To Earth... (To Terra) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

To Earth..." is a Japanese science fiction manga by Keiko Takemiya and derivative works based on it. It depicts the loneliness and conflicts of two boys, Jomy, the head of the new human race Mew, and Keith, the head of the old human race.
Derivative works include an animated film released in April 1980, an animated television series (24 episodes) broadcast from April 2007 to September of the same year, a radio drama, and a spin-off manga.
It won the 9th Nebula Award in the comic category and the 25th Shogakukan Manga Award in the boys and girls category.

Contents

The human spirit is fragile, lacking the courage and intelligence to face the truth... sometimes shattered by emotions. So why are you so foolish and selfish when you protect your weak spirit with taboos? (Original Part II)

A line Mother Eliza said to Keith Anian when he learned the secret of his birth. What she is saying is just a program, but its meaning is something that cannot be ignored. The creator of the Mother System must feel that way. It is the line that led Keith to put himself on the side of the "stupid humans" being ruled over, rather than being the chosen leader of the Mother System. It is painful to see Keith, who can only rebel against Mother's domination by playing the role of a foolish human being.

As time goes by, I'm alone... ...and I only exist once... (Part 2 of the original story)

Jomy Marquis Singh's line (or more accurately, poem) when he sensed a thought that belonged to no one.
No matter how many friends, family members, and associates one is surrounded by, one will always die alone. Even if there were a concept of reincarnation, I feel the philosophy that you only live once now. While shōnen manga is dominated by passionate friendships and teamwork, this work is unique in that loneliness is a key word, and the dialogue is both subtle and philosophical.

...The Sun Dazzles (Original Part II)

This is the line when Keith returns to the station after daring to dispose of Shiroe.
The tears are filled with a variety of feelings: he killed with his own hands a being who could have been his best friend; he would have killed her with his own hands if he could not be her best friend; he has chosen to become Mother's slave; and he longs for the light of the sun, despite his own sordid feelings.

Mother...you are as idealistic as I remember you to be... (Original Part III)

This is a line Jomie says when she sees the young people who are excited about pregnancy and childbirth and is worried. To Jomy, it seemed as if Karina and the others were taking it easy with their pregnancy and childbirth, as if they were playing a game. Jomy had hoped that Carina and her family would have a normal family, raise their children in a normal way, and find happiness in a normal way, but Carina thought of "mother" as a profession. She had become a nurse, and childbirth was part of her medical practice. Jomy's parents are also adoptive parents by profession, so it is not a mistake.
This is a very remarkable line, considering that many couples in the real world consider everything from love to marriage to pregnancy and childbirth as an event.

No more than human beings need to be human (Original Part IV)

Keith's answer when asked by Matsuka if he would attack Mew in Nazca.
Keith's reference to "more than human" refers to both Mew and computer control, but Matsuka did not take it that way. The difference between Keith and Matsuka is exactly the same composition as the difference between the Grand Mother and the Solaid military base, which relentlessly attacked with warhead missiles when the Grand Mother only ordered them to "attack.

They will fear you as humans abhor Miu Miu. But you must work. Fight... for Mew until your strength is exhausted.

Jomie's line against the Nazca child, who is hated by his Miu Miu compatriots for his too-high fighting ability. It is enough to make even black companies run away barefoot against children who are only three years old. To show the Nazca child, who has nowhere to go, the meaning of life, he must say something as harsh as this. Just as Jomie used to be continuously ruined by the elders.

Evil! Man is an evil creature. You're going to lead the earth to ruin again! We've built a controlled society! Humanity will never walk down that road again! (Original Part 4)

A line said just before Terraz number 5, the center of Ataraxia, was destroyed by Jomy. If we knew that all children in the SD era were born from Terraz, we would feel more justified in Terraz's desperate attempt to protect its children. In other words, destruction of Terraz = fetal killing and abortion. Jomy destroyed Terraz knowingly.
In the original work and the movie version, there is no direct depiction of Terraz protecting the fetus, but in the TV animation, many small monoliths are placed around Terraz, and Jomy says, "This is our home," so we can assume that these monoliths are artificial wombs.
This is a rare scene in which abortion, a taboo subject in all ages, is depicted in a shōnen manga.

Oh! Of course it is! Man must never again go astray. Each one of us must live with the earth, with water, with sun, with plants, with animals, like the ancients! ...Machines must be used only to maintain balance with the earth and with nature. Machines must not think! They must not become human! Never again (Original Part IV)

Jomie's answer to Terraz 5's refusal. The logic that machines must be tools is certainly justified. But is it the fault of machines and tools that people make mistakes? We must ask the question. As Soldier Blue once said.
Jomie says things like "grow plants and animals," but in the original Station version, students have pets, grow flowers, and pursue hobbies in their own rooms. It is not clear whether Jomie, who flunked the adult test and does not attend the Station, knows this.
It is shocking to see the protagonist of a juvenile cartoon appealing for vindication by killing the computer that is protecting the child, along with the child itself.

Physis was born from artificial cells. It had no parents or children. Besides, she could not even open her eyes. She was a failure, a female body without fertility. Blue saw such a physis as a goddess between human and Mew. It was a kind thought.

Jomie, who has learned the secret of Physis' birth, expresses her feelings toward Soldier Blue, who has kept the secret a secret from her.
The line is full of expressions that could be accused of sexual harassment, such as "a woman without fertility," "blind and a failure," etc., but it is a statement that calls into question the conventional wisdom that fertility makes a woman a woman.
The fact that Physis is not a mew and that her abilities are also a given proves that Blue has been lying to Physis, but it also raises the question of whether it is okay to tell a lie if it does not hurt anyone.

Don't you feel it, Altera? Do you feel that you are a part of the unlimited power (energy) floating in the universe (Part 4 of the original story)?

Toonyi's line after having a baby with Altera, one of the Nazca children, who cries that she no longer wants to fight as a tool for killing people. The Nazca child is hated by Mew's compatriots and treated as a tool by Jomy, whom she adores as her creator. In the original story, the Nazca child is as sterile as Physis. Because they have no contact with people, they convey the sadness of seeking contact with the world itself.

The act of procreation here refers to the act in which two people use psychokinesis to fix elements in the air to create a sperm and an egg, fertilize them, and cause cell division to create a fetus.
The fact that even Nazca's child, with all her knowledge and strength, had a child without having sexual intercourse is an important scene that leads to the hypothesis that human sexual intercourse may not exist under the SD regime, where artificial insemination by computer is the norm, but it was never filmed due to ethical concerns.

I'm glad I followed him. I'm satisfied. (Original Part IV)

On the eve of the peace negotiations with Miu Miu, Keith returns from visiting Sam and opens up to Matsuka for the first time, murmuring that he is glad that she told him about Sam's death. At this time, Matsuka brewed coffee with her faltering hands, and Keith drank only half of it before leaving the room. From this scene, it was established among fans that Matsuka was good at making coffee.

Keith had been obsessed with coffee since his Station days. There is a scene in the Station section where he ordered Sam a "hot mocha black, not instant" coffee. The reason he left half of the mocha coffee behind is that he was not in the mood for a coffee break, but he had no choice but to drink it because it was brewed for him, and the coffee had a soothing effect, even if it was bad, on Keith, who was depressed.
For Matska, who had never been able to get close to Keith, the fact that he was able to read his mind and drink bad coffee was the greatest joy of all.

Humans are will-less children who have been fawned over and nurtured by the Mother. They are the unfortunate children whose eyes, ears and mouth are closed and who do not know it... but the rebellious Mew and his friends can see it. As the form of the enemy... that is why I have come this far... to destroy you! (Original Part 4)

A line said by Jomy when she went into battle with the Grand Mother and was attacked first by the Mother.
Blind mother's love is unhappy for the child. A child who is not loved by its mother is also unhappy. A child cannot choose its parents. But they can choose to be separated from them, to be subservient to them, or to take other measures. Jomy, who was not loved by his mother, chose to kill her. Whether it was out of love, hatred, or the future of humanity and Mieux is a matter for each of us to consider.

In the original story, during the battle between mankind and Mew, Keith told the representatives of each country that if they could rewrite the Grandmother's program, they should try it, but in the end, no one, not even Keith, did it. Even at the peace negotiations, Keith did not propose rewriting the Mother System program, nor did Jomy. Submission or death. He could only choose between the two extremes. This narrow-mindedness led to the downfall of Jomy and Keith.

go-1010986831289272165607
go-1010986831289272165607
@go-1010986831289272165607

Contents