The web manga medium "Tsui4" by Seikai-sha exposed and criticized the submitted works, causing a huge firestorm. Calling it a "Tsui4 Newcomer Award Roundtable Discussion," the editors posted harsh comments such as, "We only have 10 works, but we find rough edges one after another," and "Do you think they want us to read them? The popular manga "Onna no Tomo to Musu" (A Woman's Friendship and Muscle) was subsequently suspended, and a manga artist who complained bitterly about the editors had his work cancelled, leading to many harsh opinions about Seikaisha on the Internet.
Overview of Tsui 4 (Tsui Yon)
Source: www.amazon.co.jp
Female Friendship and Muscle," which was serialized in "Tsui 4."
Tsui4" is a web manga medium by Seikaisha, which distributes a variety of four-frame manga on Twitter every day, and its signature work, "Female Friendship and Muscle," was especially well-received, ranking high in book sales and raising the profile of Tsui4.
However, the Tsui4 editor came under fire in June 2015 when he exposed and harshly criticized the entries, including the unsuccessful ones, at the "Tsui4 Newcomer Award Roundtable". The editor's remarks were criticized as being merely cursing without specificity and not advice.
In response to the uproar, the author of "Women's Friendship and Muscle" had her own thoughts on the matter and said that she would take a break from the magazine after a while, causing fans to lament.
Source: www.4gamer.net
This disturbance became a hot topic in mid-June 2015, but the issue came up again in mid-July.
Manga artist Ryusuke Hamamoto, who complained that the editor should apologize for the series of disturbances, has been fired by Seikai-sha.
Hamamoto had been serializing "Puchiin Chronicle," a comicalization of a smartphone game, on "Tsui4," where the problems occurred, while also writing serials for other companies, but the page introducing his work was suddenly deleted. The page introducing the work was abruptly deleted without any notice to Hamamoto himself.
Critique of the entries by the editors of Tsui4 (TsuiYon)
In response to the entry "The Space Flying Civil Servant
>Akan.
>In the first place, this is not a manuscript but a name, isn't it?
>Send me the finished manuscript! Only Togashi-sensei class is allowed to have unfinished work!
>I didn't think it would be this stressful to read 10 4-panel pieces. Do you intend to make us read them?
>Let's go next! Next!
In response to the entry "Ano ne no Nerine
>You lack the drawing ability and character exploration to attack with character moe. The reader is not given a sense of "This is our strength! This is our strength!" is not conveyed to the reader.
>I was annoyed by the baby language. I like young girls, but I don't like .......
>I'm not sure if this person has ever been to a bar and had a drink.
>Fuzzy Navel is no longer a tavern drink. You'd be ashamed to ask for it at a bar!
>Bars rarely serve beer by the jug, and they don't tolerate this kind of drunkenness.
>There are only 10 films, but I find one rough spot after another (laughs).
In response to the submitted work "The Wolf of Peaceful Hood
>The cute little girls are not very cute. Also, the modeling of the non-human characters is too cheap.
>There are too many sentences. Sometimes there is not even a single word, like in the case of Mr. Sattou.
>The drawing ability, characters, and stories all seem to lack two more steps. The most important thing is the lack of tempo, and it is hopeless for a four-panel comic to have no tempo.
>It is not good to have four-panel works that are tiring to read.
The 1st Tsui4 Newcomer Award Roundtable Discussion" Seikaisha Editorial Department | Tsui4 | Frontline
sai-zen-sen.jp
A heated round-table discussion, now open!
After the fire, the author announced that the book would be put on hiatus after some time, "Women's Friendship and Muscles.
ツイ4座談会が辛口で話題になっててクレームまで来ているらしいけど、実際に連載始まったら毎日有無を言わずRTや🌟が誰でも見える状態で晒され続ける事に比べたらとても親切でやさしい。媒体がTwitterだから批判コメントきてもc◯◯◯◯oみたいに削除できないよ!正直だね😃
— KANA ⑥巻発売中 (@sunny3san3) June 16, 2015
RT @samo_taro: ツイ4新人賞座談会 | ツイ4 | 最前線 #ツイ4 sai-zen-sen.jp/comics/twi4/za… これ4コマ漫画の新人賞?らしいけど編集部のコメントが最低だな~…こんな人たちに信頼して自分の作品を預ける気持ちになれない。漫画を描くって事というか……
— KANA ②巻6月11日発売 (@sunny3san3) 2015.06.17 01:00
できる限りの事はさせて頂いているつもりだけど、それでも帯から女子力の文字が消える事はないんだろうな…
— KANA ⑥巻発売中 (@sunny3san3) June 16, 2015
【お知らせ】女の友情と筋肉は近日中に切れるストックをもってお休みさせて頂きます。(タイミングが悪いですが座談会がきっかけではありません。別件で思うところが色々あります)楽しみにして下さっている方には申し訳ございません。
— KANA ⑥巻発売中 (@sunny3san3) June 17, 2015
@sunny3san3 どんな形になるかわかりませんが、物語はきちんと完結させて頂きますので、少しお待ち頂けますと幸いです。
— KANA ⑥巻発売中 (@sunny3san3) June 17, 2015
@sunny3san3 あ、すぐに話を完結させるという意味ではありません。元からある話は変えない予定です。
— KANA ⑥巻発売中 (@sunny3san3) June 17, 2015
@sunny3san3 この皮肉と意図が投稿者の考えるきっかけになれば幸いです。ツイ4をあげている気は毛頭もございません。
— KANA ⑥巻発売中 (@sunny3san3) June 17, 2015
Comments on the editor of Tsui4 (TsuiYon)
Yuzuru Nakagawa, editor and writer
Nakagawa Yuzuru - Wikipedia
ja.wikipedia.org
Yuzuru Nakagawa Source: Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Jump to: wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Yuzuru Nakagawa (born October 17, ) is a Japanese media researcher, informatics scholar, and writer. He is an associate professor at the Faculty of Film and New Media, Nihon Eiga University. D. from the Graduate School of Interdisciplinary Information Studies, the University of Tokyo. He also works as an illustrator under the pseudonym "Mishiki Sakana. Contents 1 ...
http://t.co/s0fv2wWBdk
— 未識魚 /中川譲@ティア140 お33b (@mishiki) June 17, 2015
この論評している連中は星海社の編集? アドバイスがひどすぎる。こいつらこそ「シロウト」っじゃないのか。「つまらない」とか「テンポが悪い」じゃなくて、「4コマで左から右に進むのはおかしい」等々具体的な指導の出来ない編集は無能。
ウェブに掲載するマンガだと、PCの画面通りに左から右に視線を移動させるべきか、紙の4コマに従って右から左に進めていくべきか分からなくなっている若手は多いと思う。応募作にもそういうのがあった。これは編集者の指示ミスだし、ある意味応募要項のミスだろう。それを「テンポが悪い」とは。
— 未識魚 /中川譲@ティア140 お33b (@mishiki) June 17, 2015
お節介は承知で、鋼えおさんの投稿作を(元の絵を可能な限りそのままで)修正してみました。私はこの作品好きです。
— 未識魚 /中川譲@ティア140 お33b (@mishiki) June 17, 2015
編集は、抽象的な言葉でぶっ叩く前にやることがあると思うんです。http://t.co/s0fv2xec4S pic.twitter.com/tIx2s09JiU
編集屋的にはこういうのって基本なんじゃろうか
— 朝倉 (@ohmysorrow) June 17, 2015
Contents
- Overview of Tsui 4 (Tsui Yon)
- Critique of the entries by the editors of Tsui4 (TsuiYon)
- After the fire, the author announced that the book would be put on hiatus after some time, "Women's Friendship and Muscles.
- Comments on the editor of Tsui4 (TsuiYon)
- Yuzuru Nakagawa, editor and writer
- Other
- Fans saddened by the suspension of "Female Friendship and Muscle," serialized in Tsui4 (TsuiYon).
- Takasuke Hamamoto, who had complained bitterly about the problems of Tsui4 (TsuiYon)
- Ryusuke Hamamoto's works to be discontinued
- The defunct "Puchiin Chronicle" introduction page
- Related Summary
