In-depth explanation of five contradictions and questions in "PSYCHO-PASS! PSYCHO-PASS

The anime "PSYCHO-PASS" is a high-quality crime suspense set in the near future. However, some people say that there are "quite a few inconsistencies" and that they are unable to get into the groove of watching it. Here are five elements of "PSYCHO-PASS" that are considered inconsistencies or questionable points.

I guess it's the result of sorting to the extreme.
They can't put the budget into something they won't use.

Source: blog.livedoor.jp

20 episodes

When Makishima enters the research institute in the breadbasket area, the iris recognition alone opens the gate.

The response to this on the bulletin board

Name: nameless Posted on March 08, 2013 01:38
Iris recognition security doesn't recognize an eye without pupil response.

Name: Mr. Nobody Posted: 03/08/2013 01:41
I don't care how old-fashioned the security is, it's not good enough to open with a dead eyeball.
On the other hand, we live in a high-tech world where the brain controls society.

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

4: What about basic human rights when you are isolated just because you have a high crime coefficient, even though you did not actually commit a crime! The case of

Under current Japanese law, there is a common understanding that murder is a crime, and that leaving a child at home is also a crime, and there are penalties for "acting out" beyond that line,
However, even if the crime rate is high, or even if the person is thinking of something bad, if the person is isolated in a correctional facility, it is impossible to confirm whether the person will commit a crime in the future, and isn't this "devil's proof" as to the reliability of the crime rate?

Who in the world would allow such an imperfection?
I think the public would be vehemently opposed to a world where you never know when you might become a criminal yourself...

Source: animatan.com

Right to bodily liberty (freedom of person)

Freedom from Slave Bondage and Servitude, Prohibition of Use Against Will Except for Execution of Punishment (Denial of Conscription) (Article 18)
Exhibit: wikipedia

>>I also don't understand the fact that a country that valued human rights in the first place would ignore them in 100 years.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

There has been a lot of speculation about this.

It's a world where there are no juvenile laws.
The idea of guaranteeing the safety of potential offenders is not even on the table, is it?

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

They say only 100 years, but in 100 years, a wealthy, strong military nation will become the Japan we know today.
One hundred years is enough time for change.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

Over and over again, I've said to the science fiction worldview, "That's not a good national policy!" but let's just say that such a thing is just subjective, so it's not a discussion about convenience or shit.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

5: The unusual behavior of citizens

Source: ameblo.jp

Episode 14.

Even people with an overstated crime coefficient in "Cymatic Scan" were able to roam the streets, and citizens were attacked. People who had been living under the sibylla had lost their crisis management skills and were left to be attacked.

I understand the setting of a society that assumes everyone is safe because of the sibylla system, but it would take brainwashing on an instinctive level to not even feel a sense of danger.
Even animals can sense abnormality.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

Writing on the Internet

Is it my imagination that if there was a place like 2chan or Nico Nico where you could write, the psychopaths in the citizenry would not be clear-collared...

What do you mean that at the scene of the incident, the citizens just watched the attacker because of their declining risk management skills, but on the Internet, there are many dangerous people in the kitchen!

Why isn't the internet just conveniently oppressive?

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

Various inferences have been drawn in response to this.

In the first place, people who have the initiative to report or try to help in that place would rather be caught.
Such people have aggression toward the criminals somewhere in their hearts, so they will definitely be noticed by the system.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

>Security is lax, of course.
>There are no criminals in this country.
>There's not even a lock on the house, which is foreshadowed by the fact that there's no lock on the house.

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

Is the system brainwashing the psychopaths in advance to prevent them from becoming psychopaths?
Or terrorism because they think it's not right to be controlled by the system?

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

And the Wikipedia article.
Because it is first of all impossible to erase or modify the human psyche itself,
Instead of blaming those who did not help by this bystander effect,
It is important to create a social system that does not allow the bystander effect to be triggered.
You conclude.
Sibylla is just the opposite of this.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

I don't want to know what the system is, I want to know why it was introduced and why everyone is accepting it.
Maybe they're all brainwashed or something?

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

minamina6
minamina6
@minamina6

Related Articles

PSYCHO-PASS Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

PSYCHO-PASS Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

The setting is Japan in the near future, where artificial intelligence and the Sibura system are considered absolute law. This work, which depicts detectives cracking down on violent crimes, was produced by the splendid tag team of Katsuyuki Motohiro, Gen Urobuchi, Akira Amano, and Production I.G. It is a TV anime and theater version that began broadcasting in 2012. Shinya Kugami, a detective in pursuit of the mysterious "Maxima," a man who continues to evade the surveillance system and work behind the scenes in heinous crimes, becomes a criminal himself in the course of his investigations.

Read Article

PSYCHO-PASS Psycho-Pass 3 (anime) spoiler commentary and discussion

PSYCHO-PASS Psycho-Pass 3 (anime) spoiler commentary and discussion

PSYCHO-PASS Psycho-Pass 3" is the third season of the original TV anime series produced by Pruduction I.G. The first season aired on Fuji TV's "Noitamina" program from October 2012. Set in Tokyo, where the "Sibular System" has been introduced to measure all kinds of human psychological states and personality tendencies as numerical values, the "Public Security Bureau," a police organization under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of Health and Welfare, devotes its daily activities to maintaining public safety under the Sibular System. The film's ensemble drama that follows the conflicts and dilemmas of the characters and its near-future case-solving story have been well received both in Japan and abroad.

Read Article

PSYCHO-PASS" Quotes! Many memorable lines from Shinya Kugami and Akira Tsunemori! [PSYCHO-PASS

PSYCHO-PASS" Quotes! Many memorable lines from Shinya Kugami and Akira Tsunemori! [PSYCHO-PASS

Here is a compilation of the best quotes and lines from PSYCHO-PASS, carefully selected from the first season, the second season, and the 2015 movie version. They include Shinya Kugami's "The only way to get out of being deprived is to be the one who takes" and Akemi Tsunemori's "Society doesn't choose the future of people. People choose the future of society. I believe that." These are all words that will touch your heart if you are familiar with this work.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of the watchdog, Akemi Tsunemori (PSYCHO-PASS: PSYCHO-PASS)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of the watchdog, Akemi Tsunemori (PSYCHO-PASS: PSYCHO-PASS)

PSYCHO-PASS: Psycho-Pass" is a Japanese anime produced by Production I.G. The manga adaptation of the first season of the TV anime series "Akane Tsunemori" aired on Fuji Television Network's "Noitamina" from October 2012 to March 2013. It depicts the activities and struggles of the people of the Public Security Bureau in Japan, a society that has become less stressful due to the numbers measured by the "Sibura System," in which all human emotions are quantified.

Read Article

In-depth commentary and discussion of Shinya Cunningham (PSYCHO-PASS)

In-depth commentary and discussion of Shinya Cunningham (PSYCHO-PASS)

Shinya Kogami is a character in the "PSYCHO-PASS" anime series, and is an enforcer in the Public Security Bureau's Criminal Investigation Department Section 1. Originally a surveillance officer, he was demoted to executive officer after his crime rate skyrocketed while investigating the "Specimen Case" three years ago, dating back to the sixth episode of the series, "The Return of the Mad Prince. The "Specimen Case" remains unsolved, and Cunningham continues to investigate the case. Although he sometimes clashes with Akemi Tsunemori, a new watchdog, due to their different ways of thinking, a sense of solidarity develops as they work together, and they often work together as a well-matched duo.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Soukyu no Fafner Dead Aggressor / RIGHT OF LEFT (anime)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Soukyu no Fafner Dead Aggressor / RIGHT OF LEFT (anime)

Original anime planned and produced by XEBEC in 2004 with the keywords "island, robot, ensemble drama, boys and girls". The setting is a near-future world invaded by an unknown life form called "Festum. In the year 2146 A.D., Festum invades the isolated island of Ryugujima, the only paradise in the world. Makabe Ikki, guided by Minashiro Soji, becomes the pilot of "Fafner," a manned "thought-controlled, sensory-controlled" weapon, and is caught up in a fierce battle for the survival of the human race.

Read Article

Summary of REVENGER spoilers and discussion

Summary of REVENGER spoilers and discussion

REVENGER" is a 2023 original anime film set in Nagasaki at the end of the Edo period (1603-1868) about the activities of a "Ribenjiya," a commissioned assassination businessman. It is produced by game maker Nitroplus and film company Shochiku, famous for its period dramas. Raizo Ryoma, a Satsuma clan samurai who has slain his fiancée's father in a plot hatched by his superiors, meets a maki-e artist named Yuhan Usui in Nagasaki. Usui, together with his friends Tetsuya Murakami, Grebe, and Soji, runs a convenience store where they perform assassinations for money, and Raizo, who has nowhere else to go, joins them.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Expelled from Paradise

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Expelled from Paradise

Rakuen Tsukiho -Expelled from Paradise- is an original anime film directed by Seiji Mizushima and written by Gen Urobuchi, released in 2014. The full CG anime was highly praised for its quality, and a sequel was announced for 2024. After being repeatedly cracked, the cyber world DIVA dispatches a system security agent, Angela Balzac, to the surface to catch the culprits. Soon Angela meets a cracker who is so unexpected that she throws herself into the battle to protect him.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Saya's Song (game)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Saya's Song (game)

Saya no Uta" is an adult game for PC released in December 2003 by the game company Nitroplus. The main character, Ikunori Sagisaka, was in an accident one day, and although she miraculously survived, all of her senses have changed drastically from what they were before the accident. The scenery looks like a pig's entrails, people look like strange lumps of meat, and she is on the verge of insanity. Script by Gen Urobuchi of "Puella Magi Madoka Magica" fame.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Soukyu no Fafner EXODUS (anime)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Soukyu no Fafner EXODUS (anime)

A sequel to the "Fafner of the Blue Sky" series produced in 2015, this is the second season of the TV anime series and builds on the story up to the movie version. In the year 2150 A.D., the battle between mankind and Festum has entered a new phase: the first generation of Fafner pilots, including Ikki, now 19 years old, have retired and are moving on to new paths. On the day a human military transport plane visited Ryugu Island, the last hours of the war began to move.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Oniwakigai -The Cyber Slayer- (game)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Oniwakigai -The Cyber Slayer- (game)

The Cyber Slayer" is an 18-rated novel adventure game based on a martial arts novel released by Nitroplus on March 29, 2002. In 2011, a remake version of the game was released with the rating lowered to 15 or older. The main character, Kong Tao-la, is trying to take revenge on her killers and integrate her sister's consciousness after her beloved sister, Kong Zui-lei, is brutally murdered and her consciousness is divided into five parts and transplanted into a guinoid.

Read Article

Aldnoah Zero (ALDNOAH.ZERO) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Aldnoah Zero (ALDNOAH.ZERO) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Aldnoah Zero" is an original robot animation co-produced by A-1 Pictures and TROYCA. It is a two-part series, with the first part airing from July to September 2014 and the second part airing from January to March 2015. It depicts a war between Earthlings and Martians. The two main characters, Inaho Kaizuka, an Earthling, and Slaine Troyard, an Earthling who serves the Martians, and a Martian princess, change the course of the war.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Soukyu no Fafner HEAVEN AND EARTH (anime)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Soukyu no Fafner HEAVEN AND EARTH (anime)

The film version of "Blue Sky Fafner" was released in December 2010. It takes place two years after the TV animation series, in the year 2148 AD. Peace was supposed to have been preserved. People were living in the peaceful days they had regained after making many sacrifices. In the midst of such a life, Ikki Makabe was waiting for the day when his promise to Soji Minashiro would be fulfilled. On the day a ship is launched to Ryugu Island, the temporary peace is broken and the boys and girls are once again caught up in the whirlpool of battle.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Ghost in the Shell ARISE and Ghost in the Shell: The New Movie (Kise/Ubukata version of Ghost in the Shell)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Ghost in the Shell ARISE and Ghost in the Shell: The New Movie (Kise/Ubukata version of Ghost in the Shell)

Ghost in the Shell ARISE" is a theatrical anime released in June 2013. The story takes place before the unification of Public Security Section 9 and follows the events surrounding the unidentified hacker Firestarter. Ghost in the Shell: The New Movie" is a sequel to "Ghost in the Shell ARISE" and will be released nationwide in June 2015. The story is about the connection between the Firestarter and Motoko Kusanagi's birth secret. The "Ghost in the Shell" series is directed by Kazuya Kise and written by Ubukata Tow.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion summary for Kamen Rider Armor

Spoiler commentary and discussion summary for Kamen Rider Armor

Kamen Rider Gaimu (仮面ライダー鎧武) is the 15th special effects program of the Heisei "Masked Rider" series, which depicts the activities of heroes who fight the invasion of the Otherworldly Forest. It is also the name of the hero that the main character transforms into in the work. Kota Kuzuha, a boy who helps his family by working part-time, wanders into a mysterious forest one day and obtains a mysterious belt that transforms the wearer into a superhero. At the same time, other young people in town acquire similar belts and misuse them to fulfill their own ambitions. Kota sometimes fights with them, and sometimes cooperates with them, as he confronts the world's crisis brought on by the mysterious forest.

Read Article

Thunderbolt Fantasy: East Rift Valley (San Juan) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Thunderbolt Fantasy: East Rift Valley (San Juan) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Thunderbolt Fantasy Tōri Chien-yūki" is a Taiwan-Japan joint project of martial arts fantasy puppet theater. Gen Urobuchi, well-known for his work on "Puella Magi Madoka Magica," was in charge of the original idea, script, and general supervision of this Japan-Taiwan joint film project, which created a new form of puppet theater based on the Taiwanese folk art of "Mochougeki," or puppet theater. It is a new "Hotei Gekijo" that combines analog techniques in which actual humans move puppets and staging that uses computer graphics and other techniques. It is a martial arts fantasy puppet show that revolves around a weapon group known as "shinkai makai," which is said to exhibit the power of warriors.

Read Article

GODZILLA Planet of the Monsters (Anigoji) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

GODZILLA Planet of the Monsters (Anigoji) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

GODZILLA: PLANET OF THE MONSTERS" is an animated film based on the monster movie "Godzilla" from 1954. The screenplay was written by Gen Urobuchi and directed by Kobun Shizuno and Hiroyuki Seshita. Humanity is now threatened by "monsters," giant creatures that have appeared on the earth due to environmental changes. Twenty-two years later, the film depicts the battle against Godzilla, led by the main character Haruo, in order to restore the Earth to human control.

Read Article

GODZILLA 決戦機動増殖都市(アニゴジ)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

GODZILLA 決戦機動増殖都市(アニゴジ)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『GODZILLA 決戦機動増殖都市(アニゴジ)』とは、2018年公開の日本のアニメーション映画である。監督は静野孔文と瀬下寛之。 通称アニゴジと言われている3Ⅾアニメーション作品であり、全三部作で構成されている。 ゴジラが出現したことで、人類は滅亡の危機に見舞われていた。主人公のハルオは、生き残った仲間やフツアと呼ばれる民族たちと協力し、再びゴジラに挑むのだった。 見所はフツアの民族との交流や、ナノメタルという大きな希望とそれに伴う犠牲に苦悩するハルオの心の葛藤である。

Read Article

GODZILLA 星を喰う者(アニゴジ)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

GODZILLA 星を喰う者(アニゴジ)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『GODZILLA 星を喰う者』とは1954年から続く怪獣映画『ゴジラ』を原作とした全3部作のアニメ映画作品。本作は最終作で、2018年に公開された。脚本は虚淵玄、監督は静野孔文、瀬下寛之。 ゴジラシティ壊滅後、ハルオたち人類はゴジラを倒す術を失う。ゴジラを倒す唯一の望みが、ギドラ降臨であるが、ギドラは星を守る神ではなく、破壊の神であった。 再び平和を取り戻すべく、ハルオたち人類の戦いを描く。本作は、ハルオの心の葛藤が描かれている。迫力ある戦闘シーンも魅力である。

Read Article

Summary of Servants of the Fate Series

Summary of Servants of the Fate Series

The "Fate series" is the collective name for TYPE-MOON's "Fate/stay night" and other games, anime, manga, and other works. The series depicts the "Holy Grail War," a battle royale of sorcerers seeking the "Holy Grail," which is said to grant any wish, and the people involved in it. Servants are messengers summoned by sorcerers for the Holy Grail War, and are composed of enormous magical power. Originally, the invoked spirits and phantoms were too powerful to be handled as messengers, so they were forced into a vessel called a class.

Read Article

PSYCHO-PASS: Newly edited version" additional scene summary

PSYCHO-PASS: Newly edited version" additional scene summary

If you missed the new edited version, don't miss it! Did you know that scenes that were not in the first season of Psycho-Pass have been added to the "New Edited Version"? The additional scenes, which serve as a supplement to the main story, depict in detail the psychology of the characters that was difficult to understand. What was Makishima thinking just before he confronted Cunningham? What was Cunningham thinking when he was investigating the case? And so on. The more you look at the new cuts, the more you will feel the intensity of the excitement of the main story!

Read Article

Contents