Fate Battle Scene Comparison] STUDIODEEN and ufotable's Movie Summary

What happens when two different companies produce an anime with the same story! The anime Fate/stay night hit on such a question. In this issue, we will make an in-depth comparison with a famous Fate scene that divides opinion between the Dean and UFO factions!

What is "Fate/staynight"?

In order to obtain the Holy Grail, which is said to grant any wish, magicians summon the spirits of heroes from mythology and history and kill each other in the "Holy Grail War.

Source: ja.wikipedia.org

The main character, Emiya Shiro, is suddenly caught up in the Holy Grail War and finds himself in a battle of wizards and sorcerers, a whirlwind of intrigue and intrigue, killing each other.

Source: dic.nicovideo.jp

...is the synopsis of Fate/staynight.
The original story is based on a video game of a visual novel,
Fate
Unlimited Blade Works
Heaven's Feel
There are three routes of attack.

From January 2006 to June of the same year, a 24-episode TV anime based on the "Fate" route was broadcast.
A film version of the anime "Unlimited Blade Works" was released on January 23, 2010.
In October 2014, "Unlimited Blade Works" was broadcast as a two-cour TV anime.
Production of the theatrical anime "Heaven's Feel" was also announced on July 27, 2014.

Source: ja.wikipedia.org

Such is the case with the Fate series anime. In fact, the √ of the same title has been produced by different companies (DEEN and UFO), which has caused a bit of controversy among some fans.

Opinion of the "DEEN" group

Name: nameless Posted on May 10, 2015

DEEN was definitely better, at least when it comes to BGM!
UFO's BGM really sucks! It's a shame that the production and music sucks because the artwork is so good!
What was UFO thinking when they appointed Fukasawa?
Not a single song is memorable to my ears.

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

Name: nameless Posted on May 10, 2015

>To be honest, the DEEN version is more clever that way.

The music is a big part of it.
And DEEN is excellent in preparing the punchline by bringing a huge sword at the end, even in the first unveiling of UBW.

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

Name: nameless Posted on May 10, 2015

The images are beautiful, but
UFO still sucks at making it exciting.
To be honest, the DEEN version is more skillful in that area.

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

Opinion of the "UFO" group

Name: nameless Posted on May 10, 2015

It's like DEEN for the dynamism and ufotable for the static images,
The overall production is messy, but the rough-hewn images with momentum are the best part of DEEN's version.
UFOTABLE's images are more refined, but less dynamic.
I prefer the latter.

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

Name: nameless Posted on June 28, 2015

UFO by far, beautiful light.

Source: yaraon-blog.com

Name: nameless Posted on July 27, 2014

I'm 100% sure the content will be the ufo version.
I'm not sure if the DEEN version will be the first time you've seen it. The DEEN version will be the first time you see it, you'll be in a state of ?

Source: yaraon.blog109.fc2.com

A rough summary of the features of the DEEN and UFO versions...

Depending on one's feelings and preferences, the "DEEN" version seems to have an appealing background music and structure, while the "UFO" version is known for its overwhelming visual beauty and delicate depiction.

But what is the reason why opinions are so divided in two despite the same scene?
In this article, we would like to look at the differences between the two versions, which cannot be seen from the text alone, through a comparison video.

Archer vs. Lancer Battle (DEEN to UFO)

Fate Archer vs Lancer Battle Comparison

UP for experimentation Fate Archer vs Lancer fight comparison order is DEEN anime version -> #0:00 DEEN movie version -> #2:42 ufo anime version -> #3:37 Saber vs Lancer fight -> sm24671336 Saber vs Lancer fight -> sm24771237 Church Guru -> sm24723415 Shirow vs Rin battle→sm24873698 Shirow vs Rider battle→sm24873743 Saber vs Assassin battle→sm24972030 Archer vs Caster battle→sm24972089 School Yudai battle→sm25022412 Caster group Kuzuki battle first battle related comparison→sm25118655 Dozo related Comparison→sm25166167mylist/17319516

The first thing that is visibly different is the character design.
The size of the eyes and the color scheme show the characteristics of each age group, but the design of Takashi Takeuchi, who is in charge of Fate's character design, is also changing day by day, so it is only natural that both are different from each other.
It is difficult to say which one is better than the other, especially since each person's taste is involved in the design.

I think the BGM of the DEEN version has more of a "battle of the spirits of war" feel to it.
While the UFO version gives the impression of being lighthearted, the depiction of raging battles that seem to be in inverse proportion to this may have played a role in increasing the intensity of the performance.

VS Berserker battle (UFO -> DEEN -> DEEN [theater version])

[ufo] Comparison of old and new Fate Berserker battles [DEEN].

I compared the battle of Berserker between ufotable version of Fate/stay night, studio DEEN version of Fate/stay night, and the theatrical version of Fate/stay night. My List KATATSUGETsuki related mylist/45762241 Others mylist/5265847

sulfur-kangaroo5
sulfur-kangaroo5
@sulfur-kangaroo5

Related Articles

Spoiler commentary and discussion of the Fate series (Fate/stay night)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of the Fate series (Fate/stay night)

A video game released by TYPE-MOON in 2004, as well as an anime, novel, and manga work based on the video game. In the "Holy Grail War," seven sorcerers and their counterparts, seven Heroic Spirits, who have been chosen as the "Holy Grail," the universal cup that grants all wishes, kill each other to fulfill their own wishes until there is only one last pair left. A young boy, Emiya Shiro, is caught up in the Holy Grail War, and together with Saber, a girl he summoned by chance, they begin a path of hardship.

Read Article

Summary of Servants of the Fate Series

Summary of Servants of the Fate Series

The "Fate series" is the collective name for TYPE-MOON's "Fate/stay night" and other games, anime, manga, and other works. The series depicts the "Holy Grail War," a battle royale of sorcerers seeking the "Holy Grail," which is said to grant any wish, and the people involved in it. Servants are messengers summoned by sorcerers for the Holy Grail War, and are composed of enormous magical power. Originally, the invoked spirits and phantoms were too powerful to be handled as messengers, so they were forced into a vessel called a class.

Read Article

Fate/stay night(フェイト ステイナイト)の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

Fate/stay night(フェイト ステイナイト)の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『Fate/stay night』は2004年に有限会社ノーツから発売された伝奇活劇ビジュアルノベルゲーム、およびそれを原作とするアニメ・漫画作品。持ち主のあらゆる願いを叶える「聖杯」を巡って7人の魔術師とサーヴァント(使い魔)が戦う聖杯戦争を描いている。 聖杯戦争を戦うマスターやサーヴァントはそれぞれに強い信念や誇りを持っている。彼らの信念や誇りが垣間見える名言や名シーンは、多くのファンの胸を熱くさせる。

Read Article

Fate/kaleid liner Prisma Illya (anime and manga) spoiler commentary and discussion

Fate/kaleid liner Prisma Illya (anime and manga) spoiler commentary and discussion

Fate/kaleid liner Prisma Illya" is a manga series published in the monthly magazine Comp Ace, and an anime television series based on the manga that aired 10 episodes in 2013. Ilyasphiel von Einzbern (nicknamed Ilya), an ordinary fifth grader, is transformed into a magical girl by the power of Magical Ruby, which is a "magic charm: Kaleidosteck," and cooperates with another magical girl, Miyu Edelfeldt (nicknamed Miyu), in a mission to recover class cards scattered in the town. She is also a magical girl.

Read Article

アーチャー/エミヤ(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

アーチャー/エミヤ(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

アーチャー(エミヤ)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する弓兵のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』ではヒロインの1人である遠坂凛に呼び出される。当初は記憶が混乱しており自分が何者かも分からなかったが、記憶を取り戻すと主人公の衛宮士郎を敵視し始める。真名はエミヤ。第五次聖杯戦争唯一の未来の時代の英霊であり、正体は衛宮士郎が霊長の抑止力(アラヤ)と契約を交わした存在である。

Read Article

The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II (The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II (The Case Files of Lord El-Melloi II) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

The Case Files of Lord Ermeloy II" is a spin-out novel from the visual novel game series "Fate/stay night" by TYPE-MOON. Weaver Velvet, who survived the harsh and intense Fourth Holy Grail War, changed his name to Lord Elmeroi II and became a lecturer at the Clock Tower. The Clock Tower, the headquarters of magicians, is a melting pot of intrigue and scheming, and there is no shortage of intrigue, trickery, and mysterious incidents. Ermeloy II also gets caught up in them one after another, and solves them with his apprentice, Gray, and the students in his class.

Read Article

ギルガメッシュ(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

ギルガメッシュ(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

ギルガメッシュとは、『Fateシリーズ』に登場するサーヴァントの1人。基本的にはアーチャーのクラスだが、『Fate/EXTRA CCC』においてはクラス「なし」になっている。『Fate/Zero』において遠坂時臣によって召喚されたサーヴァントで、その10年後を描いた『Fate/stay night』でも暗躍する。 その正体は古代メソポタミアの『ギルガメシュ叙事詩』など多くの神話に登場する人類最古の英雄王。英雄たちが持つ宝具の原型を所持しているため、対英霊戦における絶対強者として君臨している。

Read Article

セイバー/アルトリア・ペンドラゴン(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

セイバー/アルトリア・ペンドラゴン(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

セイバー(アルトリア・ペンドラゴン)とは、Fateシリーズに登場する剣士のサーヴァントの1人。外見は青いドレスの上に白銀の甲冑を纏った、華奢で目麗しい少女であり、シリーズの顔ともいうべき存在である。『Fate/stay night』ではヒロインを務め、マスターである衛宮士郎のことを献身的に支える。中でも"Fate"(セイバールート)では士郎と両想いになる。真名はアルトリア・ペンドラゴン。すなわちイングランドの伝説的英雄アーサー王である。

Read Article

ランサー/クー・フーリン(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

ランサー/クー・フーリン(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

ランサー(クー・フーリン)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する槍兵のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』では魔術協会からの派遣魔術師バゼット・フラガ・マクレミッツによって召喚される。しかしそのバゼットが聖杯戦争の監督役である言峰綺礼にだまし討ちを受けて令呪を奪われたため、マスターが言峰になる。 真名はクー・フーリン。ケルト神話における大英雄で、アイルランドの光の皇子である。

Read Article

ライダー/メドゥーサ(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

ライダー/メドゥーサ(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

ライダー(メドゥーサ)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する騎兵のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』ではヒロインの1人である間桐桜に召喚され、その兄の間桐慎二のサーヴァントとなる。真名はメドゥーサ。ギリシャ神話に登場するゴルゴーン3姉妹の末妹である。 『Fate/stay night』では専用ルートがないにもかかわらず、ミステリアスな雰囲気とその美貌から人気が高く、人気投票では第1回、第2回共に4位に入っている。

Read Article

キャスター/メディア(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

キャスター/メディア(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

キャスター(メディア)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する魔術師のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』ではアトラム・ガリアスタという魔術師に召喚されるが、そりが合わずにキャスターは彼を殺害して逃亡する。魔力不足で消滅の危機に陥っていたところで葛木宗一郎に助けられ、契約を結ぶ。 真名はメディア。ギリシャ神話に登場する裏切りの魔女である。

Read Article

真アサシン/ハサン・サッバーハ/呪腕のハサン(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

真アサシン/ハサン・サッバーハ/呪腕のハサン(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

真アサシン(ハサン・サッバーハ)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する暗殺者のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』では"Heaven's Feel"(間桐桜ルート)で間桐臓硯により召喚される。 真名はハサン・サッバーハ。イスラム教の伝承に残る暗殺教団の教主「山の翁」の1人であり、呪腕のハサンという異名を持つ。元は特筆すべきものがない平凡な暗殺者だったが、魔神の右腕を手に入れたことで山の翁の党首になる。

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Today's Gourmet at Emiya-san's (Fate x Cooking)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Today's Gourmet at Emiya-san's (Fate x Cooking)

Emiya-san's Today's Gohan" is a manga that has been serialized by TAa in the web comic distribution site "Young Ace UP" since 2016, and an anime work based on it, a derivative work based on TYPE-MOON's visual novel work "Fate/stay night". stay night" through "cooking". It is a peaceful everyday story in which the main character, Emiya Shiro, is a good cook, and spins a tale centered on serving food to the characters and teaching them how to cook it.

Read Article

アサシン/佐々木小次郎(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

アサシン/佐々木小次郎(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

アサシン(佐々木小次郎)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する暗殺者のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』ではキャスターのサーヴァントによって、柳洞寺の山門を触媒にするというイレギュラーな方法で召喚される。そのため正式な暗殺者のサーヴァントではなく、アサシンのクラス特性をほぼ失っている。 真名は佐々木小次郎(ささきこじろう)。日本有数の剣豪・宮本武蔵の好敵手として語られる剣士なのだが、その存在があやふやなため「燕返し」を成しえた普通の農民が召喚された。

Read Article

バーサーカー/ヘラクレス(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

バーサーカー/ヘラクレス(Fateシリーズ)の徹底解説・考察まとめ

バーサーカー(ヘラクレス)は『Fateシリーズ』に登場する狂戦士のサーヴァントの1人。『Fate/stay night』ではイリヤスフィール・フォン・アインツベルンに召喚される。第五次聖杯戦争が始まる前から召喚されており、バーサーカーは喋らないまでもイリヤと父娘のような関係性を築いている。 真名はヘラクレス。ギリシア神話における大英雄で、キャスター以外の全クラスの適性を持つ武人である。第五次聖杯戦争においては最強のサーヴァントと評されている。

Read Article

Cooking, Meals, Food, Sweets, and Drinks Summary of Today's Cooking at Emiya-san's

Cooking, Meals, Food, Sweets, and Drinks Summary of Today's Cooking at Emiya-san's

Emiya-san's Family's Today's Gohan" is a spin-off manga of "Fate/stay night" by TAa. While "Fate/stay night" depicts the bleak battle of sorcerers, "Emiya-san's Today's Gohan" focuses on cooking and the peaceful daily life in Fuyuki City, the setting of the manga. Many dishes, meals, food, sweets, and drinks appear in this work. Under the supervision of Makoto Tadano, the cooking methods are described in an easy-to-understand manner, and the backbone of the hero and heroine, such as Shirou Emiya, Sakura Madiri, and Rin Tohsaka, is also explored in depth through cooking.

Read Article

A thorough explanation and discussion of Norse mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

A thorough explanation and discussion of Norse mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

Norse mythology is a mythological system that was believed by the Norse people before the spread of Christianity. It is also called Scandinavian mythology because the Norse had the Scandinavian Peninsula as their sphere of influence. The myths were passed down orally, but around the 13th century, the Icelandic poet Snorri Sturluson compiled them into a book titled Edda. The story depicts the rise and fall of gods whose "doom of destruction" has been decreed, and many of the episodes have a dark overall impression. The story as a whole is highly accomplished, and it is often used as a subject in modern creative works such as comic books.

Read Article

A thorough explanation and discussion of Greek mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

A thorough explanation and discussion of Greek mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

Greek mythology is a mythological system believed mainly in ancient Greece. It depicts the interaction between gods and human heroes, centering on the twelve pillars that gather on Mount Olympus. The characters in Greek mythology, such as the womanizing god Zeus, his jealous wife Hera, and the demigod and half-human hero Heracles, who sometimes fought valiantly and was sometimes rewarded for his folly, were known for their very "human" characteristics, which led to the popularity and decline of the mythology. This led to both the popularity and decline of the myths. Among myths from around the world, Greek mythology is particularly well known, and is often featured as a subject in Japanese manga and anime.

Read Article

Fate/stay night [Unlimited Blade Works] (UBW) spoiler commentary and discussion summary

Fate/stay night [Unlimited Blade Works] (UBW) spoiler commentary and discussion summary

Fate/stay night [Unlimited Blade Works]" is an anime work based on the visual novel game "Fate/stay night" that depicts the story of seven sorcerers (Masters) and seven heroic spirits (Servants) fighting over a cup with universal power called the "Holy Grail. This work is one of the stories of the original work. This work is scripted on the route of one of the stories of that original work, with Rin Tohsaka as the heroine. The first season aired from October to December 2014 and the second from April to June 2015 with 13 episodes each.

Read Article

Fate/Grand Order - Absolute Monster Front Babylonia (FGO Babylonia) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Fate/Grand Order - Absolute Monster Front Babylonia (FGO Babylonia) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Fate/Grand Order -Absolute Monster Front Babylonia-" is an anime work derived from the smartphone app game "Fate/Grand Order. The story is about Tachika Fujimaru, a boy sorcerer who travels through the ages in search of the "Holy Grail," a cup with all-powerful powers, in order to recover human history that was stolen by the sorcerer King Solomon, and descends into the ancient world of Mesopotamia in 2700 BC to confront the "League of Three Goddesses" who plan to destroy the human race.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Fate/EXTRA Last Encore (anime)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Fate/EXTRA Last Encore (anime)

Fate/EXTRA Last Encore" is a TV anime work based on the game "Fate/EXTRA" released by Marvelous Entertainment, which was broadcast from January 2018. The setting is within the spirit fictional world "SE.RA.PH" created by the spirit computer "Moon Cell Automaton" that exists on the moon and has the power to grant any wish. It depicts the "Moon Grail War," in which 128 sorcerers (Masters) and Servants fight over the right to use the Moon Grail (Moon Cell Automaton) to determine the sole winner.

Read Article

Fate/strange Fake spoiler commentary and discussion

Fate/strange Fake spoiler commentary and discussion

Fate/strange Fake" (Fate: Strange Fake) is a novel by Ryogo Narita that depicts an epic battle between a number of sorcerers and legendary heroes who follow them as messengers as they vie for the Holy Grail, which grants all wishes. It was originally an April Fool's Day story project published by Narita, but the high degree of perfection drew attention and made it an official work. In Snowfield, a rural area in the United States, a battle over the Holy Grail suddenly erupts. Those who want to take advantage of the war, those who want to suppress it, and those who are caught up in it all have their own agendas, and the battle lines become increasingly chaotic.

Read Article

Fate/hollow ataraxia(フェイト ホロウ アタラクシア)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

Fate/hollow ataraxia(フェイト ホロウ アタラクシア)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『Fate/hollow ataraxia』は2005年にノーツのゲームブランド・TYPE-MOONから発売された伝奇ビジュアルノベルゲーム。『Fate/stay night』のファンディスクであり、続編にあたる。本作では第五次聖杯戦争の終結から半年後に起きた、「繰り返される4日間」を描いている。前作とは異なり、穏やかでコミカルな日常が多く、第五次聖杯戦争では敵同士だったキャラクターの掛け合いも見られる。

Read Article

Contents