Spoiler commentary and discussion of One Apothecary's Life (novella, manga, and anime).

Yakuya no Hitorigoto" is a Japanese online novel and light novel by Hinata Hinata. It has also been published as a comic book in two editions: the Big Gangan edition (illustrated by Neko Kurage, composed by Nanao Kazuki) and the Sunday GX edition (illustrated by Kurata San-noji), which is subtitled "Neko Neko no Koumiya Riddle Solving Notebook" (Neko Neko no Koumiya Riddle Solving Notebook). The two magazines both draw on the same original story. The story is set in a world similar to China. Mao Mao, a cat who used to work in the flower district, ends up working in the imperial palace. There, she gets involved in various cases (and sometimes gets involved herself) and solves them one after another with her expertise in medicine in this fantasy-love-comedy-mystery work.

Contents

A military officer whose life changed greatly by giving giri-no-kanzashi to cats at a garden party.
He took the cat out of the kokyu (empress's residence) under the condition that he introduce the cat to one of the Miyoshi princesses of Ryokuseikan, a long-established tower in the hanamachi (' flower town,' or geisha district), instead of the cat's guarantor.
On his way to the Ryokuseikan (Green Pavilion), he was introduced to Shirosuzu (white bell), a muscular lover, by Yari-Teba, who expected his trained muscles and tried to squeeze his bones to the marrow (he did not know this).
Later, when there was a rumor about a ransom for the white bell, he liked her so much that he seriously tried to prepare a gratuity, and the cat also admitted that he had a vessel to look after his precious sister, so he consulted with her.

Basen

Big Bang-Bang Version (Image by Nekokurage)

Sunday GX version (Image by Minoji Kurata)

He was Gao Shun's son and 壬氏's foster brother. He was the same age as 壬氏 and a military officer.
When he is with his father, he has a bright and honest attitude, but when he goes after a case with a cat, he acts with a grumpy attitude.
However, he never makes light of cats and does his job well.
The two older brothers are married and have children, but he is single.

Kan Rakan

Big Bang-Bang Version (Image by Nekokurage)

Sunday GX version (Image by Minoji Kurata)

He was the father of a cat.
He wears a Date's monocular mirror and always smiles as if he made a fool of himself. He was good at shogi and go, and it was said that he when he was young, but he lost to Hosen in Go. He is better at Shogi than Go.
He is said to be a strategist because of his erratic attitude and seemingly incomprehensible remarks, but his command is precise.
Because Rakan could not recognize people's faces, he was removed from his father as the heir, and his younger paternal half-brother became his successor, but his uncle 羅門, who recognized his talent, taught him how to recognize people by their physique and voices as shogi (Japanese chess) pieces. Then, people's faces became visible as shogi pieces, and even 羅門 was seen as a strong shogi piece.
Since only Hosen and the cat can be seen as human faces, I don't know whether he sticks to them because he loves them or because he knows their only face, but I know that he is trying to love and cherish their existence.
One of the few people who is aware of 壬氏's identity. Still harassing the sticky 壬氏 by the side of the cat.
It is a Sageto and soon goes out of business with a glass of sake.

Suiryo

Big Bang-Bang Version (Image by Nekokurage)

Sunday GX version (Image by Minoji Kurata)

She was a tall court lady. The material is first class, but her make-up is precious.
When a cat came as a maid with a 壬氏, she was one of the members who got involved, but she was the only one who was calm.
Later, she reunites with a cat at the doctor's office, or the cat finds the herb field she planted and meets her again.
He was the main criminal in the assassination of the Emperor's younger brother. He tried to get caught once, but he used the medicine of resurrection and escaped in a state of asphyxia, pretending to be dead.

Differences between the two comic books of "Yakuya no Hitotsugoto"

In order to compare the two works in an easy-to-understand way, from here on, it is specified that the person in charge of the drawing is Nekokurage's "Yakuya no hitotsugoto" as the Big Gangan version, and the drawing is Minoji Kurata's "Yakuya no hitotsugoto neko neko no kokyu nazo solving pocketbook" as the Sunday GX version.

Differences in story composition

It is rare for two magazines to be simultaneously syndicated based on the same book, but the biggest difference between the Big Gang-Gan and Sunday GX editions is the story structure.
The Big Gang-Gan version is comical and faithful to the original, and the content of each episode is dense. The detailed dialogue and facial expressions of the characters are drawn, so it is easy to read the feelings of each character and feel attached to them. This may be the reason why there are many frames per page. The disadvantage is that since the content of the complicated case is drawn as it is, there are too many plots of the person who caused the case and the future, so it is somewhat difficult to convey. Since the accumulation of small cases leads to large cases, the large amount of information may make it difficult for some people to read.
In the Sunday GX version, the Minoji Kurata in charge of drawing understands the content of the original, and the story that is not deeply related to the story is cut and moved forward and backward to make it easier for the readers to understand. There are scenes where the person in charge of drawing expresses it in an easy-to-understand way, so it is easy to see if the character noticed it here. The disadvantage is that there is less affection for the character because there are fewer expressions and lines.
To give a simple example, it is a story of a cat pursuing the case of a maid who had suicide by drowning.
In the Big Bang version, 壬氏 asks, "What are you thinking?" when you are thinking while playing with the leaves of flowers in a toxic vase.
Since the cat answered "Ah" and then said, "What kind of poison should I use if I die?", 壬氏 was a little impatient and asked, "Are you going to die?"
"But I don't know when people will die."

A cat that says shocking words.

After that, 壬氏 turns a completely disgusted expression to the cat.

On the other hand, in the Sunday GX version, a cat looks back after reporting a maid with suicide by drowning.
壬氏 notices this and asks the cat.
"What were you thinking?"
". I don't know what poison to use if I die."
壬氏 is surprised by the cat's answer.

I don't know what kind of expression the cat is saying.

壬氏 can't say anything about what cats say.

壬氏 is troubled by the words of cats and cats.

This is the same scene, but in the Big Bang Bang version, there are many expressions and words of the characters, and in the Sunday GX version, a large frame is made so that impressive words stand out.

kariaka13
kariaka13
@kariaka13

Related Articles

Cooking, eating, food, and drink summary for one apothecary

Cooking, eating, food, and drink summary for one apothecary

Yakuya no Hitorigoto" is a light novel by Natsu Hinata that was first published in 2011 on the novel posting website "Shosetsu-ka Naro". Due to the popularity of the original novel, a comic book version and an anime version were also developed. The setting is the fictional Chinese empire of "Li. Mao Mao, a cat with extensive knowledge of medicine, solves numerous cases in the royal court. Some of the cases are caused by poisons in food or allergies, and a variety of foods and drinks appear in the story.

Read Article

Summary of one apothecary's love relationships, couples, couples, couples, couples, and lovers

Summary of one apothecary's love relationships, couples, couples, couples, couples, and lovers

Yakuya no Hitorigoto" is a light novel by Natsu Hinata and a manga/anime based on the novel, which began serialization on the novel posting website "Shosetsu-ka Naro" in 2011. Set in a fictional Chinese empire, the story centers on a mystery in which Mao Mao, an official who is skilled in medicine, solves mysterious incidents that occur in the royal palace. At the same time, the story depicts how the eunuch Jinshi's unrequited love for Nekoneko comes to fruition, and the love story also forms another axis of the story.

Read Article

Summary of collected and unrecovered foreshadowing and mysteries of the apothecary's soliloquy

Summary of collected and unrecovered foreshadowing and mysteries of the apothecary's soliloquy

Yakuya no Hitorigoto" is a light novel by Hinata Natsu, which began serialization in 2011 on the novel posting website "Shosetsu-ka Naro" and has been adapted into a manga and an anime due to its popularity. Set in a fictional Chinese empire, this is a mystery in which Nekoneko (Mao Mao), who has been assigned to the rear court, uses her knowledge of medicine to solve mysterious cases in the royal palace. Many foreshadowing lines are laid out to captivate readers.

Read Article

神さま学校の落ちこぼれ(小説・漫画)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

神さま学校の落ちこぼれ(小説・漫画)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『神さま学校の落ちこぼれ』とは、日向夏の原作小説をもとに赤瓦もどむが漫画化した作品。『花とゆめ』で2021年17号より連載開始となった。現代日本のごく普通の世界が舞台だが、少し変わっているのは「この世界には神さまがいる」ということ。高校受験を控えた陽美谷ナギは、「神さま学校」の合格通知を受け取る。エリートばかりの学校でナギの成績は学年最下位に。落ちこぼれとなったナギが超難関の国家資格「神さま」を目指す、超能力・学園・友情・恋愛・陰謀が絡むスピリチュアルスクールドラマである。

Read Article

Contents