Don't be fooled by all the reviews of this one by the memory buffs! It's a piece of crap even if you play it now!
Good points.
Boss battles are very enjoyable with various variations including special commands.
It is fun to search for a strategy for each battle, and it is hard to get bored.
Because it is not ATB, you can think about the strategy carefully during the boss battles.
This is the only point in this game that can be praised properly. If only here, it is a god game.
Unique worldview based on the sea and water.
I didn't like it much, but it is definitely unique.
Graphics are good considering the era.
[Bad points
Field
The main road
The biggest problem of this work
There are almost no branching paths or other exploration elements, and you are forced to walk along a straight path with no way to go back.
There is no element of exploration at all.
Movies are interspersed everywhere you go, so you are forced to repeat the process of "walking down a straight path and watching a movie.
- (This improves somewhat after you get the airship, but it is too slow.
- If the map were wider like the Nagi Plain, the feeling of being forced to walk along a single road would be better...
The movement is too slow.
Riding a chocobo makes it faster, but there are very few places where you can ride it.
Encounter rate is high.
At the end of the game, you can get equipment with "no encounters," but it is very difficult to obtain.
Even if you can get it, the slow movement becomes a bottleneck.
The puzzles in the temple are not intuitive and unreasonable.
The same sphere can have different effects depending on where it is used. Therefore, the effects of spheres are unpredictable, and one has to actually use them to understand their effects.
In other words, it is necessary to make a total search in order to solve the puzzle. It is unreasonable and does not work as a puzzle.
BATTLE
Normal battles are monotonous and laborious.
In this work, there is usually one attribute per character and one weak point per enemy, making it necessary to switch members almost every time according to the enemy.
In addition, when you hit a weak point, you can almost always defeat the enemy with a single blow.
The game is fun in the beginning, but the enemies of different colors all share the same weak points, and the role of each character is too fixed in the form of "only this character's attack works on this enemy, and that character can one-punch it".
It's like playing "rock-paper-scissors" from the middle of the game, and it's monotonous and unenjoyable.
For example, in the case of Pokémon, Water-type Pokémon are weak against Grass-type Pokémon, but if they learn Freeze Beam, they will be able to fight against Grass-type Pokémon.
Also, since a Pokémon can be pushed around by type-matching compensation without going to the trouble of exploiting its weaknesses, there is no need to necessarily switch Pokémon just because it cannot exploit a weakness.
This makes it fun to train Pokémon to learn type-matching moves and moves that can exploit weaknesses, and fun to use these moves in battle.
Because the Sphere board, which will be discussed later, takes away the freedom of training, you basically can't win against enemies who are not weak, and you are forced to do the same thing over and over again, which is a lot of work.
When "capture" becomes available at the end of the game, the monotony of the game is somewhat reduced as the player is required to fight with capture incorporated in the game.
However, the "capture" function requires the player to kill the same enemy over and over again, so the game still has a strong sense of work if the player tries to play it too hard.
The process of continuously targeting specific enemies is incompatible with the random encounters, and it is frustrating when the target monster does not appear.
For example, with Pokémon, catching a single rare Pokémon is enough, and there is the fun of being able to use the Pokémon you catch in battle.
In contrast, the only advantage of "capture" in this title is the ability to fight hidden bosses, and in order to bring out the hidden bosses, you need to capture various monsters one by one, which is not worth the effort and return.
The summoner's performance is long.
Even in quick mode, it is still long.
Especially in "Summoner Battle", it is fatally slow as both sides use summons against each other
Only the character who has acted once gets experience.
As mentioned above, there are many "only this character's attack works against this enemy" patterns, so if you don't train your characters evenly, it will be troublesome later on.
However, in order to raise all the characters, it is necessary to repeatedly "switch characters and defend", which is tedious!
Elements of training
The sphere board has little flexibility and is simply a hassle.
Every time you level up, you have to open the sphere board from the menu, move your character, and put a sphere on the character. It's a tedious process.
At first glance, it looks like there is a lot of freedom in training, but in reality, skills are aligned in a straight line and there is no freedom at all.
- Toward the end of the game, you finally get to enter a branch, which gives you a little more freedom, but it is too short to be enjoyable.
What you are doing as a result is just erasing the freedom from the traditional job change and making it needlessly tedious.
The traditional job change was better because it was more flexible and automatic.
At the very least, it would have been nice if it advanced automatically every time you leveled up. ......
The collection of materials is a hassle.
Only a small percentage of the materials used for modifying weapons and strengthening summons are sold in stores.
Most of the materials need to be earned through drops, stealing, mini-games, etc.
The number of materials required is extremely high, and it is difficult to collect materials until the end of the game, so you cannot freely enjoy weapon modification and summoner enhancement.
Due to the single track and no backtracking, even if you learn the drop patterns and create a place to earn money, you will not be able to return to that place for a while as the story progresses, so it is difficult to earn money efficiently unless you get an airship.
And after obtaining the airship, the need for materials itself will diminish, since you can obtain "Seventh Day Weapons," which do not require weapon modification, and summonses so powerful that they do not need to be strengthened.
Weapon modification is pointless.
Collecting materials is very tedious, as indicated above, and not something that can be done on the road.
The most powerful weapon, the Seventh Day Weapon, cannot be modified because its slot is filled.
And since the Seventh Day weapon is stronger than any weapon made by weapon modification, I did not feel the need to do weapon modification, even in a challenging play.
...Summoner enhancements are overshadowed.
As the story progresses, stronger and stronger summons join the game, so there is no need to strengthen a single summoner in the middle of the story. Or rather, even if you do strengthen it, it will be mostly useless.
The summons that join at the end of the storyline have almost all powerful skills from the beginning, so the only thing you have to do is to put on Caerala, which can be learned from high potions sold in stores.
CINARIOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
The first central question ends without any solution.
The biggest problem of this work (2)
The first central question for the main character, Tida, is to "return to Zanarkand.
He follows Yuna on her journey because he believes that it was Shin who brought him to Spira, and that if he follows Shin, he might be able to figure out how to return home.
Despite this, there are almost no scenes in which Teada is searching for a way to return home, and the central question is not functioning properly.
In the end, the central question disappears for a certain reason.
As a result, Tida takes a certain action on her own, which ruins the efforts of the heroine Yuna.
It is a badly made and bad scenario with a bad aftertaste.
The storyline up to the middle of the film is boring and plain.
Basically, it is monotonous to follow Yuna's journey.
As mentioned above, the central question "Return to Zanarkand" does not change at all until the end of the game.
The field is a straight path, and Teda knows almost nothing about it until the end of the game, so it is boring to just follow along as she is told.
The characters are unpleasant.
Tida.
As mentioned above, he is the worst kind of man, who makes his own decisions and wastes Yuna's efforts.
Aaron.
He knows everything from the beginning, but he doesn't tell the other members about it.
- An incompetent man whose pride is unnecessarily high.
Kimari
A character who has nothing to show until the middle of the game, and just says things that we don't understand.
Although she does have a bit of a scene towards the end of the game, even with that, she is still the same in the story, and I don't feel that she has any reason to exist.
The only character who can freely choose his route on the Sphere board.
This is the only character in the system who can freely choose his/her route on the Sphere board. All characters should do that.
The sob story is too blatant to make me cry.
The characters are not well described in general, and there are many unnatural points and contradictions in the setting.
I won't go into specific examples of these because it would be a spoiler, but they are particularly bad in terms of lack of description and inconsistencies.
The setting is broken.
In this work, there is a setting that "dead people stay in this world unless they are sent to another world," but the setting is fatally broken by this.
If the dead stay in this world and can do anything, even physical interference, there is no need to even send them to the other world, except for evil people.
If they can live a normal life after death, there is no point in even sticking to life.
(In fact, Seymour died thinking that way in his work. Aaron didn't seem to have any particular anguish because he was a dead man.)
If there is no point in clinging to life, there is no need to force Shin to defeat him.
In other words, this film is light on the value of life. It's worse than "It's all right, I'll come back to life with Dragon Ball.
With such a view of life and death, the "preparedness to die" does not convey the weight of that preparedness.
(There is a scene in which he says, "If you stay dead for a long time, you will turn into a demon," but Ebon and Aaron show no signs of turning into demons, and there is a scene in which he says, "Dead people are stronger than the living because they don't die.)
Also, the multiple and diverse "actually, that person was a dead person" development in the story at the end of the film is one-patterned and boring.
UI-UI-UI-UI
Equipment UI
Equipment cannot be organized and is cumbersome to manage.
There are no scroll bars or scrolling aids, such as page forward, so when there is a lot of equipment, it takes a lot of time just to scroll through it.
- At the very least, I would like to see a function that separates equipment by type.
The poor UI makes it difficult to sell items, even though the item slots fill up quickly as enemies drop more and more weapons.
No event skip.
It's a hassle especially when you have to fight the boss again.
The bosses are a lot of fun to try again and again, but the movie interruptions during each attempt are a nuisance.
Others
Mini-games are boring.
Chocobo related games (especially chocobo races) have a lot of unreasonable elements, and luck is more important than play skill.
The balls and seagulls are placed in such a way that, depending on their placement and timing, you will never be able to see them in time. In other words, it is a game of luck where you have to pray not to get hit.
Avoiding lightning is just a hardship.
It's no longer a roll of the dice.
The music is not very good.
Normal battle music is dull.
- The music is supposed to be the most frequently heard music in RPGs, but it never catches the ear.
There are too many piano songs.
- This may be a narrow-minded viewpoint, but I can see the artifice of "just play the piano and you'll be moved".
Many of the same phrases are used over and over again. It goes beyond "catchy," and it is just too much and tiresome.
However, these problems are minor compared to the other problems, and most of the event songs are not so bad or bad at all.
Overall Rating
Story ☆1
Central Question is not functioning properly.
Direction ☆1
Too much lack of description
Character ☆1
The main character does nothing and is selfish and unpleasant
Training ☆1
No freedom, just a hassle
Map ☆1
Literally a long and narrow single road, no fun whatsoever.
Battle (small fry) ☆2
Monotonous rock-paper-scissors-scissors
Battle (Boss) ☆5+
Each boss has special commands, and it's very fun to make a strategy every time.
Music ☆3
Graphics ☆4
UI ☆2
Poor UI for equipment, no event skip
Loading ☆3
Tempo ☆1
Slow movement and high encaustic rate. No event skip.
Mini-games ☆1
Chocobo race is a game of luck.
Each of them is rated out of 5 points, and "5+" is particularly good item.
A monotonous game where you are forced to walk down a straight path, play post-race rock-paper-scissors when enemies appear, and watch a boring movie when you arrive.
The boss battles are interesting to a point, but not worth the intense stress of the rest of the game.
The story is unnatural and contradictory, and the more you try to examine it, the more rough edges you will find.
Above all, the protagonist's selfishness and dragging the party down is off-putting.
He is like a hero of the Naro type, who is transferred from another world, and who, despite all his talk and poor effort, succeeds by accident and is trusted by his friends.
This is a bad work that I can't recommend today, even if it was back in the days when movies had high value.
