drawn for her fans, "FGO," "Hiroaka," "Tourabu (sword dance)," "Twisted Wonderland," and many others.

Read Article

Kuroko no Basketball" illustrations drawn by "Kuroshitsuji" artist Yana Kuru are super cool!

Kuroko no Basketball" illustrations drawn by "Kuroshitsuji" artist Yana Kuru are super cool!

Here we present an illustration of "Kuroko no Basketball" drawn by Yana Kuru, known for the manga "Black Butler" and the game "Twisted Wonderland. This fan art, published on her blog, depicts the main character and other members of "Kiseki's Generation. The black bus characters, drawn with the beautiful touch that only Yana Tsurumi can create, became a topic of conversation on the Internet.

Read Article

Contents