Tearing Saga" Fire Emblem plagiarism trial.

A summary of incidents involving Tearing Saga, a game created by the developers of Fire Emblem after they went independent. This title was sued by Nintendo for plagiarism due to the continuation of Fire Emblem characters and similar game systems.

What is the Tearing Saga?

Tearing Saga: Battle of Jutna Heroes" is a simulation RPG developed by Tirnanog and released by Enterbrain in 2001.
It was an orthodox game in which players fought enemies by moving their characters, and during battles, the screen would switch to show RPG-like battle scenes.

Very similar to Fire Emblem.

The initial name of the game was "Emblem Saga" when it was first announced. In addition, all of the preliminary information was reminiscent of a clear connection to the FE series.

Source: www26.atwiki.jp

To begin with, the company that produced Tiering Saga, Tir Na Nog, was originally established independently by one of the developers of Fire Emblem, Intelligent Systems.
That developer was Shozo Kaga, who is known as the "creator of Fire Emblem.

Since the company was established with Mr. Kaga as its representative, it seems inevitable that it would bear some resemblance to Fire Emblem.
However! This led to the court case described below.

Kaga was initially working on "Emblem Saga" as a complete sequel to the FE series, and in an announcement in Famitsu, he implied that "Cheney" from "The Dark Dragon and the Sword of Light" would make an appearance, and said that he wanted to include as many other characters as possible.

Source: ja.wikipedia.org

1. The name of the weapon is the same and even the performance is the same!

When playing "Tearing Saga," it is clear that the characters, worldview, and gameplay are very similar to the "Fire Emblem" series.

For example, there are several weapons with exactly the same name and performance, or with slightly different names.
The "Rapier," which is very powerful against cavalry and heavy knights, and the Armor Killer Hammer, which is effective against heavy knights. The rapier is also common in that it is a weapon exclusive to the main character.

2. Game systems also have much in common.

The system is very similar to that of "FE Gaiden".
The main similarities are the whole-map movement, the alternating control of two armies, and the presence of monsters among the enemies.

Source: www26.atwiki.jp

3. Characters in common with Fire Emblem.

Interviews about Chaney, who appears in FE: The Dark Dragon and the Sword of Light and FE: The Mystery of the Crest, will be in this film as well.

Source: www26.atwiki.jp

As of the trial version, Lunan's hair color was blue (see reference). At that time, all the main characters in the FE series had blue hair, except for one spin-off, and the image of FE main character = blue hair was well established among fans.
Other characters include a character who resembles Caeda, the heroine of "The Dark Dragon" *29, an axe wielder whose name is the same as a character of a similar class in FE *30, characters in familiar positions in the FE series such as the three Pegasus sisters, and a character with the same special skill *31 as the aforementioned Chaney.

Source: www26.atwiki.jp

While not an exact match, several characters share similarities with the Fire Emblem series.
The legends that appear in the game also include the names of places that were once set in Fire Emblem.

Few place names are covered by FE *32, but some continents with names reminiscent of the settings of certain FE series appear in the old stories. It is also a place where there is no necessity to name it.

Source: www26.atwiki.jp

Nintendo sued for copyright infringement and went to "FE/TS Trial"!

Tearing Saga" shares not only the same system and items, but even the same characters as Fire Emblem.
The problem is that these items are "unauthorized by Nintendo and Intelligent Systems.
You would think for a moment, "Well, he said it in an interview, so doesn't Nintendo have permission to do this?" But all of these games were made without official permission.

However, all of these games were created without official permission, and no matter how many developers you once belonged to, if you create a similar game without permission, it is plagiarism and pacri.
Of course, Nintendo would not remain silent, so they filed a lawsuit against Tir Na Nog and Enterbrain.

Nintendo and IS filed a lawsuit against Tyrnanog and Enterbrain seeking an injunction and damages for the release of "Tearing Saga" as a violation of the Unfair Competition Prevention Act and copyright infringement.

Source: ja.wikipedia.org

greentea3580
greentea3580
@greentea3580

Related Articles

Images of previous packages of the FE series [Fire Emblem].

Images of previous packages of the FE series [Fire Emblem].

The Fire Emblem series is a very popular simulation RPG work that has been developed for various Nintendo game consoles, comics, novels, fan books, and OVAs. The story is about a hero with the blood of a hero who commands an army to fight for peace, and has been a topic of conversation since its release due to its revolutionary system that differentiates each character through graphics and experience. Here is a collection of images of the Fire Emblem series' past packages.

Read Article

Fire Emblem: The Sword of Fire (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem: The Sword of Fire (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem: Sword of Fire" is the seventh title in the Fire Emblem series of simulation role-playing games (SRPG), released by Nintendo on April 25, 2003. It was developed exclusively for the Game Boy Advance (GBA) by Intelligent Systems, Inc. The title of this title reads "Rekka no Ken," and the catchphrase is "People grow with the story. The main character, Eliwood, sets off on a journey in search of his missing father, which leads him into a battle for the fate of the continent against the mysterious assassin group "Black Fang.

Read Article

Fire Emblem Warriors: Fuuka Yukigetsu (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem Warriors: Fuuka Yukigetsu (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem Musou: Fuuka Yukigetsu" is an action simulation game released by Koei Tecmo Games for the Nitendo Switch. The game allows players to enjoy exhilarating action while controlling the main character and his companions, who are original characters in the game. The main character is a mercenary who, together with his friends, must fight a battle for Fodora in order to defeat his sworn enemy, the "Gray Devil".

Read Article

Fire Emblem Engage (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem Engage (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem Engage" is a game software for Nintendo Switch and the 18th simulation RPG in the Fire Emblem series, which has been on sale since 1990. Characters from past generations also appear in the game, and a new element, "Engage," allows the player to significantly change the course of battle. After awakening from a 1,000-year sleep, the protagonist throws himself into the battle for the Twelve Rings in order to defeat the evil dragon that plunges the continent of Eleos into crisis. Along with the friends he meets on his journey, he learns of the fate that befalls him.

Read Article

Fire Emblem: The Sealed Sword (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem: The Sealed Sword (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem: The Sealed Sword" is a simulation RPG in which the main character Roy leads the Lycian League against the Kingdom of Berne and the Dragon Tribe on the continent of Ereb. Players use tactics and character development to advance the story. The game progresses on a turn-based system, and players aim for victory by utilizing the unique classes and abilities of their units. The story follows the main character Roy and his friends as they grow through battle and struggle to save the world.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Genshikai Ibunroku #FE (game)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Genshikai Ibunroku #FE (game)

Genshikai Ibunroku #FE" is an RPG game released exclusively for Wii U. It is a collaboration between "Fire Emblem" and Atlus, the developer of "Persona" and "Megami Tensei". The game is an ensemble coming-of-age drama in which young people living in the modern age fight against evil and grow together with their friends while taking an active part in the world of "entertainment" as a result of a certain incident. The battle system is also gorgeous, and there are many fascinating effects scattered throughout the game.

Read Article

ファイアーエムブレム 風花雪月(FE風花雪月)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

ファイアーエムブレム 風花雪月(FE風花雪月)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『ファイアーエムブレム 風花雪月』とは、「インテリジェントシステムズ」と「コーエーテクモゲームス」が開発したシミュレーションRPG。ファイアーエムブレムシリーズの1つで、2019年に発売された。様々な人の思惑が交差する混迷の大地・フォドラを救う為、傭兵上がりの教師である主人公が仲間達と共に立ち上がる。自らの選択が物語に大きな影響を与える他、登場人物の成長や葛藤を描く人間ドラマと見所満載。日本ゲーム大賞2020では優秀賞を受賞するなど、世間的な評価は高い。

Read Article

Fire Emblem Warriors (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem Warriors (game) spoiler commentary and discussion.

Fire Emblem Warriors" is an action game released by Koei Tecmo Games in 2017. Players can enjoy exhilarating action by controlling characters from previous "Fire Emblem" games. There are also elements that allow players to develop their characters and deepen their friendship with other characters, and all of the game is fully voiced. The kingdom of Aitolis has been plunged into darkness after the castle fell due to demons that appeared from the gates of the Otherworld. Theon and Lian, the children of the previous king, who succeeded in escaping from the castle, travel with the successive protagonists to confront the mighty darkness.

Read Article

A thorough explanation and discussion of Norse mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

A thorough explanation and discussion of Norse mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

Norse mythology is a mythological system that was believed by the Norse people before the spread of Christianity. It is also called Scandinavian mythology because the Norse had the Scandinavian Peninsula as their sphere of influence. The myths were passed down orally, but around the 13th century, the Icelandic poet Snorri Sturluson compiled them into a book titled Edda. The story depicts the rise and fall of gods whose "doom of destruction" has been decreed, and many of the episodes have a dark overall impression. The story as a whole is highly accomplished, and it is often used as a subject in modern creative works such as comic books.

Read Article

Contents