Return of the Obra Dinn (game) spoiler commentary and discussion summary

Return of the Obra Dinn is a mystery-solving adventure game directed by Lucas Pope. It is characterized by graphics expressed in one bit of black and white only.
The story takes place in the early 19th century, when the "Obra Dinn," which has been missing for five years, returns to port with zero crew members. The protagonist, an insurance investigator, is sent to the ship to prepare a loss assessment report, and uses a strange pocket watch to determine the cause of death and estimated current location of the 60 passengers and crew. With the special power of the pocket watch, the protagonist is able to identify the final scenes of the dead and use this information to unravel the truth about what happened on board the ship.

Contents

The Mysterious Power of Shells

As the sailors are losing and dying, Itoben, an old man from Formosa, plunges a shell into the liquid of the box to save Lord Lim, and a beam-like substance generated from the box (or shell) hits the mermaids, knocking them out. However, Lim has already suffered a fatal wound to the neck from the mermaid's attack, and when Itben calls out to him, he draws his last breath. There is much mystery about Itben's attack, and there is much speculation about what the liquid was and why the beam-like object was generated.

Vicious Navigators.

An elderly Formosa royalty, Shea Itben, also dies, having burned his right arm in compensation for the attack. Nichols, the only surviving navigator, is loading the unconscious mermaids into the boat. He also dumps the dead sailors' bodies into the sea to load the mermaids, a truly evil act.

Reason for mermaid attack

The surviving Nichols returned to the Obra Din with the stolen treasure, the royal corpses, and the unconscious mermaids. But he said, "Don't shoot! We surrender!" Nichols is shot to death by Formosa guard Tan Cho.
If we look at the three mermaids on the boat in this scene, we can see that two of them have shells, but one of them does not. It is likely that the shells possessed by the Formosa royal family originally belonged to mermaids who did not have shells. This would explain why the Formosa royal family was concerned about the appearance of demons and why the mermaids actually attacked them.

Chapter V. Cursed Prey

Mermaids and shells to the home country

The mermaid brought back by second mate Nichols is unloaded onto the ship. At the same time, on deck, the captain interrogates Tan Cho, a Formosa man, about the mermaid and the box that belonged to the Formosa royal family. Suddenly, the mermaid wakes up and fires a spike, which pierces Tan Chou and the deck hands behind him.
During the interrogation, Tan Chow says, "We must protect the shells...! We will all die!" But in reality, the disaster is over when Tan Chou returns the shell to the mermaid in Chapter VIII. It is thought that Tan Chou had not been told much about the shells, the box, or the demons, and only knew that he had to protect the shells anyway.
Also, after this, the ship changed course, heading back to England instead of the Cape of Good Hope, where it was originally headed. The captains seem to have decided to bring the mermaid back to England.

carelessness

The mermaid is wrapped in cloth and carried into the warehouse by four people. A curious cook approaches and finds a shell in the mermaid's possession. When the cook tries to touch the shell, the mermaid goes berserk and the cook is beaten to death by the mermaid's tail. The mermaid's violent attack also causes four of the bearers to lose their balance and fall down the stairs; one deck hand gets his head caught between the stretcher bars and a barrel on the floor below, and dies as a result.

The Beginning of the Curse

Without any connection from "carelessness," one deck hand, Philippe Dahl, a galley hand, had his leg amputated with a sword.
The captain raised his voice, to which Philippe appealed to return the mermaid to the sea. The captain, however, refuses to listen and orders Philippe and the mermaid to be detained in the aft storeroom.
Meanwhile, a deck hand, who had lost a leg, dies in spite of the ship's doctors' efforts.
We are not told what Philippe did here or why he attacked the deck hands.
According to the profit and loss assessment form, which can be seen after the safety of the passengers and crew in all chapters except Chapter VIII, Philip is listed as "in default of duty". This suggests that "dereliction of duty" may refer to his attempt to kill the mermaid instead of following the ship's intention to "bring the mermaid back to England". Unable to change the captains' decision, Philip then decided to kill the mermaid rather than let her escape into the sea. However, one of the deck hands found out, and Philip cut the deck hand.

Chapter VI Soldiers of the Sea

atmospheric disquiet

The Obra Dinn, loaded with mermaids and on her way back to England, was hit by a sudden storm. The mastmen were working on the mast, hoping to fold the mast before the storm hit. Suddenly, a bolt of lightning strikes the mastmen who were crossing the rigging.
This scene serves as a source of information for the progression of the game, which can identify who the mastmen are.

New Monster Attacks

With the storm, two monsters, riding giant crabs and covered with what looked like black cloth, appeared and boarded the Obra Din. These monsters proceeded to the lower deck. The sailors desperately tried to attack the monsters, but they were unable to do anything, and one by one, sailors were killed. Burn it! Cadet Charles throws a lantern at the monster.

Brave cadets

The monster, burning from the lantern's flames, finally collapses but struggles desperately. Charles holds on to it with determination, and the other cadet stabs the monster with his sword. Charles dies with the monster in tow. Meanwhile, the other monster is still making its way through the ship.

vengeance

The monster, still alive, finally reaches the cargo deck, where the ship's master, armed with a gun, is determined to confront it. Despite being stabbed in the neck with a nail, the ship's master uses his last ounce of strength to fire his gun and repel the monster. The shipmaster also dies. The shipmaster succeeds in avenging the death of his assistant who died in this chapter. Incidentally, the monster was apparently heading toward the aft warehouse where the mermaid was. Therefore, it is thought that the mermaids had summoned these two crab-riding monsters.

Chapter VII Ruin

false accusations

2xyraau197
2xyraau197
@2xyraau197

Contents