What is the "strongest" Nintendo Legal Department?

News has broken that Nintendo has lost a lawsuit filed by a former Sony employee against the company for its 3D technology. On Twitter, people were surprised that Nintendo lost the case. Here is a summary of why the term "Nintendo's legal department" is said to be the most powerful.

With news of Nintendo's defeat

newsbiz.yahoo.co.jp

That Nintendo legal had lost

The Nintendo Legal Department has won a number of lawsuits.

KING KONG Trial (1982) -

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

It is the case that Universal sued Donkey Kong for infringing the copyrights of the film "KING KONG".
In response, Nintendo countersued Universal Studios for defamation.

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

Source: blog.seesaa.jp

The outcome of this trial

In fact, Universal lost the case after an investigation by the Ministry of Justice revealed that it had not acquired the rights to remake the original "KING KONG," and ended up paying Nintendo 1.6 million dollars in damages.

● Tetris Incident (March 1989)

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

Sega and Nintendo are competing for the Tetris game.

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

Sega acquired the rights from Atari and its subsidiary Tengen, while Nintendo entered into an exclusive distribution agreement with the Soviet Foreign Trade Association for game software for home consoles. Atari and Tengen sued for infringement of their rights, while Nintendo countersued to stop the sale of Tengen. It was a full-scale confrontation.

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

This case, on the other hand, won.

The right to Tetris held by Atari was purchased through a number of companies, but it was originally the right only for IBM-compatible computers. Nintendo investigated this, Atari and Tengen lost the case, and Sega was unable to sell Tetris due to an injunction.

○ Pokémon Yungeler trial (December 2000)

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

The Pokemon character "Jungerer" was accused by a Uri Geller of violating his rights.

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

In the trial, Nintendo won the case because "Yungeler" is only licensed and sold in Japan, so the law does not apply overseas to products sold in Japan.

The fact that the use of "Yungeler" was limited to Japan probably means that the company foresaw the possibility of lawsuits and took the initiative.

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

In a lawsuit against a magic-computer sales company

I was looking ahead.

If you set up a copy protection device and play with a magic-computer, the ship will not arrive at the port.
The next day, however, a magician responded with a farm upgrade.
However, this is an act that falls under the Unfair Competition Prevention Law. This will immediately lead to a lawsuit.

In other words, it was assumed from the beginning that the copy protection measures would be broken. Otherwise, 54 companies would not join the lawsuit in such a short period.

Source: d.hatena.ne.jp

This kind of trial is said to be the strongest in Nintendo's legal department.

d.hatena.ne.jp

But we can't win all.

gamemusic.blog50.fc2.com

please_go_home
please_go_home
@please_go_home

Contents