Is corporal punishment necessary? A summary of the opinions of prominent athletes [including Masumi Kuwata and Hidetoshi Nakata].

Corporal punishment has been hard to eliminate in sports coaching, and we have compiled the opinions of prominent athletes on how it affects them with regard to their players. Masumi Kuwata and Hidetoshi Nakata's idea that "anachronistic corporal punishment coaching will never develop athletes" resonates very much with us.

Is a teacher who can't teach without beating incompetent?

awabi.2ch.net

"Corporal punishment is the easiest way to teach, due to the lack of study by the instructor, and teams and players never really become strong."
Masumi Kuwata

I've seen hundreds of teams all over Japan.
All the leaders are shouting at the children.
I don't have enough leadership to make them understand without yelling at me.
It's like talking to the people around you.
Don't you even know that?
It's kind of embarrassing, it's just too much.
Well, there are times when you have to scold them.
But you don't shout during the game, during the practice, from beginning to end.
I think that passion is great, but it's going in the wrong direction.
If you have that much passion, you should study more and acquire knowledge.
Even more scary is a leader who has knowledge but uses it incorrectly.
For both types of leaders
Since they take care of other people's precious children, they should acquire the minimum knowledge.
If you have the knowledge, I want you to use it in the right direction.
I would like to ask this in a loud voice, and I hope it will be "noticed" by now.
Masumi Kuwata
http://web.archive.org/web/20090314025316/http://kuwata-masumi.cocolog-nifty.com/blog/2009/03/post-ea9b.html

You don't need a leader who is sweet to you, gentle to you, and strict to your children. Please don't have a meeting while you smoke. What can you teach a weak person who can't even stand smoking during practice?

"Masumi Kuwata's official blog"
March 10, 2009 notice
When I was a boy, I was scolded and beaten so much that there was no day when I went to practice and was not beaten.
In an age where it is common to practice from morning to night
It was a time when people couldn't drink water even in the middle of summer.
He also drank water from toilets and puddles left after the rain.
I will play at Koshien, throw at the Giants and throw at the Majors
I think I know baseball to some extent.
Having had such an experience, I would like to ask a Japanese baseball coach of today.
It may be hard to say, but.
"Notice me." "Notice me."
You don't need a leader who is sweet to you, gentle to you, and strict to children.
Please don't have a meeting while smoking.
What can you teach a weak person who can't even hold a cigarette during practice?
It is not good to practice drinking alcohol such as beer for lunch.
What does a sweet person who can't stand alcohol until night teach children?
Strange, right?
Before you teach your children, ask someone to teach them.

Hiromitsu Ochiai's views on corporal punishment

WHAT WOULD A VICTIM THINK? "I COULD N'T HIT, I COULD N'T PROTECT" IS AN AFTER-THE-FACT ARGUMENT. WHY WOULD I GET HIT IF I GET HIT SO HARD?
Hiromitsu Ochiai

When I became manager, it was the players over there who would fight, not me and this bench, I had to stick a nail in the player without raising my hand.

Corporal Punishment Should Be Done by Incompetence -
Hiromitsu Ochiai: "You teach? It's never so easy to raise your hand."
ALL SILENT.
Denny: (Staring at the forest) Huh?
Mori: "It's easy."
Mori: "It's easy to raise your hand. If you do something wrong, I'm angry, so you can hit me."
Ochiai: "This is the easiest."
Ochiai: "What do people think when they are beaten?
IT'S AN AFTER-THE-FACT ARGUMENT, AND THEY SAY, "WHY WOULD I BE BEATEN IF I GET THAT FAR?"
And when I become manager, it's the players over there who fight, not me and this bench.
I didn't raise my hand against the players, and I stuck a nail in them. "
Ochiai: "If I raise my hand, I'll take off my uniform, so keep this promise."

* Opinions on corporal punishment online

IF THERE WAS A STUDENT WHO STOOD OUT DESPITE BEING PUNISHED, IT WAS N'T BECAUSE OF THE PUNISHMENT, IT WAS JUST BECAUSE HE WAS STRONG.

Aside from talking about corporal punishment, all Kuwata is saying is idealism.
Aside from talking about corporal punishment, all Kuwata is saying is idealism.
The Aso Giants Boys, in which this guy was involved
It is also a famous story that he was confused by the gap between Kuwata's ideal and the site.

IN KUWATA'S TIME, THERE WERE MANY THINGS LIKE BROKEN BONES, NEAR BLINDNESS AND tympanic membrane laceration.

Famous episode of Hidetoshi Nakata's middle school days

The following is a famous episode of Nakata's junior high school days.
Shinichi MINAGAWA, who was a coach of Kofu Hokuchu at that time, ordered 50 dashes as a punishment run to the students who lost the game.
' The children were unwillingly and justly punished, but only Hide stood by the bench and would not run.
I was puzzled.
"Why are you running?" he shouted.
Hide's answer was:
"I don't know why I should run. I can't accept that we have to run alone. Run with me, Mr. Minagawa. Then I'll run too."
It may be said that Hide was a problem child in a sense.
At The Time Of The Second Year Junior High School incident, if I had beaten him to stop fooling around, would the personality of Hidetoshi Nakata have been able to spread to the world?
When I think so, I sometimes get chills.
The German children always ask for an explanation about the coach's instructions at the pre-game meeting.
"Why do you fight with this system?" "Why do you use this tactic?"
On the other hand, the coach properly explains the intention of the system and tactics.
Otherwise, the German children (and the children of other European countries, if you will) will not move.
Whenever I met this kind of situation while studying in Germany, I thought that Hide had this type of stammering.
It is a unique character for a Japanese child.
His success in European football may be partly due to his European-like personality. "

KUWATA WAS THE ONLY MEMBER OF THE CLUB WHO DID N'T RAISE HIS HAND AGAINST HIS JUNIORS DURING HIS CAREER AS A producer.
KUWATA WAS THE ONLY MEMBER OF THE CLUB WHO DID N'T RAISE HIS HAND AGAINST HIS JUNIORS DURING HIS CAREER AS A producer.
BUT.
Kataoka and Tatsunami were most afraid of Kuwata.
According to Kataoka:
I don't get angry even if I make a mistake and I only say "Be careful next time" but my eyes were not smiling. It would be easier if they raised their hands instead.
I'm scared.

KUWATA IS DENYING THAT HE IS A WORTHLESS LEADER WHO DEMANDS GUTS FROM HIS CHILDREN, BUT HE DOES N'T EVEN HAVE THE GUTS TO STUDY TEACHING THEORY.

Kazushige Nagashima: 384 games, 843 at-bats, 161 hits, 18 HR OPS. 618
Masumi Kuwata: 478 games, 890 at-bats, 192 hits, 7 HR OPS. 537

The leaders at the time looked proud, saying, "I raised Kuwata."
A PERSON AS SUCCESSFUL AS KUWATA.
"I have never felt love for corporal punishment."
"I didn't want to go to the field because I didn't want to be hit."
"I don't want to remember."
"My high school days, when there was no corporal punishment, grew the most."
Well, that sounds convincing.
But the leaders at the time said, "I raised Kuwata."
AND THEN USED CORPORAL PUNISHMENT ON THE KIDS.

Story of Giants' fan Bibiru Oki (on Fan Appreciation Day)

◎ Story of Bibiru Oki, a Giants fan (on fan appreciation day)
"Bikiru Oki" (Big Dipper) is running Fan Appreciation Day.
Bibiru Oki: "Good morning!"
Goto:' Dekire' (lit a cigarette and blew smoke on a big tree)
Bibiru Oki: "Good morning!"
ABE IGNORES HER ON PURPOSE IN FRONT OF HER.
Oki greets the following players by saying, "Today, please."
However, all of them were ignored.
KIYOHARA: "Hey! How long are you going to do this?" (Microphone OFF)
Bibiru Oki "Sumimasen. yoroshiku onegaishimasu"
Goto & Motoki: "Kiyohara-san, you are so cute!"
A sweltering Yoshinobu Takahashi.
After finishing, "Good work today. Thank you!"
Pitcher Kuwata is the only one to thank him.
I heard that Uehara and Ki Sanuki, who were familiar with him, greeted him.
"This is the first time I've had such a sad experience since I've been supporting the Giants.
After all, it's not good to get too close to it even if you like it.
It's best to cheer from a distance where you don't know what's wrong with your real face. "

www3.nhk.or.jp

It's often said that corporal punishment is love, but I never felt that it was love when I was hit.

massa1005y3
massa1005y3
@massa1005y3

Contents