Ritsumeikan University drew attention when it cited an R18-rated novel posted on the illustration communication service "pixiv" and published a paper on it. The author and URL of the novel were listed as is, which led to criticism that the work was "labeled harmful" and "merely exposed," resulting in a flaming situation. Some pixiv users who were actually quoted not only closed their works to the public, but also quit their creative activities.
Filtering of obscene expressions focusing on words whose meaning changes depending on the domain
jsai2017:2M2-OS-34a-1 Filtering obscene expressions focusing on words whose meaning changes with domain
kaigi.org
Some information posted on the Web may be harmful to young people
harmful to young people, especially words with obscene meanings.
are often expressed using metaphors instead of direct descriptions.
The purpose of this study is to filter out
The purpose of this study is to filter out harmful sentences that are expressed by using metaphors.
The proposed method machine-learns sentences containing harmful expressions in each domain
and builds a classifier for harmful expressions.
and filter out the harmful expressions. Experiments to evaluate the usefulness of the proposed method
We conducted an experiment to evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method using a novel designated as R-18.
Source: kaigi.org
2017 National Conference on Artificial Intelligence (31st)
Presented on May 24th from 13:50 to 14:10
Full paper PDF
web.archive.org
▼ The Flow of the Riots
Ritsumeikan University Paper citing R18 novels on pixiv (presented at the national conference of the Japanese Society for Artificial Intelligence on May 24)
It's just a toxic labeling and exposure.
Source: pbs.twimg.com
Source: pbs.twimg.com
URL and author's name as the data used in the analysis (pine tree, red bean, sword) as it is.
As a result, the people quoted are private (my pic).
People who were not involved who found out about the uproar are also privy (My Pics).
The situation has caused a great uproar, with many people deleting their IDs and quitting secondary creative activities.
は?立命館頭おかしいだろ。 卑猥なワードをフィルタリングする学術目的とか言って同人作品のpixivのURLと作者名勝手にピックアップして大公開。大学が。大学が!! kaigi.org/jsai/webprogra… pic.twitter.com/3pluI5zjK3
— マスターみつる【リハビリ療養中】 (@Mituru_666) 2017.05.25 00:16
@Mituru_666 いちおうルールはあってそれを守ると使えるみたいです jera.jp/outline/privac… この場合、作者全てに許諾をもらえば問題ないということになりそうです pic.twitter.com/oiVWlU6xY3
— いらじ (@ERageGraph) 2017.05.25 01:28
ピクシブちゃんの規約の真逆を立命館大学がやっててクソ笑う pic.twitter.com/GbAQNqzWLj
— たろいも (@tottoto778) May 24, 2017
つまり、ピクシブに掲載されている時点で、該当作品は有害猥褻な物ではない。
— たろいも (@tottoto778) May 24, 2017
立命館大学の学生と助教はそれを有害と言ってのけたんだ…すげえ…その基準どこからきたの…
×ピクシブに掲載されてる時点
— たろいも (@tottoto778) May 24, 2017
○ピクシブに削除されずに掲載されている時点
民事訴訟を…作者は精神的苦痛による慰謝料を立命館大学宛に請求するのです…
— たろいも (@tottoto778) May 24, 2017
立命館の件、論文を乗っけているリンクページの右上にこんな事が書いてある。他人の権利は尊重しないの?他人の作品の無断転載はいいの? 関西では上位の大学なのに、残念な事だ…
— りるか@パン好き (@rirukayodakanoh) May 24, 2017
URL:https://t.co/POKAfWto7l pic.twitter.com/mIx3ogXFLs
例の論文への引用の件、引用の規定自体を完璧に満たしてるとは言い難いと思うんだけど(「」の引用箇所に出典明記がない)、支部の利用規約には引っかかるような気がするかな…青少年に有害な情報って決めつけてるところからセッションが始まってる。 pic.twitter.com/S7rRNbR2gT
— 晶 (@jingxxxjing) 2017.05.25 01:44
支部のR-18小説を検索かけて読もうと思ったらこうなる。つまりあの論文はR-18作品が読める状態に設定した上での結果なんだね pic.twitter.com/0UrTMtMLnX
— 遠征シーズン (@ysizuya) May 24, 2017
支部って登録しなきゃ中身見られないし、且つR-18は設定しないと見られないよね。それをわざわざ引っ張り出してきてこれは有害だのなんだの言って論文にするって…… pic.twitter.com/p7XTHWNjJf
— グラファイトくまのみ (@aiueyun0mi) 2017.05.25 01:08
Contents
- Filtering of obscene expressions focusing on words whose meaning changes depending on the domain
- ▼ The Flow of the Riots
- Ritsumeikan University Paper citing R18 novels on pixiv (presented at the national conference of the Japanese Society for Artificial Intelligence on May 24)
- It's just a toxic labeling and exposure.
- URL and author's name as the data used in the analysis (pine tree, red bean, sword) as it is.
- As a result, the people quoted are private (my pic).
- People who were not involved who found out about the uproar are also privy (My Pics).
- The situation has caused a great uproar, with many people deleting their IDs and quitting secondary creative activities.
- May 26: Presentation to students cancelled.
- pixiv has also asked Ritsumeikan University to resolve the issue.
