Black Butler] A summary of the foreshadowing of the Ciel twins theory! For fans of the original work

This is a compilation of dialogues and scenes that seem to foreshadow the twin theory from the first volume of the original work to the latest episode. There are major spoilers, so please be careful. For fans of the original work. Note that the original story and the anime (1st and 2nd seasons) have different stories and settings. Please read to the end!

Contents

109 episodes: "That Butler, Faith"
On the initial color page The sleeping boy is Ciel.
111 episodes: "The Butler, the Thief"
THE GUARDIAN STAR OF THE YOUNG MASTER IS SIRIUS.
-> Sirius is a two binary star (commonly called' twin star' and consists of Sirius A and Sirius B).
113 episodes: "That Butler, Self-Traveling"
The sleeping boy Lizzy is facing is not a young boy, but a Ciel in another room (no patch, no shoes, different background).
Lizzy doesn't want to go home because she knows the truth (the replacement of twins).
114: "The Butler, Assault"
Lizzy snuggled up to Ciel (same attire as last month's issue)
115: "That Butler, Listen"
"SIRIUS-SAMA" IS ACTUALLY CIEL'S.
=> Botchan, Ciel, and Violet. All of them are thought to be type AB.

24 volumes (edited by Ao No Kyodan)

WHAT IS SIRIUS-SAMA REALLY?

What did Lizzy know?

117 episodes "That butler, 丁々"
` But I. I can't go back there alone!'
-> It means that you cannot leave the ciel (the real thing) in the religious organization.
Sirius-sama's room = 108, same as the room where the mortician visited Ciel in his sleep
-> Mr. Sirius is alive in Ciel with the medicine given by the funeral director and the blood collected from the believers?
Last Page
A stuffed rabbit with an eye patch on the bed (the one Lizzy was holding in 33 or 58)
=> You left the stuffed animal that you had cherished for a long time = Does it imply a break with the young master?
118 "The Butler, Redecorated"
Three tier tray that Sebastian has on the door
On the third level, the Bitter Rabbit lying on his back is a young boy (wearing an eye patch).
The first one is Soma and Agni
Lizzy is the Bitter Rabbit with the ribbon on the second level, and the one lying on his stomach next to it is Ciel (the real thing).
Special edition for the 10th anniversary of the series "That butler, lyricism"
Botchan no Omoide
-> The child holding hands with young Lizzy is not a young boy but Ciel.
THE SICKLY BOY COULD N'T JOIN IN, SO HE ALWAYS LOOKED AT THEM FROM A DISTANCE AWAY. (* SEE CHAPTER 132)

25 volumes (edited by Blue Cult)

HE FINALLY WOKE UP?

WHEN HE WOKE UP, WHAT WAS THE FIRST PLACE HE WENT?

123 episodes:' That butler, Myocho'
Pitt's lines
→ It was Ciel who was a mischievous and curious person.
THE REASON WHY THE YOUNG MASTER DID N'T WANT TO SEE HIS OLD FAMILY PHOTO WAS BECAUSE HE DID N'T WANT SOMA TO KNOW HE WAS A TWIN.
124 "The Butler, Transported"
When Violet saw the boy, she looked surprised.
→ Because I mistook it for Sirius-sama (Ciel)
125: "The Butler Returns"
What Agni found in the fireplace cinders were 123 episodes of family photographs that the young master stubbornly refused to show to Soma.
-> I was surprised because I knew that Ciel was a twin.
The man who pointed the muzzle at Soma = Ciel
-> Judging from Soma's reaction, the person was on friendly terms with Soma (I thought he was a young boy when I saw Shiel).
-> Because the soma is slightly crouched down, it is shorter than the soma.
-> Worried that he might have a fever (in the circus story, Botchan had a fever and was taken care of by Soma).
The onja waiting outside looks like a funeral director.
-> At the beginning of the "Blue Cult Edition", it was said that "it is too early to wake up", but Ciel (the perfect Bizarre Records doll using the latest technology?) was finally revived.

26 volumes (edited by Ao-no-kyodan)

THE CLIMAX OF THE STORM!

The twin theory is finally confirmed in this volume.
THE RECOVERY OF TEN YEARS' WORTH OF FORESIGHT BEGINS NOW!

Episode 127, "That Butler, Praise."
Agni!"
→Soma thinks Ciel is a monk, so he reflexively stops Agni who is about to attack Ciel.
→Agni comes back to himself from battle mode at the sound of Soma's voice and is astonished to see the attacker (Ciel) (because he looks just like a boy).
→While he is distracted for a moment, the other attacker (hooded figure) stabs him in the side.

Episode 128 "The Steward, a Testimony"
Soma hits Bo-chan because he thinks one of the attackers (Ciel) is Bo-chan.

He asks, "Who stole the candy from your belly?"
→Immediately after that, we cut to the boy's hand (the ring).
→The candy is probably the ring of the head of the family.
→Ciel swallowed the ring before he was killed, and there is a description that suggests that Bo-chan took it out of Ciel's body after his death (episodes 10, 54, and 62).

The photograph that fell from Soma's palm
→The family photo of the Phantomhive family that Pitt probably brought in episode 124 (showing Bo-chan and Ciel)
→(Episode 127) Agni is depicted handing something to Soma before he shoves Soma into the closet.
→Agni handed it to Soma to tell him the truth, but Soma was too stunned to see it yet.
→So he didn't know about the twins and thought the boy had killed Agni, so he hit him.

Soma said, "You... you haven't lied to me, have you?"
→Did you really eat Ciel's soul that day? meaning "Did you really eat Ciel's soul that day?

"Unfortunately, I do not lie."
→Ciel's soul was definitely sacrificed to the devil that day. In other words, the "Ciel" that came back is most likely a soulless being (i.e., Bizarro Doll).

Episode 129 "The Steward, the Complication
*In conclusion, the twin theory is confirmed!

The "Ciel" who came back is a soul-less being (i.e., a Bizarro Doll).
→Ciel, who has the same face as the little boy, may come to see you.

"The young lady has gone to where she belongs."
→It probably means that Lizzie went to Ciel.

"If the thing you cherish the most suddenly breaks one day..."
→Does this mean that Lizzie found out that the little girl was not Ciel and that this destroyed her love for the little girl that she cherished so much?
→Or that "the most precious thing = Ciel" and that Ciel is now broken (dead) and she is working hard to bring him back to life?

The real blue star is...
→The real Blue Star and Sirius-sama are Ciel.

"There's no way I could have mistaken him for..."
→He's Ciel, too (but he's most likely mistaken for a boy).

Ciel Phantomhive is me.
→This is a counterpart to the line in episode 2 about Bo-chan. However, it is really "Ciel," so unlike Bo-chan, there are no quotation marks.

Episode 130 "That Butler, Authentication
"You did me a great favor that day."
→Sebas ate the soul of the true Ciel when he summoned it.

"I have never met a man like you before."
→Does it mean that this is the first time I've met someone whose soul was eaten by a demon and then resurrected?

Rachel's delivery scene.
→The thin birth voice is the boy's and the loud one is Ciel's?
(*There is a possibility that the twins were actually born before Rachel and were switched for some reason.)

(Actually, the boy was born first, but the twins may have been switched for some reason.
The two of you are like mirror images of each other.
→The twin theory is completely confirmed.

The last panel
→See the cover of Vol. 7, No. 32. Ciel gave the flower crown to the boy.

Episode 131 (*An answer to the twin theory, so to speak. All the foreshadowing for the past 10 years is recovered.)
Cover.
→The pairing with Ciel on the cover of episode 32.

The boy watching from his room as Ciel and Lizzie play with Madame Red in the garden.
→The same scene as Madame's recollection in episode 10

The scene where she says, "She looks like her sickly mother..."
→The same scene as in episode 28

The scene with Diederich, Vincent and the twins
→Same scene as episode 101

The scene where she says, "Unlike me, I can say hello..."
→Same scene as episodes 31 and 32

The panel of "I'm the only one who can't be the Count.
→The illustration is believed to be the same as the illustration in the "Yana Cardinal Art Collection: Black Butler 1" (2008), in which one side of the illustration is burnt (see below).

Recollections of Boating
→Same scene as the special bonus manga "The Butler, Nursing" from Book of Circus DVD/BD volume 4 (see below)

I was happy.
→The flowers picked by Ciel are lilac (innocence), lupine (always happy), daisy (peace), gerbera (hope), lily of the valley (purity), camomile (innocence, happiness), begonia (happy days), and rose (happiness), all symbols of happiness

Scene from episode 2

The boy is not a shell, so there are quotation marks.

Scene from episode 128

Ciel is really ciel, so there's no quotes.

Recovery of foreline for about 10 years

The illustration on the left was first shown at the Phantom Night event in 2008.
The right is a frame of 26 volumes and 130 stories (this book 131 stories).

There are a lot of hints on the twin theory! Bonus comic "That butler, nursing"

Book of Circus DVD/Blu-Ray4 volume first special bonus comic "That butler, nursing"

Bochan's Recollection (The content is so rich that it's a waste to be a special bonus comic. There is a lot of background on the twin theory, so please buy it if you are interested!)

Book of Circus DVD/Blu-Ray4 volume first special bonus comic "That butler, nursing" (* Linked with 130 episodes)
The scene from the beginning of Boy's Recollection to the delivery of food to Rachel is Ciel (a bright and energetic child), and the following page shows Boy's Recollection playing alone in the nursery room (a child with asthma and low eyebrows).
Botchan: "I have eaten this menu once before."
-> "I have eaten it" instead of "I have made it", so it was Ciel who cooked the dish with Vincent and ディーデリヒ.
Vincent: "Let's do it again when we're all together."
-> "When everyone is together" instead of "when Rachel gets well" means that Rachel is not the only one who is sick (the young master was also sick).
Vincent (to Ciel): "I mean, you've stolen (an asthma lozenge) again."
-> Ciel doesn't have asthma, so he doesn't need to eat candy, so he "steals food".
Vincent: "That was delicious, so I wanted to let my family eat it, too." "ディーデリヒ said it was okay for my family to die."
--> Not limited to Rachel. The two who were sick were Rachel and Botchan.
Ciel: "You're coughing, こんこん. You're hurting me. I want you to get well soon."
-> I didn't say who, so I told you about Rachel and the baby.
Ciel: "Have you had sex with Lizzy!"
-> Ciel calls Elizabeth' Lizzy' (refer to the second and fifty eighth episodes).
"I don't want a fake (brother)," said Ciel.
→ Meaning "I have a real younger brother."
Rachel, "Go check on her."
-> If it refers to Ciel who has just left the room, it is supposed to be' see how that child is doing,' so it refers to another child (Botchan) who is not Ciel.
Two plates and a matching stuffed bear.
-> Until just before that, Botchan and Ciel were playing chess while eating.
YOUNG MASTER: "I HAD A FEVER THE NEXT DAY, SO WE COULD N'T GO BOATING TOGETHER."
Three of us, Vincent Rachel Sciel, went boating.
YOUNG MASTER: "THIS IS THE ONLY TIME MY PREDECESSORS (VINCENT SCIEL ディーデリヒ) HAVE COOKED THEIR OWN FOOD."
--> Since he says "Sendatsuta ga" instead of "Sendatsuta to," it is not the boy who was cooking was cooking together in the reminiscence, but the Ciel.

Source: pbs.twimg.com

Unexpected aspect of Ciel

Ciel: "Ryoko?"
Dad: "You can do something like a school-exclusive little brother someday."
"No, I don't want a fake."

go-1126699686594383289821
go-1126699686594383289821
@go-1126699686594383289821

Related Articles

Spoilers and discussion of Black Butler (Cardinal Yana)

Spoilers and discussion of Black Butler (Cardinal Yana)

Kuroshitsuji" is a manga series written by Yana Cardinal and serialized in Monthly G-Fantasy. It is a dark fantasy in which Ciel Phantomhive, a young lord of the prestigious noble Phantomhive Countess family in late 19th century England, and his butler Sebastian Michaelis, a demon contracted with Ciel, try to find out the truth while getting involved in incidents such as Ciel's past and a request from the Queen of England. An animated film "The Luxury Liner Arc" is scheduled to be screened in 2017.

Read Article

A collection of too beautiful crayons drawn by the creator of "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler) [Studio Ghibli].

A collection of too beautiful crayons drawn by the creator of "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler) [Studio Ghibli].

The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana TODO, has created a collection of illustrations that are too beautiful to be called "doodles", which she drew during her work. The illustrations were mainly shown on "Tsunabiy" and became a topic of conversation because they were so good even though they were "doodles". There are many illustrations of his own characters for practice and illustrations of "Sword Dance," "Anna and the Snow Queen," "Studio Ghibli," and many others that we have all seen before.

Read Article

Kiseki's Generation] A compilation of beautiful illustrations of "Captain Levi" and other manga by the creator of "Black Butler" [Kiseki no Generation] [Marching Giants].

Kiseki's Generation] A compilation of beautiful illustrations of "Captain Levi" and other manga by the creator of "Black Butler" [Kiseki no Generation] [Marching Giants].

Illustrations of other manga drawn by Yana TODO, the creator of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler), were compiled. His illustrations of "Kuroko no Basketball" became a topic of conversation for their beauty, and he also drew illustrations of "Shinkou no Kyojin," "Durarara! Inazuma Eleven," "Fate/Zero," "Gintama," "Persona 4," "Valvrave," and many other characters are shown on her blog.

Read Article

[Sword Dance] "Black Butler" author's beautiful rakugo compilation [Twisted Wonderland].

[Sword Dance] "Black Butler" author's beautiful rakugo compilation [Twisted Wonderland].

The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana Tobori, has compiled a collection of "practice illustrations" and "doodles" that she drew in her spare time between jobs, which she showed on Twitter and which have become the talk of the town for their beautiful illustrations. She draws rough sketches and settings of her precious works, her own characters drawn for her fans, "FGO," "Hiroaka," "Tourabu (sword dance)," "Twisted Wonderland," and many others.

Read Article

Kuroko no Basketball" illustrations drawn by "Kuroshitsuji" artist Yana Kuru are super cool!

Kuroko no Basketball" illustrations drawn by "Kuroshitsuji" artist Yana Kuru are super cool!

Here we present an illustration of "Kuroko no Basketball" drawn by Yana Kuru, known for the manga "Black Butler" and the game "Twisted Wonderland. This fan art, published on her blog, depicts the main character and other members of "Kiseki's Generation. The black bus characters, drawn with the beautiful touch that only Yana Tsurumi can create, became a topic of conversation on the Internet.

Read Article

Contents