What Are the Three Complaints of People Who Saw "Princess Mononoke"? And Hayao Miyazaki's thoughts on them [Studio Ghibli].

Although "Princess Mononoke" is renowned as a masterpiece, its style, which was different from that of previous Ghibli films, was met with some negative comments. Fans were dissatisfied with the grotesque depictions of battle scenes, the lack of a suitable voice actor for San, and the fact that the ending was not clearly depicted. Here are Hayao Miyazaki's thoughts on these voices.

It's strange, because what adults think when they see that depiction is "gross.

But children think "scary" instead of "grotesque. I think this difference is very important. Scary" and "grotesque" are not equal at all.

A "grotesque" work is just grotesque, but a work that makes you feel "scary" must have something important to it. In particular, I think it is very important to feel "scary" in this work. The reason for this fear may be awe or fear. I think that is what this work was trying to convey in a secondary way.

The expression does not compromise at all for that purpose. Depending on the viewer, it could be a good point or a bad point. That's what I felt.

Source: sakuhindb.com

Complaint #2: "The voice actors are not the right ones."

Particularly uncomfortable with actress Yuriko Ishida (as Sun)?

The actress Yuriko Ishida voiced the heroine, San, but some people have rated the work lower because her voice does not match the atmosphere of San.

I just watched the movie from the middle, and I can see that most of the actors are not suitable for voice-over work. I felt like I wanted to turn off the TV.
Hayao Miyazaki's pictures are wonderful, though. I think I could get more into the film if the voice actors were more appropriate.
I was so bothered by the voices that I couldn't get into the content.

Source: eiga.com

Sun is not bad in terms of character, but I felt uncomfortable with his voice here.
I don't know what to say...I spent a lot of time as a wolf, but I didn't feel the wildness in his voice.
The quality of his voice was good, but it was too good and became strangely clean and urban, which didn't match San's appearance and personality.
I would have preferred someone with a bit more of an intense feel to their voice.

↓Opinions on Twitter

Hayao Miyazaki's commitment to voice

Source: cinetri.jp

Ghibli films often use famous actors and actresses instead of professional voice actors, and there are still pros and cons to this commitment.
There may be no answer as to which is better, but it seems that Director Miyazaki still has his rationale.

Director Miyazaki: "Films are actually made in a short amount of time, so we rely on the dexterity of the voice actors. But there are times when I feel frustrated. It's like a lack of presence.

Source: ghibli.jpn.org

You are talking about something a little difficult.... In short, Director Miyazaki understands that voice actors are not all-powerful. It is only actors and actresses who can perform with their natural voices that can create a sense of presence.

Producer Toshio Suzuki's thoughts

Source: ghibli.jpn.org

Producer Suzuki has worked with Director Miyazaki on numerous Ghibli films. Like Miyazaki, he was particular about his voice.

Producer Suzuki: "In short, Ghibli films carefully depict food, clothing, and shelter. In other words, Ghibli's films carefully depict food, clothing, and shelter. In this case, it is not good if the actors are too exaggerated. The actor needs to be able to perform in a normal way. So, to put it bluntly, voice actors' performances can be divided into "hare" and "ke. And what we want is the "ke.

Source: ghibli.jpn.org

Hare (晴れ, "clear") refers to "extraordinary" events such as rituals, festivals, and annual events, while ke (褻) refers to "everyday" things that are part of normal life.

Complaint #3: "The last part is not clear!

Source: ciatr.jp

Last scene. Sure, the crisis is over, but San is going back to the forest and Eboshi says, "Let's make a good village." Eboshi probably will continue to damage the forest for his own survival after this. Ashitaka will not return to his hometown, but will stay at the ironworks...
That being said, maybe things haven't changed much...

It is characteristic of Miyazaki's animation to have a half-way
The last. It is too half-hearted.

Source: sakuhindb.com

Especially the last part...it was quite indigestible.
I wanted the film to end with a "big circle," which is one of the charms of Miyazaki's animation. It left a bad aftertaste.

Source: sakuhindb.com

↓There are some opinions here and there on Twitter that the last part is unconvincing and not well understood.

KE
KE
@KE

Related Articles

Princess Mononoke (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Princess Mononoke (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Princess Mononoke" is an animated feature film written by Hayao Miyazaki and Studio Ghibli. The film was released nationwide on July 12, 1997, with some movie theaters holding long-run screenings until early spring 1998, The film grossed 19.3 billion yen, making it the highest-grossing Japanese film of the 20th century. The film depicts the encounter between a human named Ashitaka and San, who was raised by a monster, and is an epic depiction of the conflict between man and nature.

Read Article

A compilation of handsome characters from Ghibli movies! The circumstances they each have are fascinating!

A compilation of handsome characters from Ghibli movies! The circumstances they each have are fascinating!

This article introduces a collection of handsome characters that have appeared in films produced by Studio Ghibli. Many attractive characters have appeared in Ghibli films, such as Haku from "Spirited Away," Pazoo from "Castle in the Sky," and Sho from "The Borrower Arrietty. Each of these characters has his or her own story, and this is what makes them so appealing. We hope you will find your favorite character.

Read Article

もののけ姫の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

もののけ姫の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『もののけ姫』とは、1997年公開のスタジオジブリ制作の長編アニメーション映画である。原作・脚本・監督は宮崎駿。 中世の日本を舞台に、エミシの村で暮らす少年アシタカが村を襲ってきたタタリ神から村を守ったことで、死の呪いを受けてしまう。呪いを絶つために旅立ったアシタカは、山犬に育てられた少女・サンと出会う。人間と自然の対立を描いた壮大な作品である。本作には、人やもののけそれぞれの立場や考え方を表したセリフも多く、考えさせられるような印象的な名言が数多く登場する。

Read Article

Castle in the Sky (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Castle in the Sky (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Released in 1986, this is a Studio Ghibli film. Hayao Miyazaki directed, wrote the script, and wrote the original story for this feature-length animation. Sita has a mysterious stone called the Flying Stone, and a boy named Pazoo rescues her. Dreaming of discovering Laputa, an island supposedly floating in the sky, Pazoo, who has been building an airplane, proposes to search for Laputa with Sita. Then, aerial pirates, government forces, and others intervene, aiming for the flying stone and Laputa. The fact that it is not just an adventure adventure drama has made it popular even after several decades.

Read Article

My Neighbor Totoro (Ghibli Movie) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

My Neighbor Totoro (Ghibli Movie) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Released in 1988. In the 1950s, sisters Satsuki Kusakabe and Mei Kusakabe move to a lush green farm village and meet Totoro, a strange creature. Including a cat bus, this film depicts their interactions with these people, whom they only see as children, and a bit of growing up. It is also a film with refreshing depictions of nature and many dark urban legends to contradict it. An animated film written and directed by Hayao Miyazaki.

Read Article

Ponyo on the Cliff (Ghibli film) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Ponyo on the Cliff (Ghibli film) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Ponyo on the Cliff" is an animated feature film directed by Hayao Miyazaki and produced by Studio Ghibli and released in 2008. The ending theme song "Ponyo on the Cliff," sung by Fujioka Fujimaki and Nozomi Ohashi, became a hot topic, reaching No. 3 on the Oricon weekly chart. Sosuke, a five-year-old boy who lives in a house on a cliff, meets a fish girl named Ponyo in the sea. Ponyo falls in love with Sosuke and tries to become human.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind (Ghibli film).

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind (Ghibli film).

Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind" is a 1984 Top Craft-produced Japanese animated film and the second animated feature film directed by Hayao Miyazaki. It is based on Miyazaki's manga of the same title, "Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind," which was serialized in "Animage. In the far distant future, modern civilization has collapsed and the world is covered by a fungus forest called the "Sea of Decay. The film depicts the life of a young girl who survives in the remote "Valley of the Wind".

Read Article

Omohide Poroporo (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Omohide Poroporo (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

A Studio Ghibli film released in 1991. Directed and written by Isao Takahata. Hayao Miyazaki also participated as a production producer. The film tells the story of a 27-year-old me who sets out on a journey alone, and looks back on my life up to that point with "Watashi, a fifth grader. The participation of Imai Miki and Yanagiba Toshiro as voice actors was also a hot topic at the time of the screening. The catch copy of the film is "I'm going on a journey with Watashi.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Wind Rises (Ghibli film).

Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Wind Rises (Ghibli film).

The Wind Rises" is an animated film released by Studio Ghibli in 2013 and directed by Hayao Miyazaki. Its catchphrase is "I must live." . The main character, Jiro Horikoshi, has loved airplanes since he was a child and wanted to become an airplane pilot. However, due to a critical defect, namely his nearsightedness, he gave up his dream of becoming an airplane pilot and decided to become a designer. When he was a university student, he was struck by the Great Kanto Earthquake and fell in love with Nahoko Satomi, a girl with tuberculosis whom he met at that time. The film is a moving portrayal of a young man struggling between life and death as the Taisho and Showa eras pass by.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Spirited Away (Ghibli film)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Spirited Away (Ghibli film)

Spirited Away" is an animated feature film by Ghibli that was released in theaters in the summer of 2001. The film tells the story of a 10-year-old girl named Chihiro who wanders into the world of the gods. The film generated box-office revenues of over 30 billion yen and won an Academy Award in 2003. It is truly a masterpiece among masterpieces. It is such a masterpiece that it was voted by the BBC of the United Kingdom in 2016 as the fourth best film of the 21st century in their list of the 100 greatest films of the 21st century.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of From Up On Poppy Hill (Ghibli film).

Spoiler commentary and discussion of From Up On Poppy Hill (Ghibli film).

From Up On Poppy Hill" is an animated film by Studio Ghibli released in 2011. The director is Goro Miyazaki, and the catchphrase is "Ue wo muite arukou." The film is based on the story of a high school student, Mel. Every morning, a second-year student at Konan Gakuen High School, Umi Matsuzaki, aka Mel, flies a flag in the garden. It was a signal flag for her father, who had gone off to war and never returned. One day, she noticed that she was featured in the school newspaper, "Weekly Carceratan," as the girl who flies the flag. It was an article written by Shun Kazama, a junior at the same high school. Mel begins to pay attention to Shun because of this article and gradually becomes attracted to him.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Witch's Delivery Service (The Witch's Home)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Witch's Delivery Service (The Witch's Home)

The Witch's Delivery Service" is an animated film produced by Studio Ghibli and released in 1989. Kiki, a 13-year-old witch, leaves her home town on a full-moon night and arrives in Koriko, a town across the sea. There, she opens "The Witch's Delivery Service" and experiences setbacks and grows up. Based on Eiko Kakuno's "The Witch's Delivery Service," the film features less fantasy than the original.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of How Do You Live (Ghibli movie)

Spoiler commentary and discussion of How Do You Live (Ghibli movie)

How Do You Live?" is an animation film by Hayao Miyazaki about a boy who travels through a mysterious world to save his mother-in-law. The film, which Miyazaki made explicitly stating that "this is really the last one," became the talk of the town for its unique technique of being released with no publicity, no official website, and no information at all. As the Pacific War intensifies, Masato Maki and his father move to the suburbs, where he is reunited with his aunt Natsuko, who is to become his new mother-in-law. While the two are at a loss as to how to interact with each other, Natsuko disappears into thin air, and Maki is led on a journey to another world by a mysterious blue heron in order to bring her back.

Read Article

Howl's Moving Castle (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Howl's Moving Castle (Ghibli Movie) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Howl's Moving Castle" is a Japanese animated feature film directed by Hayao Miyazaki and produced by Studio Ghibli, which was released nationwide on November 20, 2004, grossing 19.6 billion yen at the box office. It surpassed "Princess Mononoke" and became the second largest animated film produced by Studio Ghibli after "Spirited Away". The story takes place in a fictional world where magic and machines coexist. It depicts the warlike love between Sophie, a girl who was turned into an old woman by a curse, and Howl, a wizard.

Read Article

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Gedo Senki (Ghibli movie).

Spoiler commentary and discussion of Gedo Senki (Ghibli movie).

Released in 2006, this is a Studio Ghibli film and the first animated feature film directed by Goro Miyazaki, the son of Hayao Miyazaki. Prince Allen, who has abandoned his country and set out on a journey, and Teru, a girl with a burned face whom he meets on his journey. As the two travel, they come to understand each other better while confronting their own painful pasts. This work brings various ways of thinking about the message and the way they walk into each other's hearts and grow together.

Read Article

Summary of spoiler commentary and discussion of "Mimi wo susumeba" (ear-splitting)

Summary of spoiler commentary and discussion of "Mimi wo susumeba" (ear-splitting)

Mimi wo Sumeba" is a Ghibli film released in 1995. The original author is Aoi Hiiragi. This is the first and last film directed by Yoshifumi Kondo, who supported Ghibli's films with his drawings, and Hayao Miyazaki was in charge of the script and storyboards. The story centers on the main character "Tsukishima Shizuku" and depicts her love, dreams, and worries. It is a sweet and sour coming-of-age story that everyone has experienced at least once, and it remains a popular work.

Read Article

Spoiler alerts and discussion of The Borrower Arrietty (Ghibli film).

Spoiler alerts and discussion of The Borrower Arrietty (Ghibli film).

The Borrower Arrietty" is an animated film produced by Studio Ghibli and directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi, based on the book "The Little People Under the Floor" by Mary Norton. The film won the Japan Academy Award for Best Animated Film in 2011 with a final box-office revenue of 9.25 billion yen. The very beautiful visuals went well with the music in the film, and made the viewers engrossed in watching it. The film depicts how a dwarf, who must not be seen by humans, hides and lives in a human house while borrowing things, and the friendship and bond between the dwarf, Arrietty, and the boy, Sho, that is built in a short time.

Read Article

The future of death that Nausicaä invited [Manga version of Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (spoiler alert)].

The future of death that Nausicaä invited [Manga version of Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind (spoiler alert)].

Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind" is the first Ghibli film and one of its best-known works. Nausicaä has both a movie version and a manga version, and the content of the movie version is the story of the first volume of the manga version's seven millstones. The manga version reveals shocking facts that were not depicted in the movie, such as why the king bugs and the bugs of the Sea of Putrefaction were born, what the Giant God Warrior was born for, and who Nausicaä and his friends are. When Nausicaä learns of these facts, she decides to take certain actions. It is a path of perdition from which there is no escape. This article explains the shocking ending and Nausicaa's decision as depicted in the manga version.

Read Article

ハウルの動く城の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

ハウルの動く城の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『ハウルの動く城』とは、2004年公開のスタジオジブリ制作の長編アニメーション作品である。脚本・監督は宮崎駿。 帽子屋の少女・ソフィーは兵隊に絡まれていたところを魔法使いのハウルに助けられるが、魔女の呪いによって90歳の老婆に姿を変えられてしまう。店にいられなくなったソフィーは旅に出、その途中でハウルの動く城に出会うのだった。ファンタジックな世界観や美術、個性的なキャラクターが魅力の作品。ハウルとソフィーの戦火の恋がストーリーの軸となっているため、本作にはロマンチックな名言も数多く登場する。

Read Article

風の谷のナウシカの名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

風の谷のナウシカの名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『風の谷のナウシカ』とは、1984年公開のトップクラフト制作の長編アニメーション作品である。原作・脚本・監督は宮崎駿。1982年に『アニメージュ』で連載していた宮崎の同名漫画を原作としている。宮崎駿の長編アニメーション映画としては第2作である。 「火の七日間」という最終戦争から1000年後の世界。近代文明が崩壊し、「腐海」と呼ばれる異形の菌類の森に世界は覆われていた。本作には、この世界の過酷な現状やナウシカの生き様を表した印象的なセリフが数多く登場する。

Read Article

紅の豚の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

紅の豚の名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『紅の豚』とは、1992年公開のスタジオジブリ制作の長編アニメーション作品である。監督は宮﨑駿。1990年に『月刊モデルグラフィックス』で連載された『宮崎駿の雑想ノート』の『飛行艇時代』を原作としている。 世界大恐慌に揺れるイタリア・アドリア海。豚の姿になった「ポルコ・ロッソ」が、飛行艇を乗り回す空中海賊「空賊」たちを相手に賞金稼ぎとして空中戦を繰り広げる。中年男性向けを意識して制作されたため、「飛行機」や「空軍」などロマンがあり、渋い名言も多い。

Read Article

千と千尋の神隠しの名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

千と千尋の神隠しの名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『千と千尋の神隠し』とは、2001年公開のスタジオジブリ制作の長編アニメーション作品である。原作・脚本・監督は宮崎駿。 10歳の少女・荻野千尋は、両親と共に引っ越し先に向かう途中で不思議な世界に迷い込んでしまう。両親を豚にされ、パニックになる千尋だったが、ハクという不思議な少年に助けられる。そして神々が客として集う湯屋で働くことになった千尋は、だんだんと成長していく。10歳の少女千尋が主人公であるため、わかりやすく、ストレートに心に響く名言が多数登場している。

Read Article

天空の城ラピュタの名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

天空の城ラピュタの名言・名セリフ/名シーン・名場面まとめ

『天空の城ラピュタ』とは、1986年公開のスタジオジブリ初制作の長編アニメーション作品である。原作・脚本・監督は宮崎駿。鉱山で働く少年パズーは、ある時、空から降ってきた不思議な女の子・シータを助ける。追われている彼女を助けようとするパズーだが、自分の古い名前がラピュタであることを打ち明けたシータは、敵に捕まってしまったパズーの身代わりとして連れ去られてしまったのだった。本作には、「バルス!」や「見ろ!人がゴミのようだ!」など有名でキャッチーな名言が多く登場している。

Read Article

The original story of "My Neighbor Totoro" is the Sayama Incident? A summary of the urban legend [Studio Ghibli].

The original story of "My Neighbor Totoro" is the Sayama Incident? A summary of the urban legend [Studio Ghibli].

We summarized the urban legend that the masterpiece "My Neighbor Totoro" is based on the actual "Sayama Incident. This incident was the kidnapping and murder of a high school girl in Sayama, Saitama Prefecture, in 1963. Although Studio Ghibli denies any connection, there are many similarities between the work and the incident, and it is a fact that it is strongly believed on the Internet.

Read Article

A compilation of miscellaneous trivia and urban legends to help you enjoy "Ponyo on the Cliff" for the rest of your life! Thorough explanation of the Ghibli works of Hayao Miyazaki and Isao Takahata.

A compilation of miscellaneous trivia and urban legends to help you enjoy "Ponyo on the Cliff" for the rest of your life! Thorough explanation of the Ghibli works of Hayao Miyazaki and Isao Takahata.

This is a collection of miscellaneous trivia and urban legends for enjoying the Studio Ghibli film "Ponyo on the Cliff". The film was produced by hand, following a review of the drawing method and Hayao Miyazaki's intention to "draw with a pencil. This section thoroughly introduces voice actors, story settings, and other items related to "Ponyo on the Cliff.

Read Article

Contents