This is an examination of the urban legend that Jonathan, the hero and Karen, the heroine of the sci-fi game classic "Police Notes," may actually have been father and daughter. While providing information on the characters and characters, we will also introduce the reasons why the father-daughter theory was whispered and players' reactions to it.
■Net reaction to the denial theory
If you don't understand without a direct explanation...
I think that's fine.
Source: medaka.5ch.net
Karen is not Jonathan's child.
Redwood died with a final repentance for his sins.
These two points are often discussed by the know-it-alls in the kitchen.
The correct answer is the opposite of both.
Source: game9.5ch.net
The bulletin board system is not helpful to the gullible because it is not even snobbish with many people wanting to mount the theory in an enlightened way, but unfortunately, there were no articles or statements at all that attacked the negative theory theoretically, so I had no choice but to include it.
All the blog posts and other evaluations and comments that I googled were all about accepting the Jonacare bloodline as it is as a normal storyline, regardless of whether or not there is any evidence for it.
Naturally, I did not see any reference to the rejection theory itself.
It's not officially known, it's not 100%.
Are you going to take my word for it?
Source: game9.5ch.net
It's implied in the storyline that he and Jonathan are father and son, but there's no set explanation given.
Source: medaka.5ch.net
■Conclusion from the main game
There is no definitive evidence that Jonathan and Karen are related.
It is only a storyline direction and script that can be inferred.
■Final Conclusion
>Karen is Jonathan's child.
Director Kojima clearly says so.
He said so in an interview with his wife in the Polysnotes Official Visual Data Book.
Source: game9.5ch.net
Ruthless Settlement
Yeah, ...... I knew that.
Give me something more in the making, W.
Source: "Police Notes Official Visual Data Book: Haou Game Special 45," p. 92.
Kodansha, ISBN 4-06-329246-0
■Omake it a Gates trap.
The one mystery I've wondered about is whether it was really a coincidence that Gates' bone marrow matched Karen's.
I wonder if it was really a coincidence that Gates' marrow matched Karen's.
Source: medaka.5ch.net
Top secret information obtained by doctor hacking database
I heard that Karen's doctor did his best, but the information is too dubious to be kicked out as sarcasm.
However, if he was Gates' dog, it is strange that he does not have access to Tokugawa side information. It could be a pose, but it could also be information leaked on purpose from the Gates side.
That HLA type match is nothing but a coincidence, and unlike the case of Jonathan and Karen, it is opportunistic!
Source: medaka.5ch.net
No, the match between Jonathan and Karen is also coincidental.
Although they are father and son, they are far, far away from a quarter of their siblings.
It's just a possibility that doctors say is "very rare".
For some reason, he's the man who knows what's going on.
Redwood's line about shooting his birth mother, Chris, at the end of ACT6.
This would not make sense without the assumption that "Jonathan knows about the Gates HLA match".
Jonathan! It's a trap!" And he said it with all his might, didn't he?
Source: medaka.5ch.net
At the beginning of ACT 7
Merrill's reply to Jonathan, "We need Gates' marrow to save Karen."
This is certainly too suspicious information, but we have no choice but to put our faith in it at this point, regardless of its authenticity.
You can't have me! She needs my marrow!"
Gates' line at the decisive battle.
The final stunt to Jonathan after the speech is revealed in the TV broadcast.
A scene only in the PC-9821 version.
Applicable scenes after PS version
The bone marrow is not discussed, and Ed shoots him dead and his head comes flying in as it is.
In the PS and SS versions, Ed knows about Jonathan's HLA match at this time. In the PS and SS versions, Ed knows about Jonathan's HLA match.
In the PC-9821 version, he does not know.
Ed, Karen's marrow is ......" "...... what?"
■Finally.
It is my own speculation, but I believe that Karen was only discovered to be the child of Jonathan and Lorraine after the discovery of Karen's leukemia (after she had grown up quite a bit).
If Lorraine had known from the beginning, there is no way that she would not have doted on Karen, since she was in love with Jonathan. In reality, however, Lorraine's love for Jonathan has become so strong that she and her husband do not get along, they fight a lot, and she is distant from her daughter.
The father, Kenzo, must have tried his best to show his love to Lorraine, not to mention to Karen.
If Lorraine had the same level of concern for her family as Kenzo (at least balanced by her love for Jonathan), Karen would have no reason to hate him so much.
I wonder how the couple must have felt when they found out that Karen was the child of Jonathan.
No doubt it was complicated for both of them, but Kenzo still had the same love for her, and at one point he even went so far as to do something evil for her sake. He was a deadly unhappy (literally) man, but I think the only part that comes to mind is that he was a father who was hated by his daughter, but still consistently adored by her (albeit with some sympathy).
Lorraine also had a very unhappy and solid life, but it is a small consolation that she passed away in the arms of her beloved Jonathan in her last moments, and her face as a mother entrusting her daughter to him is memorable.
If Jonathan had been the first man to run to Lorraine, who was injured in the explosion, instead of the gunfight with Redwood, she might have been happy.
I thought, but she would have to be pregnant at least by the end of 2012, so as of June 2013, the fastest she could have met Kenzo, she would be in the 6th month of Lorraine's pregnancy.
Tags
Contents
- ■Introduction of Important Personnel
- The hero and heroine. Two people who are attracted to each other.
- ■Forbidden love by a real father and his daughter? Really?
- ■Tips in the main game
- ■Network Reactions
- Another clue-like sequence
- The above sequence is only the result of "Jonathan's HLA type miraculously matched Karen's," and it definitely does not determine their kinship.
- If we ignore the storyline, but focus only on this HLA adaptation, the relationship between Jonathan and Karen is more likely to be that of brother and sister than parent and child.
- ■Theories/denials that Karen is not Jonathan's daughter.
- Lorraine, I think you're falling apart. ......
- What this item shows is that chronologically, the theory of Jonathan's biological father is acceptable, but never good or excellent.
- The fact that it is not accompanied by any content at all is sufficient to make the negative theory valid.
- ■Net reaction to the denial theory
- ■Conclusion from the main game
- ■Final Conclusion
- ■Omake it a Gates trap.
- ■Finally.
- I thought, but she would have to be pregnant at least by the end of 2012, so as of June 2013, the fastest she could have met Kenzo, she would be in the 6th month of Lorraine's pregnancy.
