Return of the Obra Dinn (game) spoiler commentary and discussion summary

Return of the Obra Dinn is a mystery-solving adventure game directed by Lucas Pope. It is characterized by graphics expressed in one bit of black and white only.
The story takes place in the early 19th century, when the "Obra Dinn," which has been missing for five years, returns to port with zero crew members. The protagonist, an insurance investigator, is sent to the ship to prepare a loss assessment report, and uses a strange pocket watch to determine the cause of death and estimated current location of the 60 passengers and crew. With the special power of the pocket watch, the protagonist is able to identify the final scenes of the dead and use this information to unravel the truth about what happened on board the ship.

Contents

Overview of Return of the Obra Dinn

Return of the Obra Dinn is a mystery and adventure game directed by Lucas Pope and released in 2018 by 3909 LLC.
The merchant ship Obra Dinn, carrying 60 crew and passengers, disappeared after leaving the port of Falmouth, England, but suddenly returns unmanned five years later. In this film, the protagonist, as an insurance investigator, investigates what happened to the Obra Dinn.

This work is characterized by its unique game system and visuals. The game system, in which the player must identify 60 people from the many residual thoughts and hints left in their memoirs, confirm the safety of each of them, and investigate the cause of death, is unique and unparalleled. The black-and-white, one-bit yet 3D visuals are also appealing and match the early 19th century setting.

It has won in seven categories of five awards, including Best Art Direction at The Game Awards 2018 and Best Indie Game at the Titanium Awards, and has been nominated for a total of 10 awards in 33 categories. This is the second game directed by Lucas Pope after "Papers, Please," released in 2013, which also won five awards and nine nominations. The film was initially released for Windows and MacOS, but has been ported to PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, and Xbox One since 2019.

Synopsis and story of Return of the Obra Dinn

Present (before survey)

In 1802, the merchant ship Obra Dinh left Falmouth, England, for the Cape of Good Hope in South Africa, but disappeared during the voyage. Five years later, in 1807, the Obra Dinh suddenly returned to Falmouth harbor. However, none of the original crew and passengers were on board, making the ship look like a ghost ship. The British East India Company, which managed and owned the ship, dispatches the protagonist, an insurance investigator, to the ship in order to examine the ship directly and prepare a damage assessment report. Using the journal entitled "The Return of the Obra Din" and the strange pocket watch "Memento Mortem," both of which are in the possession of the protagonist, the protagonist begins his investigation.

Chapter I. Collapsed Cargo

An unfortunate accident during a cargo transfer was the beginning of the tragedy of the Obra Dinh. While unloading a cargo on the cargo deck in England, a rope broke and the cargo fell. One sailor, who was under the cargo, was crushed to death by the falling cargo. Soon after, an unidentified stowaway hiding in a barrel of the cargo also dies from the impact of the fall. Note that the stowaway is neither a crew member nor a passenger, so identification is not required.

Chapter II: Deadly Diseases

lung disease of unknown cause

The sailor (left) died of lung disease despite medical attention from a doctor (right).

Two sailors die in this chapter due to a disease of unknown cause. The ship's doctor suspects that they contracted the disease in the Indian sailor's waiting station prior to embarkation on the Obra Din. The truth is also not certain, as the disease has been diagnosed as a lung disease, but not tuberculosis, nor is it contagious. This is an important scene in the progression of the game, as there are many hammocks in this chapter that provide significant clues to the identification of the sailor.

Cattle slaughter

While two cadets were suffering from the disease, a cow for slaughter was killed by a sailor. Here three cadets are learning to slaughter cattle under the guidance of the livestock guard. It does not seem necessary to write in the book that the cow died, but the scene was necessary as a stepping stone to this chapter and a clue to the cadets' identities.

Chapter III Murder

In addition to the 51 sailors on board, the Obra Dinh also had nine civilian passengers on board, including the royal family of Formosa (Taiwan). The royalty were in possession of glowing shells, which the second mate, Nichols, was after.

muzzling (a person)

The navigator beats up the baggage keeper of the Formosa royal family and rifles through the royal family's luggage. Another passenger, who unfortunately sees him, is killed to keep him quiet. In the back where the murder took place, a shell shines divinely and strangely in a drawer. It seems that the navigator was trying to steal the treasure of the Formosa royal family, but he could not steal this shell here because of the murder.

court-martial on a ship

The baggage handler of Formosa, who was beaten up in this chapter, has been sentenced to death by firing squad for killing a passenger. Apparently, the navigator was accused of the crime. This scene is sketched in the book under the title "The Trial on Board." According to the captain's statement, the baggage handler confessed to the murder. However, as we will see in this chapter, the baggage handler did not commit the murder, nor is it likely that he would falsely claim that he had killed someone. Perhaps this involved a Chinese mastmaster who had been assigned to interpret for the Formosans. It is possible that this mastmaster was part of Nichols' faction and that this mastmaster made it appear that the baggage handler had confessed. A mastman is a deck officer of higher grade who specializes in the job of going up the mast and adjusting sails and rigging.

Treasure Robbery

After the theft fails, the navigator and some sailors rob Formosa of its treasure, the shells, and plot to escape by boat with the royal family as hostages.
One of the sailors notices this and stops him, only to be shot dead by the navigator.
The body of the sailor who died here seems to have been hanging outside the window of the first mate's cabin with a rope tangled around his leg for a long time. At the time of the investigation, only his shoes and the bones of his feet remained, from which the corpse can be traced back to this Chapter III.

Chapter IV Appearance

Mermaid attack

Having escaped from the Obra Din, navigator Nichols and his companions are on their way to the Canary Islands. Immediately after the hostages, the royalty of Formosa, are concerned about their boxes (luggage) and have a conversation about "if demons appear," three mermaid demons appear and attack them.
The sailors are attacked, and Nichols, the navigator, is called upon to fire his gun by the shichuushu, but the important thing is that Nichols is cowering pitifully at the bottom of the ship with his head in his hands. A galley master is a seaman who takes care of the personal needs of higher-ranking crew members and works to make their employer's life on board more comfortable. For example, a captain has a galley hand with the captain, and a first mate has a galley hand with the first mate.

2xyraau197
2xyraau197
@2xyraau197

Contents