Corporal punishment has been hard to eliminate in sports coaching, and we have compiled the opinions of prominent athletes on how it affects them with regard to their players. Masumi Kuwata and Hidetoshi Nakata's idea that "anachronistic corporal punishment coaching will never develop athletes" resonates very much with us.
NHK NEWS WEB Masumi Kuwata: Corporal Punishment Is an Easy Instruction
www3.nhk.or.jp
Masumi Kuwata, a former professional baseball player, spoke in an interview about the suicide of a male student at a municipal high school in Osaka Prefecture who had been subjected to corporal punishment by an advisory teacher of the basketball club. Kuwata won two national championships in high school baseball, and after playing for the Giants in professional baseball, he studied at a graduate school about the problems of sports spiritualism. Today, based on his own experience of being subjected to corporal punishment, Kuwata has taken part in lecture activities and child-rearing nationwide while appealing against instruction through corporal punishment.
Kuwata: Of course, I was also subjected to corporal punishment (when I was in elementary and junior high school), and there were no days when I went to the playground and wasn't beaten. Every day, I was beaten several times, and I went home with my hands on my cheeks. I was butted on my, and I had three or five bat marks on my bottom. I went home on my bicycle, but it got so swollen that I couldn't sit on the saddle.
I often say that corporal punishment is love, but I didn't feel that it was love when I was beaten.
I think professional baseball should be based on the principle of victory first. But I think amateurs should be based on the principle of human resource development or fostering rather than the principle of victory first.
NHK News: "Corporal punishment is necessary for strong teams"
www3.nhk.or.jp
At a municipal high school in Osaka, a male student committed suicide after being subjected to corporal punishment by a teacher who was an adviser to a basketball club.
At a municipal high school in Osaka, a male student who had been subjected to corporal punishment by a teacher who was an adviser to a basketball club committed suicide. It was revealed that the adviser told the Osaka City Board of Education, "Corporal punishment is necessary to make the club strong, and by doing so, I felt that I was making the students go in the right direction."
"I might have been able to do it, but I had a real sense that corporal punishment made students go in the right direction," the adviser said.
I don't think that corporal punishment is necessary. It is corporal punishment that occurs in a hierarchical structure where "no one will ever get revenge". Does a coach mislead and get hit by a player? It is the most shameful and shameful act in sports.
It's also proof that leaders are lazy. The easiest way to do this is to use violence and threats to get your child to do what you want.
A child who has been subjected to corporal punishment may fall into the negative thinking, "What should I do to avoid being beaten?"
A child who has been subjected to corporal punishment falls into the negative thinking of "What should I do to avoid being hit?" This does not develop the child's independence and only does what he or she is instructed to do. He or she cannot judge the play by himself, and he or she cannot become a good player.
In amateur sports, the days of teacher-student bonding through obedience are over.
[Osaka, Corporal Punishment Suicide] Coach of the Basketball Club: "Corporal Punishment Is Necessary to Make a Strong Club". In response to the interview after suicide ★ 2
uni.2ch.net
At a municipal high school in Osaka, a male student who had been subjected to corporal punishment by a teacher who was an adviser to a basketball club committed suicide. It was revealed that the adviser told the Osaka City Board of Education that "corporal punishment is necessary to make the club strong, and I felt that it would make students move in the right direction."
Why corporal punishment has been largely eliminated in soccer
1. The licensing system has taken off and corrupt leaders have been eliminated.
2) You can't get there if you don't win a big league match in the best competition.
3. The development of club youth has increased the choice of players.
1 → By systematizing and rationalizing teaching methods, original teaching methods such as corporal punishment were completely denied.
Since the original mezzot was introduced from Germany, ambiguous persons such as "human education" were excluded.
2 -> The best competition, the Prince Takamado Cup, is a method in which if you do not win in the regional league, you will never advance to the final round.
IT'S NOT A ONE SHOT MATCH, BUT AN ALL-ROUND MATCH, SO YOU HAVE TO GET RESULTS CONSTANTLY, RATHER THAN MENTAL STRENGTH OR GUTS.
IN SHORT, IT BECAME A FORM THAT COULD N'T BE HELPED BY GUTS.
3 → Since there are many choices such as club youth, street youth, high school soccer, the recruitment of players is not led by high schools.
IT'S LIKE A STRONG HIGH SCHOOL BECOMES A SOCCER CLUB THAT CAN WIN BY DROPPING OUT OF CLUB YOUTH.
If you do something like corporal punishment, the source will be cut off and the association will move to dislicense the leader
As a result, it's no good to do corporal punishment.
[Suicide in 2nd year high school] "I grew the most when I was in high school when I was not subjected to corporal punishment." Many sympathize with former giant Kuwata's denial of corporal punishment
uni.2ch.net
"When I was in elementary and junior high school, I was beaten every day for practice," Kuwata said.
"Corporal punishment is an easy way to teach," he said. Comments on the Internet have included "very logical criticism of corporal punishment" and "the words of top athletes carry weight."
[Summary of Osaka City Sakuranomiya High School]
[Summary of Osaka City Sakuranomiya High School]
The coach of the basketball club. decides the captain as a' beaten player' and leads him to commit suicide by abusing him.
And before that, I had to go to class regularly
VOLLEYBALL CLUB COACH. IF YOU DROP ONE SET, CALL EVERYONE TO THE WAREHOUSE, HIT THEM, KICK THEM.
If you talk back to me, keep hitting me until I break my nose.
BASKETBALL CLUB MEMBERS. LIVING IN TRAINING CAMPS WITHOUT PERMISSION, SUSPECTED DRINKING AND SMOKING, VIOLENCE, UNLICENSED DRIVING.
THE PRINCIPAL. HE KNEW ALL THIS, BUT HE IGNORED IT.
Graduates praise violent teachers
Parents hold meetings to encourage violent teachers
Osakans Fully Support Violent Teachers
[Summary of Osaka City Sakuranomiya High School] 2
[Summary of Osaka City Sakuranomiya High School]
Coach of the basketball club. Exceptionally worked for Sakuranomiya for 18 years. Focused on student guidance.
The captain is designated as a "beaten man" and is forced to commit suicide.
EVEN IN PHYSICAL EDUCATION CLASSES (OTHER STUDENTS) ARE ASSAULTED. NO MATTER HOW MANY TIMES I WRITE A LETTER OF APOLOGY, THE STUDENTS ARE IMMEDIATELY ASSAULTED.
VOLLEYBALL CLUB COACH. IF YOU DROP ONE SET, CALL EVERYONE TO THE WAREHOUSE, HIT THEM, KICK THEM.
If you talk back to me, keep hitting me until I break my nose.
Student lynching leads to a national newspaper article. Suspended for three months.
He returned to work after completing training and writing a letter of apology.
MEMBERS OF THE BASKETBALL CLUB. LIVING IN A PRIVATE DORMITORY WITHOUT PERMISSION FROM THE SCHOOL, DRINKING AND SMOKING, VIOLENCE AND DRIVING WITHOUT A LICENSE.
Basketball Parents' Association: Students are made to live in private dormitories without permission from the school (there is no administrator).
I DO N'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE SCHOOL OR THE BOARD OF EDUCATION EXCEPT FOR MY ADVISOR.
JAPAN BASKETBALL ASSOCIATION: NO PENALTY FOR UNLICENSED DRIVING
THE BASEBALL CLUB. WAS BANNED FROM INTERNATIONAL MATCHES FOR A MONTH AFTER A STUDENT ASSAULT LAST SUMMER.
THE PRINCIPAL. EVEN IF HE KNOWS ABOUT THE TEACHER'S ASSAULT, HE HIDES EVERYTHING.
"Teachers are not wrong," says graduates
Parents hold meetings to encourage violent teachers
Osaka citizens: "You're a good teacher, aren't you?"
Japan: Prohibition of corporal punishment under the School Education Act
World: The Convention on the Rights of the Child bans corporal punishment as child abuse (children are defined as those under 18)
Agnes. "."
なんだか、なんでも体罰体罰クレームされると先生達も大変よね。時と場合によるでしょう。先生責める前に自分の子が先生に
— isako@多摩っ子 (@isako0223) February 3, 2013
暴言吐くことをやめさせろよ
@Yaminachan けどー噛んだら殴られる。体罰だっ!!委員長なんてやめればよかったー
— あかね@じゅんじゅん★ミ (@iitennkikumori) 2013.02.03 12:41
#tvasahi 体罰反対はいいのだが、求道心を失わないような指導は維持していかなくては。武道に厳しさを失ってはいけない。
— bara (@gongitunelamp) February 3, 2013
@watabo_91 柔道の授業であいつに突き飛ばされて前受け身してくっそ痛かった。 体罰じゃー
— すぎえじゅんや (@juntabox) 2013.02.03 12:40
ゆとりは誉めてのばすタイプだから、あれですよ、もう体罰とか古いです。
— kano (@111kn111) 2013.02.03 12:40
TVで今のスポーツ指導者は、自分が選手の時に体罰有きの指導を受けてきたから、それが当たり前になっていて、それを今の選手達にどう当たればいいのかわからないと言っているが、簡単じゃないかね。「自分がやられて嫌なことは、ほかの人にもしない」子供の頃そう習わなかった?
— shinobu (@Gaow_Gaow) February 3, 2013
まあどっちのダメージに優劣があるなんて個人によるからアレだけど、体罰をしなくなっても別のグレーな方法はいくらでもあるんだよね。体罰が1番効率的なだけであって、体罰をしたら即解雇!と言われたら渋々2番3番の方法を持ち出すだけよ。生徒は結局辛いままだよね
— ゆきのん (@3_1_ykn) February 3, 2013
ただこれは部活での体罰についてだから、教育現場一般での体罰についてはどう思うのか気になるところではある
— ぐれ (@fxxk_star) 2013.02.03 12:40
これbit.ly/11svMZ5が体罰となると、学校での躾は不可能ですなwww モンスターペアレントさんもそうでないペアレントさんもこれから大変だわ そのうちに警官から拳銃や警棒も取り上げられるかもねぇ
— ぐい樽 (@gui1964) 2013.02.03 12:40
Contents
- Is a teacher who can't teach without beating incompetent?
- You don't need a leader who is sweet to you, gentle to you, and strict to your children. Please don't have a meeting while you smoke. What can you teach a weak person who can't even stand smoking during practice?
- Hiromitsu Ochiai's views on corporal punishment
- * Opinions on corporal punishment online
- Famous episode of Hidetoshi Nakata's middle school days
- Story of Giants' fan Bibiru Oki (on Fan Appreciation Day)
- It's often said that corporal punishment is love, but I never felt that it was love when I was hit.
- In amateur sports, the days of teacher-student bonding through obedience are over.
- [Summary of Osaka City Sakuranomiya High School]
- [Summary of Osaka City Sakuranomiya High School] 2
