The Need for Magical Girls
In the story, "magical girls" are a system created by incubators to obtain human emotions as energy. In the process, magical girls despair and become witches, and new magical girls are created to defeat these witches.
Since the incubator's purpose is also for the greater good of the universe, its actions cannot be denied. Of course, it is wrong for a girl to be sacrificed for that purpose.
The problem is the position of the magical girl and Madoka's wish in the last episode. Madoka wished for the extinction of witches from the past to the future, but at the same time, she also wished for the girl to remain a magical girl forever.
In the resulting reborn world, instead of witches, magical beasts appear as new enemies for the magical girls to defeat. Magical girls are also rescued by the truth of the circle before they become witches.
But to begin with. Magical girls and witches are a system created to prolong the life of the universe, not for the sake of girls. Madoka's wish is almost a personal abuse of that system.
Also, some magical girls do not want to fight, and some did not become magical girls because they wanted to. It is possible that there are girls who wish to quit the magical girl system, although they are not mentioned in the anime. For them, the Circle of Reason is not salvation, but hell.
The wish to "stay a Puella Magi forever" is not a wish shared by all Puella Magi, but rather a personal desire of Madoka. It seems more like a desire than a good intention.
Fundamentally, if incubators could find a way to obtain emotional energy without the need for magical girls, the existence of magical girls would be unnecessary. And if ordinary people have the ability to resist magical beasts, there will be no need for girls to become magical girls.
