Read two "Mysteries of Everyday Life" mysteries

There is a genre of mysteries known as "everyday mysteries. Instead of detectives and detectives solving difficult cases, these mysteries are about ordinary people solving "little mysteries" that bother them in their daily lives. Among such "everyday mysteries" mysteries, we will introduce the "Classics Club" series, which has been adapted into an anime and has been well received, and the "Haruchika" series, whose anime airing is scheduled to begin in January 2016.

What's an "Everyday Mystery" Mystery?

Some mysteries are called "everyday mysteries"; Wikipedia describes them as follows

This term refers to works of fiction that deal with the mysteries of everyday life and the process of solving them. Most of them are classified as full-fledged mystery novels.
In the process of unraveling the mystery, the human psychology behind everyday life is often revealed at the same time.

Source: ja.wikipedia.org

Simply put, it is a type of mystery in which someone other than a skilled detective or detective solves a small everyday mystery in the story. It seems that this type of mystery was already available in the 1980s, with the "Classics Club Series" (written by Honobu Yonezawa) first published in 2001 and the "Haruchika Series" (written by Haru Hatsuno) first published in 2005. The reason why the characters are not modern and neither smartphones nor social networking services appear in the series is simply because they were first published in the past.

Two similar but different works

The "Classics Club Series" and the "Haruchika Series" have in common that they both deal with "everyday mysteries" and are set in club activities on the verge of being discontinued. However, the "Classics Club Series" is set in a city modeled after Yonezawa's hometown of Takayama, Gifu Prefecture, and has a relatively rich regional flavor, with some stories solving mysteries based on old customs of the Hida region.

In contrast, the "Haruchika Series" has aspects of high school life in a brass band, which Hatsuno, who is from an athletic club, describes as "a boxy world, similar to a fantasy of desire for me" (quoted from "The Exit Game" commentary, page 293). As a result, the work does not have much of a local flavor, even though it is actually set in Shimizu-ku, Shizuoka City, where he is from.

Please do not misunderstand me, as I am not talking about whether one is better or worse than the other, but only about the difference between them.

Which cover would you prefer?

Incidentally, the "Haruchika Series" is sold with the anime version of the character printed on the cover, due to the anime airing soon. The one above is Chinatsu on the original cover, while the one below is the anime version of Chinatsu.

It depends on the person which one he/she prefers, but personally I think the upper one is closer to the image of Chinatsu that I imagine from within the work.

keeper
keeper
@keeper

Contents