Spoiler commentary and discussion of Fictional Reasoning (novel, manga, and anime)

Fictional Mystery" is a mystery novel by writer Kyo Jouhei and a manga/anime work based on it. A comic adaptation of the work by manga artist Chashiba Katase has been serialized in Shonen Magazine R since April 2015. The story is about a girl, Kotoko Iwanaga, who has become a god who controls the wisdom of monsters, and together with her lover, an immortal man named Kuro Sakuragawa, she solves cases in response to help from the monsters. The theme of the work is "fiction," and the goal is not to unravel the truth, but rather "how to create a fiction that will convince people and make things go well.

Outline of "Fictitious Reasoning"

"The Mystery of Fiction" is a mystery novel about supernatural phenomena written by the author Kyo Shirodaira, and a comic and anime series based on the novel. The comic book writer Katase Chashiba's comic adaptation of the novel has been serialized in "Shonen Magazine R" since April 2015. For Katase Chashiba, this is his debut work. The original novel won the 4th place in the top 10 of the Honkaku Mystery at the 12th Honkaku Mystery Grand Prize in 2012. In 2016, it won the 7th place in the 6th NEXT Breaking Comic RANKING BEST50. As of December 2021, five volumes of the comic adaptation version were published. In 2018, he was nominated for the 42nd Kodansha Manga Award in the Shonen Category. The first episode of the anime was aired from January to March 2020, and the production of the second episode has been decided.
Kotoko IWANAGA, a girl with "one leg, one eye" who has become the god that controls the wisdom of monsters, and her immortal lover Kuro Sakuragawa solve the incident in response to the help of monsters. Since the purpose of Kotoko is to maintain world order by acting as a broker between monsters and humans, it is not enough to solve the problem just by uncovering the truth. After guessing the truth to some extent, the theme of the story is "how to create a fiction that will convince people and how to settle things well."

Outline and story of "The Mystery of Fiction"

Encounter between Kotoko and Kuro

腕を食われる九郎。

Kotoko IWANAGA, the main character, falls in love with Sakuragawa Kuro at first sight, but he has a long-term girlfriend called Yumihara Saki. For the next two years, Kotoko, who has not given up and has been looking for an opportunity, hears that Kuro broke up with Saki and starts approaching her.
However, Kuro met Kappa during his trip and told Kotoko that he was such a pathetic man who was dumped by Saki for running away at once.
However, Kotoko realized that Kuro dared to make the subject vague, and asked,' Please make the subject clear. Which one left Saki and ran away?' The Kotoko's point was right. In fact, it was Kappa who ran away. Seeing that Kappa looked at Kuro and said,' Gross, terrible, horrible,' Saki became frightened and shook Kuro.
When Kuro says,' There is no such thing as a kappa,' Kotoko tells him that he was kidnapped by a monster when he was young and became the' god' of monsters with his eyes and legs taken away. Kuro doesn't believe it, but he has no choice but to believe it because a talking raccoon dog asked Kotoko for help.
Kuro and Kotoko go to the scene and fight against the strange cow. In the fight, Kuro defends the Kotoko and his arms are eaten. But the arms grow immediately, and the strange cow that ate Kuro's flesh disappears in agony. Kuro was immortal when his grandmother made him eat mermaid meat when he was 11 years old. He also had the ability to the same time gave him the ability to determine the future of the range that could occur in the event of death.
In the eyes of the monsters, Kuro's simultaneous display of the powers of the two monsters was extremely frightening and terrifying. For Kotoko, who had the destiny of having to resolve the troubles between the monsters, Kuro was an irresistible presence. Kotoko asked Kuro to be with them even in a romantic way, and the two started dating.

Steel man Nanase

It has been two and a half years since Kuro and Kotoko started dating. The stage has moved to Sakaichi, Magura, far from the city where they live. In Sakaichi, Magura, there has been a mysterious incident in which a faceless woman wearing a red and black miniskirt dress with a steel frame of about three meters was often seen.
She was very similar to the idol Nanase Karin (Nanase Karin), who committed suicide in Sakaichi, Magura. She was rumored to be called' Kojin Nanase' (Kojin Nanase) because she was killed by a steel frame crushing her face.
One day, an incident occurred in which Saki was attacked by Karin Nanase. After escaping with the help of Kotoko, Saki began an investigation into Karin Nanase and Nanase Karin. The result of the investigation revealed that Nanase Karin, who had gained popularity by appearing in gravure and TV dramas, had disappeared from the main stage when her father committed suicide. The cause was the release of a note by her father, who committed suicide, saying, "I die because of Karin because of Karin.
A few days later, Saki is summoned by a monster. At the scene, Kuro and Nanase the Steeler are fighting. The two seem to be fighting a close match, but they can't make Nanase the Steeler disappear. Kotoko sees this and concludes,' It's impossible to kill Nanase the Steeler by force.' Nanase the Steeler is a' monster of imagination' that embodies people's imagination and cannot be made to disappear by Kuro's power alone.
In order to make Hagen-Genji disappear, the reality that' there is a specter of Hagen-Genji Nanase' must be overwritten by the fiction that' there is no specter of Hagen-Genji Nanase.' The three decided to cooperate in order to make Hagen-Genji disappear. In order to make Hagen-Genji disappear, the reality that' there is a specter of Hagen-Genji Nanase' must be overwritten by the fiction that' there is no specter of Hagen Nanase
The three of them started to gather information about Nanase KOJIN, but one night, Tokunosuke TERADA, Saki's colleague, was killed by Nanase KOJIN. The news spread nationwide and the summary site of Nanase KOJIN became very popular.
Kotoko realizes that Kuro's cousin Sakuragawa Rokka, like Kuro, was the man who ate mermaid meat.
On that night, Kuro threw himself again into the battle against Nanase, a steelworker.
While Kuro and Nanase were fighting, Kotoko began to write four fictional stories on the bulletin board. These stories were necessary to make Nanase disappear. As more people believed the stories written by Kotoko, Nanase became less powerful.
Encouraged by Kotoko, Hisahito Nanase was judged to be a fiction, and Hisahito Nanase who had been fighting against Kuro disappeared. Immediately after that, Rokka sent an e-mail to Kotoko saying,' You guys win this time. See you later.' The incident was safely, and Saki said goodbye to Kuro again.

Lightning Pinocchio or Hoshini-Negaiwo

Kotoko and Kuro had visited a seaside town called Totomizu Town in B Prefecture in response to a request about a monster. In the town, where the number of tourists has increased significantly in recent years due to the influence of dramas, there was an incident in which a fish died mysteriously due to a doll that emitted electric shock from the tip of the finger.
The human-sized wooden doll was made by an old man named Zenta Tohira. He suddenly started making the doll after his grandson was hit and killed by a tourist car that was looking aside. He died of illness shortly after the doll was completed. Since then, the doll has been seen wandering the streets alone.
The people of the town had rumored that the doll was Zenta's revenge on the town and tourists, and the monsters living in Watari Mizu-cho were also troubled by the doll's electric shock from their fingertips, so they asked Kotoko for help. Kotoko, Kuro, the monster cat, and the town's senior lady-in-waiting, Tae Shimai, teamed up to kill the doll.
The destruction of the doll itself is not difficult with Kuro. Kuro succeeds in catching the doll, but he realizes that the names of the four university students who ran over and killed Zenta's grandson are inscribed on the doll. The doll was a curse doll. If he had destroyed it without thinking, the university students whose names were inscribed might have died.
In addition, Tae's name was inscribed on the doll. In the past, Tae had received a mountain of reparations for losing her two children in a traffic accident. The people around her were jealous of Tae, who had obtained a large amount of assets, and called her "a witch who made money from the dead bodies of her relatives."
Zenta, who believed, "If you lose your family, you must be unhappy," probably could not forgive Tae, who seemed to be living happily due to the misfortune of his relatives. Kuro scraped five names from the doll, but no change occurred. Zenta's curse was all he could do by moving the doll.
When the incident was over, Kotoko and Kuro left Watarimizu-cho.

Guillotine Sanshiro

Morino Sayoko, an illustrator known for her combination of a maneki-neko and "something ominous," met Kuro and Kotoko on the train and talked about an incident that happened the other day.
It was an incident in which Kojiro MIYAIGAWA, an old man with assets who lived in Y village, D prefecture, cut off the head of his younger brother, who had been killed due to financial trouble, with a guillotine that he owned.
Kuro told Sayoko that his statement, "I wanted to use the guillotine once before I was arrested," was a lie. Kuro and Kotoko visited Y Village at the request of the guillotine and were looking for Sayoko.
Guillotine said that it had been used once in the past, so he wondered that Kojiro's statement that he wanted to use it once did not make sense. Guillotine said that he had used it 10 years ago when he killed Sayoko's father.
Sayoko was from Village Y, and was on good terms with Kojiro. However, one day, when Sayoko was about to be attacked by her father, she accidentally let him die. At the suggestion of Kojiro, who asked for help, she used a guillotine to separate and bury the body of her father. Sayoko, who received financial support from Kojiro, left the village, and the two had not been in contact since.
However, Kojiro still thought that Sayoko was a dear friend, so when he killed his younger brother, he cut off his head thinking,' If the guillotine is examined in detail, it may be revealed that he cut off the body of Sayoko's father.'
When he learned the truth, Guillotine asked Kotoko for another favor: to draw a picture of him and a maneki neko (beckoning cat). Guillotine himself said that his father's body would be moved further out of sight by the hands of the monsters, and that the shape of the guillotine's blade would be changed so that it did not match his father's body.
When Sayoko woke up and was told the truth about the incident and Guillotine's request by Kotoko, she accepted the request with confusion.

Sleeping Mader

Kotoko receives a strange request from Goichi Otonashi, chairman of the Otonashi Group, which focuses on hotels, real estate, and tourism.
The request is as follows.

Twenty-three years ago, he asked a fox to kill his wife, Sumi Otonashi, who was the general manager of the group. Sumi was stabbed to death with a knife on her way home from a massage parlor in the evening. The incident was believed to be the work of a street robber, and neither he nor his three children, who had alibis, were ever suspected. As a result, the group's unreasonable expansionary course came to a halt and a good future opened up for the children, whom his wife was trying to control, but murder is a crime. I have only six months to live because of cancer, and I think that suffering and dying in the end will be my atonement, but it is not good for my children to remain in the mindset that 'my mother's death has opened up a future for them. He wants to instill in his children the awareness that "I killed my wife, so I will die with this kind of retribution. But I think it is hard to believe that he asked the fox to kill her, so I need your help to construct a false theory that he was able to kill her, even though he had an alibi and it seemed impossible at the time."

Kotoko decides to accept Goichi's request. As a way to accomplish her request, she asks the children to "explain that Goichi murdered Sumi twenty-three years ago. Explain that this is the truth. The one who responded best to the task would be given priority to inherit the property.

September 3. At the hotel are Goichi's second son, Susumu Otonashi; Goichi's eldest daughter, Kaoruko Fujinuma's husband, Koya Fujinuma; and Rion Otonashi, the daughter of his oldest son, Ryoma Otonashi. Goichi, Kotoko, and Kuro were also present.

After Goichi left after presenting the issue again, Kotoko proposed a meeting with them, saying, "I don't want anyone to hold a grudge against me as a result of the decision. The meeting went very smoothly, but Kotoko pointed out the unnaturalness of the talks going smoothly without Kaoruko and Ryoma, who were the parties involved.

In response to Kotoko's questioning, Susumu confesses that he and Ryoma were working together to plan the murder of his mother. Not only that, but Koya confesses that Kaoruko and Koya were also planning to kill Sumi. In the end, however, their plan was never carried out. On the day they were to carry out their plan, they received the news of Sumi's death. Both Susumu and Koya were afraid that their murderous plan would be exposed, and they wanted to conclude their agreement as quickly as possible.

Kotoko, however, is unperturbed by this admission, and forces them to continue the discussion, claiming that Goichi's task is "how Goichi killed Sumi.

During the discussion, Ryoma's daughter, Rion, tells Kotoko that "this case may be Sumi's suicide. She speculates that "Goichi killed her" means that he encouraged Sumi's suicide by telling her that "the children are planning to kill Sumi. Rion's answer was told to Goichi the next day by Kotoko.

He endorses this answer, but he tells the children that he did not know they were planning to kill Sumi and that he has cancer. He tells them that they should know that their suffering death is the punishment for killing someone.

But Kotoko does not stop there. Goichi killed Sumi with the help of a monster, which upset the balance between the world of humans and the world of monsters. As an arbiter, Kotoko could not let that go and pointed out the real culprit. The fox had indeed tried to kill Sumi by making it look like an accident, as he had requested. However, before Yohko could do so, Sumi was killed by Kaoruko with a knife, as planned.
The fact that Sumi was killed by the robber was a cover by Youko.

The foxes had used such a cover in order to win the development rights to the mountain where the hostile foxes lived, which was their reward. Kotoko, however, claims that the fox's cry was "the last falsehood a mother utters for her daughter," and tells Kaoruko that Kaoruko is the real culprit.

After the incident, Kaoruko attempted suicide, and Goichi was hospitalized due to heartache. Goichi calls Kotoko and Kuro and tells them that he asked Kotoko to make this ruling because Rokka recommended her to do so.

Snow Woman's Dilemma

Eleven years ago, Masayuki Muroi, then a university student, was pushed off a mountain by his best friend due to a tangle of affection while climbing a snowy mountain. Masayuki, who almost died, was saved by a snow woman by paying money in return.
After returning to Japan, Masayuki received a large amount of consolation money from his parents based on the confession of his best friend. Masayuki started his own business using the consolation money and married at the age of 29. Although he seemed to be leading a smooth life, he had a lot of bad luck recently, such as being almost killed by his wife who made him a lover or being betrayed by his friends and losing his company.
Due to this, Masayuki, who had fallen into a state of distrust of human beings, moved alone to a place near the mountain where he met a snow fairy. There he met the snow fairy again. Masayuki and the snow fairy got along well, and the two of them often acted together. In such a peaceful life, however, the police came to visit Masayuki. It was discovered that Masayuki's former wife, Miharu HARADA, had been beaten to death with "Masayuki" written in her hand.
Miharu assumed that Masayuki would come to kill him someday, and left a document at home that said, "If I were to die, it must have been Masayuki who killed me." At the time of Miharu's murder, Masayuki was with a snow woman. So she has an alibi, but she doesn't become a witness. In addition, since the appearance of the snow woman and Miharu was similar, it is misunderstood that she was with Miharu at the time of the incident.
Receiving advice from the snow fairy, Masayuki asked Kotoko for help. However, when Kotoko met the two of them, she questioned whether Masayuki had actually killed Miharu. When Kotoko told her that he would use the snow fairy to kill his friends who had betrayed him, Masayuki became enraged. However, the snow fairy sheltered Masayuki by saying, "Masayuki is not a person who can do such a thing."
While Masayuki was heartbroken by his desperate attitude, Kotoko laughed, saying, "That was a complete lie," and Kotoko told Masayuki the truth about the incident.
If Miharu left the accusation in the first place, he should be able to stop Masayuki's crime by using it as a shield. In other words, the criminal killed Miharu while Masayuki did not have an alibi, and left Masayuki's name in Miharu's hand on purpose. The criminal was a person called Nagisa Iizuka who worked for Masayuki's company. Masayuki was confused because he did not know why Nagisa, who supported him before and after he left the company, had a grudge against him. However, encouraged by the snow woman, Masayuki regained his composure.
Although he remained silent to the two, Kotoko realized that Nagisa loved Masayuki. In a situation where everyone was suspicious of Masayuki, he knew that only Nagisa wanted to gain his love by showing that he believed in Masayuki.

Counterattack and defeat by Kotoko Iwanaga

Of a group of five men and five women who had gone into the mountains of Z Prefecture to spend the night, three were killed and one of the two survivors was seriously injured. The mountain is said to be haunted by the ghost of a giraffe. After the giraffe's death, a number of ominous accidents occurred, so the zoo had dedicated the giraffe to a shrine deep in the mountain, but the shrine recently collapsed due to a landslide. The giraffe's spirit, which had been trapped in the shrine, was released.

Upon receiving the news from the mountain monsters, Kotoko begins to investigate the connection between the giraffe's ghost and the deaths. Just then, Kuro is informed by the police that one of the survivors in the case is Rokka.

Rokka had only met the men who died while climbing the mountain. Rokka found the four men who had fallen from the cliff and rescued one of the survivors, Fuyuji Okamachi, before descending the mountain. Okamachi said he had temporary amnesia and did not know what had happened at the scene. In fact, however, Rokka and Okamachi had discussed the matter and reported the incident to the police, partially withholding the facts.

The truth is that the three, who had been college circle mates with Hilltown, were attacked by a giraffe in the mountains and fell off a cliff, and only Hilltown, who accidentally survived with Rokka underneath him, survived. Rokka, who was heartbroken over the death of the steel worker Nanase, drove the giraffe away to save the others, and then descended the mountain to save Okumachi. However, Rokka had once been murdered by Hilltown a few hours before they fell off the cliff. Rokka expected that Hilltown must have entered the mountain for some reason.

The next day, Kotoko and the others were summoned by the police, who told them that they had found a diary in a small bottle in the bag of Akira Nagatsuka, one of the deceased.
The journal says, "For the crime of leaving Nagatsuka's lover, Hiiragi Owada, to die, Nagatsuka killed three other people and committed suicide. The giraffe's haunting may have been true, but I want to choose how to ruin myself," he wrote.

The police predict that Nagatsuka killed himself after he made the other three fall off a cliff.

There is a reason why the four left Hiiragi to die. Hiiragi's great-grandfather was an employee of the zoo that imported the giraffe, and after the giraffe's death, there was a lot of bad luck in her family. That is why she wanted to reenshrine the giraffe's shrine, which is said to be deep in the mountains. The four of them were attracted to Hiiragi and began to help her prepare for her visit to the shrine. However, misfortunes began to happen to the four of them, and just as they were thinking bad luck, Hiiragi was hit by a car and died.

However, the misfortunes continued to happen to the four of them even after Hiiragi's death, so they decided to climb the mountain to "reenshrine the giraffe's shrine.

There, Kotoko developed suspicions about Rokka. She wondered if the incident was a plot designed to discredit Kotoko. If Kotoko makes a fatal mistake in the process of solving the case, and Rokka is the only one who can correct it, Kotoko will have no choice but to give in to her demands.

In order to avoid this situation, Kotoko instructed the monsters to fabricate evidence. She also told Okamachi that she had deduced that Nagaoka had fled from the three men, claiming to have seen the ghost of a giraffe, and had pushed them off a cliff when they were chasing him.

Kotoko thought that this would settle the case with Nagatsuka's theory of culpability without any problems, but contrary to her expectations, the police declared that the culprit was Okumachi. The police, however, were not convinced, because he had confessed and committed suicide. The reason was that Okumachi wanted to take his life with the honor that he was the one who committed the murder for Hiiragi. The reason why Okumachi murdered Rokka was to erase anyone who knew the truth of the case from the world.
From the very beginning, he had intended to die. Rokka taunts Kotoko, saying, "You left a person I saved to die.

Rokka wants a private conversation with Kotoko. Rokka assures Kotoko that if she continues to respect order as the god of wisdom, she will eventually kill Rokka and Kuro, who are nothing but disruptors of order.
Kotoko tolerated Kuro's existence because she has an enemy, Rokka, whose purpose is to clearly disrupt the order. Therefore, beyond Rokka ceasing her confrontation or dying, Kuro's existence cannot be tolerated. If he does not want a future in which Kuro dies, he offers to "find a way to make him and Kuro human again together.

Kotoko tries to refuse Rokka's proposal. However, fearing a future in which she would lose Kuro, Kotoko eventually accepts Rokka's proposal.
Kuro also accepts Kotoko's decision. Thus, the three teamed up to find a way to return Kuro and Rokka to human form.

Fictional character

Key person

Kotoko IWANAGA

CV: Kitou Akesato
The main character of this series. She is the only daughter of a famous family. She was 15 years old when she met Kuro. Most of the series is about four and a half years later, so she is now 20 years old. At the age of 11, she was kidnapped by monsters and signed a contract to become the god of wisdom. Since then, she has worked hard to solve various troubles related to monsters in order to maintain order. She is quick to turn her head and is good at sophistry because she needs to arrange incidents and accidents related to monsters so that they can be accepted by human society, and she often needs to prepare answers that are acceptable to monsters who have different values from humans. She has a lovely appearance like a doll, but she is small and often mistaken for a junior high school student. When she became the god of wisdom, she lost one eye and one leg, her right eye is artificial and her left leg is artificial. She can see monsters that ordinary people can't see and exchange words with them. The monsters call her "Ohisama" and call her "Pretty and Violent." She is often criticized by several people for her lack of grace, but she seems to have no intention of changing her.

Kuro Sakuragawa

keeper
keeper
@keeper

Related Articles

Spoilers and discussion of Spiral (Bonds of Reasoning)

Spoilers and discussion of Spiral (Bonds of Reasoning)

Spiral (推理の絆)" is a mystery adventure manga series that ran from August 1999 to October 2005, written by mystery novelist Kyo Shirohira, who debuted in "Monthly Shōnen Gangan" with "A Rose for the Detective," and drawn by Eita Mizuno of "Ura Sekai Picnic. It is a mystery adventure manga. The appeal of the manga lies in the vividness with which the main character, high school student Ayumi Narumi, uses his deductive powers, rather than his physical abilities, to overcome the battle for his life with the Blade Children, boys and girls who have abilities superior to those of ordinary people.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Tempest of Zetsuen (manga and anime).

Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Tempest of Zetsuen (manga and anime).

The Tempest of Zetsuen" is a fantasy manga and anime series that was serialized in "Monthly Shonen Ganguan" (Square Enix) from 2009 by Kyo Jouhei (original story), Yuhide Sa (composition), and Ren Ayasaki (artwork). It is a fantasy with elements of mystery, depicting the journey of two boys seeking revenge for the murder of a girl and the struggle between wizards in the modern world. The work skillfully depicts not only foreshadowing but also battle action and psychological battles between the protagonists.

Read Article

Another(小説・漫画・アニメ)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

Another(小説・漫画・アニメ)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『Another』とは、綾辻行人による日本のホラー小説、およびそれを原作とした漫画やアニメ作品である。小説は『野性時代』(角川書店)にて2006年より連載を開始した。 物語は1998年に夜見山北中学校3年3組で起こる不気味な出来事を中心に展開する。転校生の榊原恒一は、謎めいたクラスメイトの見崎鳴とともに、クラスにかかる「呪い」の真相を探ることになる。読者の予想を裏切る展開や独特の雰囲気が魅力のミステリー・怪奇作品である。

Read Article

Contents