This is a compilation of dialogues and scenes that seem to foreshadow the twin theory from the first volume of the original work to the latest episode. There are major spoilers, so please be careful. For fans of the original work. Note that the original story and the anime (1st and 2nd seasons) have different stories and settings. Please read to the end!
8 volumes (circus version)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Bochan's Recollection of "That Day" ②
"You are now out of the cage,"
34 episodes
"My name is Ciel Juan, Tom Herr Eve, and that's the only one."
-> A botchan who insists on his name and Sebastian who looks at the botchan in a meaningful way (* According to the recollection of the luxury cruise described later, Sebastian probably knows from the beginning that the real name of botchan is not' Ciel').
The boy in the cage. Recollection of "that day" from the point of view
-> At the end of the line of sight, the ciel (divided to the right, with a bruise on the left eye) has been knocked down on the table and is desperately reaching out to the young master, but on the next page, he has been stabbed in the stomach to his heart's content.
"Please, please, somebody, anybody, anybody, anything, help us."
-> plural form (meaning' me and ciel')
"You are out of the cage now."
-> In other words, at the time of summoning Sebastian, Botchan was' in a cage' (it was his older brother Ciel who was inevitably stabbed on the stand).
35 episodes
"Is it all a lie?" "Yes, my name is Ciel Juan Tom Herr Eve."
→ "My name is Ciel ~" is also a lie.
36 episodes
"The devil is mine."
-> The young boy who seems to have just summoned Sebastian (three buttons closed, no blood on the shirt, contract mark on the right eye).
37 episodes
There is no trace of stab wound on the boy's stomach (there is no setting that Sebastian has the ability to cure, so it was not the boy but Ciel who was stabbed in the stomach on that day).
9 volumes (Yugijo Satsujin Jiken hen)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Botchan's Childhood Recollections
"Younger brother."
40 episodes
Bochan no Kaiso
-> The one who snuck into my parents' room was a young master (* The division of the bangs was reversed in this book, but it was corrected in the comic version).
"Younger brother."
-> He is treated as a younger brother by Arthur and remembers his older brother Ciel.
10 volumes (Yugijo Satsujin Jiken hen)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Bochan's Recollection of "That Day" ③
44 episodes
"Anyone was fine at that time" is a frame of Bo-chan's recollection. From the viewpoint of Bo-chan who was in the cage, the devil Sebastian is in front of you. It seems that Bo-chan was in the cage when Sebastian was summoned.
11 volumes (Yugi Castle Murder Case)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
What do you mean by "lie"?
50 episodes
"If you lie, it becomes the truth. The end is all you have to swallow."
→ Lie = Botchan's identity, in other words, Botchan's determination to live and die as a "ciel" without disclosing the truth to anyone.
12 volumes (deluxe passenger boat edition)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Bochan's Recollection of "That Day" ④
"Ciel is no longer here,"
53 episodes
"It's a cake with strawberries on top, which Ciel likes."
-> The favorite cake of the twins is different. Lizzy thinks that the boy is a ciel, so she chose a strawberry cake for his favorite cake, but the cake that the boy actually likes is gateau chocolate (* see Chapter 63).
54 chapters
"I'LL PROTECT YOU, NO MATTER WHAT!"
→ Does it mean that you are Ciel's fiancee, so you will protect her instead of Ciel? Or does it mean that you couldn't protect Ciel, but this time you will protect only Lizzy?
Botchan's Recollection of "That Day"
-> The child in the cage is a young boy, a ciel (with a bruise on his left eye and only one button on the top closed) who is taken by an adult in front of him, and a young boy who reaches out from the cage (without a bruise and with three buttons closed).
"No, it's the same. I'm out of the cage."
In other words, "that day" was in a cage.
"Ciel is no longer here,"
The real Ciel died "that day."
"I am Juan, Tom Herr, Count Yves." "I am me, I am."
=> A young boy whose memory is confused
The child (Ciel) who was stabbed to death in the stomach has a bruise on the left eye, while the boy on the next page (with the contract mark on his eye) does not have a bruise on the same place, and moreover, there is no blood on his shirt.
"That day." It was Ciel who was stabbed to death.
The ring of the family head is in the palm of the blood-stained young master.
-> Probably from the body of a dead Ciel.
56 episodes
Lizzy looking anxiously at the coughing boy
-> In episode 66, Lizzy recalls this scene, so there seems to have been something that caught her. (Has she started to realize the identity of the young master?)
57 episodes
"BUT IF YOU COOL YOUR BODY, YOU'LL COUGH AGAIN." "DO N'T TALK ABOUT IT NOW!"
-> When I talked about asthma, there was a possibility that Lizzie might find out that I was actually a sickly younger brother instead of Ciel, so I stopped talking to Sebastian (* Since there was a young Lizzie in the reminiscence of Bocchan in Chapter 28, Lizzie surely knows the twin younger brother (Bocchan) and knows that he had asthma).
13 volumes (luxury cruise ship edition)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
"THAT DAY" FROM SEBASTIAN'S POINT OF VIEW
"What's your name?"
58 episodes
Lizzy's Recollection
-> Vincent Rachel Ciel who is happily married in the garden. The young master was probably unable to go out due to asthma and was inside the house.
"That's all for today."
-> It is Ciel who is trained in fencing by Francis.
-> It is hidden by the balloon, but there is a young boy sitting opposite Lizzy (* see episode 131).
"I'm glad Lizzy will be my wife."
→ Ciel's comment
-> By the way, it is nicknamed "Lizzy".
"I can't believe it! It's really a shell." "."
-> A young boy who can't answer questions and returns silently.
"Hello, Elizabeth."
-> He calls himself' Elizabeth' instead of his nickname' Lizzy.'
→ The sickly young master was not familiar with Lizzy and did not call him by his nickname like Ciel.
-> Lizzy opens her eyes wide on the next frame (does she feel uncomfortable calling her "Elizabeth"?)
"When Ciel came back, he was thinner and smaller than me,"
-> It is not that Lizzy grew taller, but the sickly boy was a bit shorter than Ciel?
"I'm a scary girl who doesn't like Ciel, ~~」「? What is that!" "You said that a strong daughter-in-law was no good, ~~!」「. that's an old story."
→ The person who actually said it was Ciel, not Botchan, so I don't remember Botchan.
現在、黒執事読み返し祭り開催中なんですが、シエル双子説を念頭に読み返すと、ほんと細かい節々にそのヒントが隠されててめっちゃおもしろい✨
— ソラマメ🐾 (@soramame_320) February 19, 2017
ほら、このシーンなんか、シエルと呼ばれてる倒れこんでる男の子の他にエリザベスと一緒に座ってる子どもっぽい足が描かれてるの!! pic.twitter.com/KYoild2abn
Source: pbs.twimg.com
Little feet under the callout
* Refer to chapter 130.
61 episodes
"What's your name?" "My name is. Ciel Ciel Juan Tom Herr Eve."
-> There is a pause before you say your name. There is no bruise on the left eye, no blood on the shirt (that is, the young master is not stabbed)
Frame to the left of "Watashi na wa."
-> It is somewhat difficult to see, but there is a body of Ciel on the table.
"Heh heh. it's all right."
-> Sebus has already seen through Botchan's "lie".
62 episodes
"You've made a great sacrifice." "I've received a lot of money from you."
→ Sacrifice = Watari = Death of Shiel (* Probably at the time of summoning, Sebastian' ate' Shiel's soul)
"I WANT POWER. THE POWER TO TAKE REVENGE ON THOSE WHO HAVE TREATED US LIKE THIS!"
-> plural form (meaning' me and ciel')
The ring of the family head in the blood-stained palm (* refer to the cinematic record of Cebus in Episode 10)
-> When it was published in a magazine, it was a frame of Ciel with a ring on his palm, but in a single volume, it is a ring covered with blood. If he took the trouble to rewrite one frame, is the ring an important foreshadowing?
"This time. I will never lose, Juan Tom Herr, the head of the Eve family, Ciel Juan Tom Herr, as Eve. Never!" "You tell me not to lie, but you are very much a liar."
-> "Lie" refers to the part of "as Ciel Juan Tom Herr Eve."
"I haven't been out much."
=> Botchan is the child of the person who was weak.
Reunited with Tanaka at the hospital, Tanaka calls the returned child "Botchan"
Perhaps Tanaka immediately recognized that this child was not Ciel but his younger brother, Botchan?
It is hard to see because it is hidden by the balloon, but there are 4 brand-new graves.
-> From left to right, the graves of Bocchan, Vincent, Rachel, and Ciel
-> Because Botchan came back as' Shiel,' the grave of' Shiel' was later removed (refer to Chapter 8).
Bathing scene
=> There is no trace of stab wound on the boy's stomach = It was Ciel who was stabbed.
映画でもがっつり「4つ」あったファントムハイヴ一家のお墓。漫画では両端のお墓が見切れてるから気づきにくいかも?
— 釦@黒執事考察垢 (@cielfutagosetsu) February 26, 2017
因みに坊ちゃん・ヴィンセント・レイチェル・シエルの順で並んでる。左端の墓石には坊ちゃんの本名が書いてあると思われます。 pic.twitter.com/wNeiPmd4h0
The grave on the far left is Botchan's.
14 volumes (deluxe passenger boat edition)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Cebus Cinematic Records continued
"What happened to you in that month?"
Related Articles
Spoilers and discussion of Black Butler (Cardinal Yana)
Kuroshitsuji" is a manga series written by Yana Cardinal and serialized in Monthly G-Fantasy. It is a dark fantasy in which Ciel Phantomhive, a young lord of the prestigious noble Phantomhive Countess family in late 19th century England, and his butler Sebastian Michaelis, a demon contracted with Ciel, try to find out the truth while getting involved in incidents such as Ciel's past and a request from the Queen of England. An animated film "The Luxury Liner Arc" is scheduled to be screened in 2017.
Read Article
April 2024 Spring Anime (First Semester Anime) Summary
This is an alphabetical list of spring anime that will start airing in April 2024.The April 2024 spring anime lineup includes many hot new anime and sequels to popular series. Information such as anime titles, broadcast information, cast voice actors and staffs are compiled in an easy-to-understand format.
Read Article
This is a list of live-action films that are too terrible.
I collected live action that was too much.
Read Article
Beautiful original drawings of Sebastian and Ciel from "Black Butler".
If you are a big fan of the gothic and aesthetic world of "Black Butler," you will be hooked first. This is a beautiful shot drawn by the original author, Yana Cardinal.
Read Article
The quality of the "Black Butler (Circus version)" dolls is so high, their destructive power is amazing!
Black Butler" continues to be very popular, and due to its popularity, various manufacturers have released dolls of Ciel and Sebastian, but this time a doll of great quality is being released. This high quality doll is a must-see.
Read Article
A collection of too beautiful crayons drawn by the creator of "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler) [Studio Ghibli].
The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana TODO, has created a collection of illustrations that are too beautiful to be called "doodles", which she drew during her work. The illustrations were mainly shown on "Tsunabiy" and became a topic of conversation because they were so good even though they were "doodles". There are many illustrations of his own characters for practice and illustrations of "Sword Dance," "Anna and the Snow Queen," "Studio Ghibli," and many others that we have all seen before.
Read Article
Black Butler's characters ranked in order of popularity!
The ranking of characters with various personalities, such as Grell the Grim Reaper and Sebastian the servant, who appear in the popular manga "Black Butler" by Yana Toboso, is introduced. The ranking is based on the first-ever character popularity poll, and includes the number of votes received by the fans for each character.
Read Article
Kiseki's Generation] A compilation of beautiful illustrations of "Captain Levi" and other manga by the creator of "Black Butler" [Kiseki no Generation] [Marching Giants].
Illustrations of other manga drawn by Yana TODO, the creator of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler), were compiled. His illustrations of "Kuroko no Basketball" became a topic of conversation for their beauty, and he also drew illustrations of "Shinkou no Kyojin," "Durarara! Inazuma Eleven," "Fate/Zero," "Gintama," "Persona 4," "Valvrave," and many other characters are shown on her blog.
Read Article
[Sword Dance] "Black Butler" author's beautiful rakugo compilation [Twisted Wonderland].
The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana Tobori, has compiled a collection of "practice illustrations" and "doodles" that she drew in her spare time between jobs, which she showed on Twitter and which have become the talk of the town for their beautiful illustrations. She draws rough sketches and settings of her precious works, her own characters drawn for her fans, "FGO," "Hiroaka," "Tourabu (sword dance)," "Twisted Wonderland," and many others.
Read Article
Summary of foreshadowing and discussion of Black Butler (Black Butler)
Kuroshitsuji" is a dark fantasy manga series by Yana Toboso. It was adapted into anime in 2008, 2010, and 2014, a stage version in 2009, and a live-action movie in 2014 starring Ayame Tsuyoshi and Hiro Mizushima. Here we will discuss the foreshadowing and discussion of one of the main characters, Ciel Phantomhive, the boy who is the current head of the Phantomhive Countess family.
Read Article
Kuroko no Basketball" illustrations drawn by "Kuroshitsuji" artist Yana Kuru are super cool!
Here we present an illustration of "Kuroko no Basketball" drawn by Yana Kuru, known for the manga "Black Butler" and the game "Twisted Wonderland. This fan art, published on her blog, depicts the main character and other members of "Kiseki's Generation. The black bus characters, drawn with the beautiful touch that only Yana Tsurumi can create, became a topic of conversation on the Internet.
Read Article
Fans rejoice at Captain Levi and Armin drawn by "Black Butler" author Yana Kururunobu.
Many fans were excited to see the illustrations of Captain Levi and Armin by Yana Cardinal, the author of the popular dark fantasy manga "Black Butler. The super-beautiful illustrations are one of the quintessential examples.
Read Article
Tags
Contents
- What is the Siel twin theory?
- The original author, 枢先 no comment on the twin theory! BUT?
- Comments of Mr. Kuma in charge of the interview in 2016
- 枢先'S WAY OF LAYING A GROUNDWORK IS AMAZING!
- Outline of the twin theory (volumes 1 to 26)
- Original 1 Volume (The Butler)
- 2 volumes (Red Butler version)
- 3 volumes (Red Butler version)
- 4 volumes (edited by Huang Shuji)
- 7 volumes (circus version)
- 8 volumes (circus version)
- 9 volumes (Yugijo Satsujin Jiken hen)
- 10 volumes (Yugijo Satsujin Jiken hen)
- 11 volumes (Yugi Castle Murder Case)
- 12 volumes (deluxe passenger boat edition)
- 13 volumes (luxury cruise ship edition)
- 14 volumes (deluxe passenger boat edition)
- 15 volumes (dormitory school edition)
- 19 volumes (The Green Witch)
- 20 volumes (Green Witch Edition)
- 21 volumes (The Green Witch)
- 22 volumes (completed version of the Green Witch)
- 23 volumes (edited by Blue Cult)
- 24 volumes (edited by Ao No Kyodan)
- 25 volumes (edited by Blue Cult)
- 26 volumes (edited by Ao-no-kyodan)
- There are a lot of hints on the twin theory! Bonus comic "That butler, nursing"
- Anything else that seems to be a foreshadowing.
- IN FACT, THERE WAS A HIDDEN PLOT IN YOUR BLOG!
- Musical Foreshadowing
- Black Butler's Official Anthology "Rainbow Butler 2" Included Extra Volume "Father and!"
- Knox's Ten Commandments
- Mystery of the twin theory
- Contradictions? Or new plots?
- About anime (first and second period, "Book of ~" series)
- By the way, what are the views of overseas fans?
- IN FACT, IT'S BEEN AROUND FOR A LONG TIME. WHAT IS THE "SIEL MASTERMIND THEORY"?
- THE BOY'S "LIES" HAVE FINALLY BEEN REVEALED. WHAT WILL BECOME OF THEM?
- References
