This is a compilation of dialogues and scenes that seem to foreshadow the twin theory from the first volume of the original work to the latest episode. There are major spoilers, so please be careful. For fans of the original work. Note that the original story and the anime (1st and 2nd seasons) have different stories and settings. Please read to the end!
8 episodes (* See also episode 62)
Three graves in recollection.
-> It seems that Botchan, Vincent (the late), and Rachel (the late) are listed in this order.
* In the recollection of Chapter 62, there were four graves. In chronological order, from the recollection of Chapter 62 to the recollection of Chapter 8, the number of graves decreased by one, not by one.
The chronological order is as follows:
In December, Juan Tom Herr Eve's house was attacked by unknown assailants, killing Vincent and Rachael and leaving the child's body undiscovered.
December - January Grave for 4 family members is made without the body of child.
In January, Botchan returns to the Juan Tom Herr Eve family as' Ciel' (Recollection of the 62nd episode -> 4 graves).
In January, a child came home alive and his grave was removed.
From January, Botchan visits his grave (8 episodes of recollection => 3 graves).
3 volumes (Red Butler version)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
The key is Madam Red's recollection.
The plural form of' nephews' is used to the extent that one does not feel uncomfortable, while skillfully blurring the singular and plural forms such as' dead body of a child' and' my child'.
10 episodes
"Shall I take out the ring?" (part of Sebastian's cinematic record)
→ Memories shortly after being summoned. The ring refers to the ring of the head of the Juan Tom Herr Eve family, which was hidden by Ciel (the most likely theory is that he swallowed it).
In other words, "Shall I take out the ring of the family head (from the body of the dead Ciel)?"
Scene where Madame is stabbed by Grell and a cinematic record appears
→ Next to the crying baby, you can see the legs of the other baby.
Rachel giving birth
-> The child that Anne is holding is Ciel, and the one next to Rachel is Bocchan (* see episode 129).
The boy playing with Lizzy is my brother Ciel.
-> The young master had severe asthma and couldn't go out (* see episode 130).
"Pretty Nephews."
-> It refers to twins, not Lizzy.
"It's my kid's birthday."
-> I dare to say it not by name ("Ciel's birthday") but without specifying the number of people.
11th episode
"The body of the child was not found."
-> I dare to say "the body of a child" instead of "the body of a ciel."
Scene of Madame and Botchan's Reunion
-> It seems that the reason why the saw the young master and called him "Ciel!" was because she had been told by the hospital staff in advance that "Ciel came back alone."
(* In the reminiscence of Episode 62, there is a scene in which a young master calls a at the reception desk of a hospital.)
"Good. You're safe."
--> One of the twins is dead, but it's good that you are back. "
CHAPTER 13
"I KNEW THAT I COULD N'T HELP HIM. EVEN THE RELATIVES WHO KNEW THAT AND LEFT HIM TO DIE."
--> The background of the frame of "Even close relatives" is a, but did it actually point to Ciel?
"I thought that Madame could not kill me. my family."
-> Because Madam loved Ciel the most. Or because the real Ciel is already dead.
14 episodes
"Aunt Anne loved me most, because I was Ciel."
-> "Ichiban" means that there was an object he loved other than Lizzie and Ciel (Botchan).
これ、赤子が二人描かれてるけど、マダムのシネマティックレコードが時系列順じゃないとしたら、わざわざ描写するほどマダムと関係のある赤子って?
— 愛莉 (@_airi_rose_) March 25, 2017
いやもうシエル双子説確定ですやん。 pic.twitter.com/X8So6DGdJ3
Madame's Cinematic Record (10 episodes)
4 volumes (edited by Huang Shuji)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Bochan's Recollection of "That Day" (1)
The biggest mystery is Mr. Tanaka. What is the real meaning of his lines in the reminiscence scene of episode 19?
17th CHAPTER
"No matter how much I scratch my foot, there are things that I can't get back, and there are things of despair that I can't get out of."
-> Vincent, Rachel, Madam Red, Sebastian (dog) and Ciel in the background are all dead (* see the cover of episode 133).
19 episodes
"PLEASE RUN AWAY, SIELSAMA. IS TOO CRUEL FOR YOU."
He began to say something about Shiel, saying, "Shiel-sama. (where, or so)."
-> If the rumor that Ciel was the mastermind (* to be described later) is true, did he start to say,' Ciel-sama has been disturbed' or' Nobody can stop him anymore'?
"Oh. this!" "It's rare, isn't it?"
-> "Rare" because they are twins
"This is worth more than two!"
-> Since it is twins, "more than 2 servings"
"How did we,"
-> plural form (meaning' me and ciel')
A child in a cage
-> I have a bruise on my left eye, so I'll give it a try.
A child who was knifed during a mass
=> Ciel (* Botchan was in a cage at this time)
"You have summoned me, and that fact will remain the same forever, and the sacrifice paid will never return."
→ Sacrifice = The soul of Ciel, in other words, "The sacrifice paid will never come back" means "The life of a dead Ciel will not be revived."
7 volumes (circus version)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
An exaggerated recollection of Baron Kelvin
The scene is an essential part of the twin theory. There are too many unnatural things such as Vincent's gaze, the position of the child, Klaus and the tone.
28 episodes
"People lie without a second thought, and so do I."
=> Botchan's lie = It's not really a shell.
Madame, Rachael and Lizzy looking anxiously at the bedside of a young boy who is ill in bed with asthma
-> Lizzie knows that her younger brother, Botchan, has asthma. That's why in episodes 56 and 57, Botchan tried to hide asthma from Lizzie (* see episode 131).
リジーはたぶん(弟の方の)「坊ちゃん」が喘息体質だったこと知ってたんじゃないかな。原作28話で坊ちゃんが喘息で倒れた時1コマだけ幼少期の回想があってベッドにいる坊ちゃんを心配そうに見つめるリジーが描かれてる。アニメでも確か一瞬だけこの回想挿入されてたと思う(うろ覚え) pic.twitter.com/K9Ym11IloS
— 釦@黒執事考察垢 (@cielfutagosetsu) February 25, 2017
Source: pbs.twimg.com
Botchan's Childhood Recollections (Original 28 episodes)
Madame, Rachel and Lizzy gaze anxiously at the young boy. (* See also episode 130.)
29th episode
"Surely he has many lies and secrets,"
=> Lie, secret = Identity of Botchan
52nd page
-> The child who greets Kelvin is Ciel (see the 31st and 32nd episodes) because it is the reminiscence frame of the viewpoint of the young master hidden on the left side of Vincent.
31 episodes
129 pages Baron Kelvin's Recollection of "Strange Things"
-> The position of Vincent's eyes and hands are strange. It is hidden by the guest's dress, but there is another child there.
Page 130. She's holding hands with Vincent. She's got a falling eyebrow and bangs on the left.
-> Botchan (there is a ciel in the part hidden by the hand of Count Burton)
"Say hello to me first," on page 131
It means "the eldest son, Ciel, greets you before the second son, Botchan." Ciel is on Vincent's right side as he strokes his head with his right hand.
Page 131 The child who greeted "I am Ciel"
-> Ciel (* see chapter 130)
はい、シエル双子説みんなどう思ってるんだろ〜わたし絶対双子だとおもう✋二重人格もありえるけどさ〜双子だよ!! pic.twitter.com/YfrjGUvlq2
— 悠 里 (@y____u802) August 27, 2014
Source: twitter.com
Clever visual tricks by 枢先 students
31 episodes
Source: twitter.com
Ingenious visual tricks by 枢先 students ②
There's a Ciel right where it's hidden by the hands of the partygoers.
Source: twitter.com
Clever visual tricks by 枢先 students ③
Ciel's on Vincent's right.
32 episodes
Front cover: Ciel (divided to the right) is passing a corolla to Botchan (* refer to 129 and 130 episodes).
→ The flower language of white clover is "happiness", "promise", "think of me", "be mine," and "revenge."
Page 134, top. The child greeting Kelvin is Ciel.
Lower frame The child hiding behind Vincent is a young boy.
"She's shy and a little weak, and she doesn't go out much."
-> A young boy who had asthma and was in poor health. He dared to say "koko" instead of "ciel."
135 pages
-> The child who ran up to Klaus with full of energy was Ciel (the line' Is it Ciel?' was because I couldn't decide which of the twins it was).
Page 136: "It's unusual that we're all together today."
-> It means that it is rare for a sickly boy to attend a party together. (If Ciel and Vincent were the only two people present, the expression "all together" would be unnatural.)
Page 136: "I didn't ask you to come with me. She's still recovering."
"Konoko" is for Botchan. The fact that the sailor suit does not have a breastplate is probably due to the author's forgetting to draw.
"I couldn't take my eyes off those three people" on page 137
-> The child held by Klaus is Ciel, and the baby is at the sight of Vincent (outside the screen).
The "three" Kelvin refers to are twins and Vincent.
Klaus has a tone = meaning that it is not in the eyes of Kelvin.
"To kill all the children, not to mention the Earl."
Since it is written in plural form as "children", it was confirmed that Shiel already had a brother at this point (2009).
* In the series of scenes up to this point, it is confirmed that there were actually two children in 130 episodes.
151 pages A child in a cage and a child dead on a table.
-> Both are ciel (there is a bruise on the left eye).
Vincent's eyes are on a little boy.
あとシエルくん双子説といえば、サーカス編のセリフの「お子様達」とか pic.twitter.com/bTyCW2MHhO
— カーナ (@kaxxnaxx621) July 5, 2014
"TO KILL ALL THE CHILDREN, NOT TO MENTION THE COUNT."
Related Articles
Spoilers and discussion of Black Butler (Cardinal Yana)
Kuroshitsuji" is a manga series written by Yana Cardinal and serialized in Monthly G-Fantasy. It is a dark fantasy in which Ciel Phantomhive, a young lord of the prestigious noble Phantomhive Countess family in late 19th century England, and his butler Sebastian Michaelis, a demon contracted with Ciel, try to find out the truth while getting involved in incidents such as Ciel's past and a request from the Queen of England. An animated film "The Luxury Liner Arc" is scheduled to be screened in 2017.
Read Article
April 2024 Spring Anime (First Semester Anime) Summary
This is an alphabetical list of spring anime that will start airing in April 2024.The April 2024 spring anime lineup includes many hot new anime and sequels to popular series. Information such as anime titles, broadcast information, cast voice actors and staffs are compiled in an easy-to-understand format.
Read Article
This is a list of live-action films that are too terrible.
I collected live action that was too much.
Read Article
Beautiful original drawings of Sebastian and Ciel from "Black Butler".
If you are a big fan of the gothic and aesthetic world of "Black Butler," you will be hooked first. This is a beautiful shot drawn by the original author, Yana Cardinal.
Read Article
The quality of the "Black Butler (Circus version)" dolls is so high, their destructive power is amazing!
Black Butler" continues to be very popular, and due to its popularity, various manufacturers have released dolls of Ciel and Sebastian, but this time a doll of great quality is being released. This high quality doll is a must-see.
Read Article
A collection of too beautiful crayons drawn by the creator of "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler) [Studio Ghibli].
The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana TODO, has created a collection of illustrations that are too beautiful to be called "doodles", which she drew during her work. The illustrations were mainly shown on "Tsunabiy" and became a topic of conversation because they were so good even though they were "doodles". There are many illustrations of his own characters for practice and illustrations of "Sword Dance," "Anna and the Snow Queen," "Studio Ghibli," and many others that we have all seen before.
Read Article
Black Butler's characters ranked in order of popularity!
The ranking of characters with various personalities, such as Grell the Grim Reaper and Sebastian the servant, who appear in the popular manga "Black Butler" by Yana Toboso, is introduced. The ranking is based on the first-ever character popularity poll, and includes the number of votes received by the fans for each character.
Read Article
Kiseki's Generation] A compilation of beautiful illustrations of "Captain Levi" and other manga by the creator of "Black Butler" [Kiseki no Generation] [Marching Giants].
Illustrations of other manga drawn by Yana TODO, the creator of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji" (Black Butler), were compiled. His illustrations of "Kuroko no Basketball" became a topic of conversation for their beauty, and he also drew illustrations of "Shinkou no Kyojin," "Durarara! Inazuma Eleven," "Fate/Zero," "Gintama," "Persona 4," "Valvrave," and many other characters are shown on her blog.
Read Article
[Sword Dance] "Black Butler" author's beautiful rakugo compilation [Twisted Wonderland].
The author of the popular manga "Kuroshitsuji", Yana Tobori, has compiled a collection of "practice illustrations" and "doodles" that she drew in her spare time between jobs, which she showed on Twitter and which have become the talk of the town for their beautiful illustrations. She draws rough sketches and settings of her precious works, her own characters drawn for her fans, "FGO," "Hiroaka," "Tourabu (sword dance)," "Twisted Wonderland," and many others.
Read Article
Summary of foreshadowing and discussion of Black Butler (Black Butler)
Kuroshitsuji" is a dark fantasy manga series by Yana Toboso. It was adapted into anime in 2008, 2010, and 2014, a stage version in 2009, and a live-action movie in 2014 starring Ayame Tsuyoshi and Hiro Mizushima. Here we will discuss the foreshadowing and discussion of one of the main characters, Ciel Phantomhive, the boy who is the current head of the Phantomhive Countess family.
Read Article
Kuroko no Basketball" illustrations drawn by "Kuroshitsuji" artist Yana Kuru are super cool!
Here we present an illustration of "Kuroko no Basketball" drawn by Yana Kuru, known for the manga "Black Butler" and the game "Twisted Wonderland. This fan art, published on her blog, depicts the main character and other members of "Kiseki's Generation. The black bus characters, drawn with the beautiful touch that only Yana Tsurumi can create, became a topic of conversation on the Internet.
Read Article
Fans rejoice at Captain Levi and Armin drawn by "Black Butler" author Yana Kururunobu.
Many fans were excited to see the illustrations of Captain Levi and Armin by Yana Cardinal, the author of the popular dark fantasy manga "Black Butler. The super-beautiful illustrations are one of the quintessential examples.
Read Article
Tags
Contents
- What is the Siel twin theory?
- The original author, 枢先 no comment on the twin theory! BUT?
- Comments of Mr. Kuma in charge of the interview in 2016
- 枢先'S WAY OF LAYING A GROUNDWORK IS AMAZING!
- Outline of the twin theory (volumes 1 to 26)
- Original 1 Volume (The Butler)
- 2 volumes (Red Butler version)
- 3 volumes (Red Butler version)
- 4 volumes (edited by Huang Shuji)
- 7 volumes (circus version)
- 8 volumes (circus version)
- 9 volumes (Yugijo Satsujin Jiken hen)
- 10 volumes (Yugijo Satsujin Jiken hen)
- 11 volumes (Yugi Castle Murder Case)
- 12 volumes (deluxe passenger boat edition)
- 13 volumes (luxury cruise ship edition)
- 14 volumes (deluxe passenger boat edition)
- 15 volumes (dormitory school edition)
- 19 volumes (The Green Witch)
- 20 volumes (Green Witch Edition)
- 21 volumes (The Green Witch)
- 22 volumes (completed version of the Green Witch)
- 23 volumes (edited by Blue Cult)
- 24 volumes (edited by Ao No Kyodan)
- 25 volumes (edited by Blue Cult)
- 26 volumes (edited by Ao-no-kyodan)
- There are a lot of hints on the twin theory! Bonus comic "That butler, nursing"
- Anything else that seems to be a foreshadowing.
- IN FACT, THERE WAS A HIDDEN PLOT IN YOUR BLOG!
- Musical Foreshadowing
- Black Butler's Official Anthology "Rainbow Butler 2" Included Extra Volume "Father and!"
- Knox's Ten Commandments
- Mystery of the twin theory
- Contradictions? Or new plots?
- About anime (first and second period, "Book of ~" series)
- By the way, what are the views of overseas fans?
- IN FACT, IT'S BEEN AROUND FOR A LONG TIME. WHAT IS THE "SIEL MASTERMIND THEORY"?
- THE BOY'S "LIES" HAVE FINALLY BEEN REVEALED. WHAT WILL BECOME OF THEM?
- References
