Spoiler commentary and discussion of The Philosopher's Grandson (novel, anime, and manga).

The Wise Son" is a fantasy novel by Tsuyoshi Yoshioka and a manga and anime work based on it.
The novel has been serialized in "Shosetsu-kaerou" since January 2015. The novel version is illustrated by Seiji Kikuchi and published by Famitsu Bunko. A comic book version is also serialized in Young Ace UP, with Shunsuke Ogata in charge of the artwork. There are "The Philosopher's Son Extra Story," which depicts the younger days of Merlin and Merida, "The Philosopher's Son SP: Ojousama Struggle" and "The Philosopher's Son SS" as external biographies.

Contents

In the comics, Merida explains to Sicily.

This line was uttered by Merida when Shin presented Sicily, Merlin, and Merida with a necklace containing magaishi (devil stone) that had been given the magic of removing foreign objects. This necklace removes foreign objects such as poison, and also removes germs, so it doesn't catch colds. Merida was impressed by Shin's gift because she didn't want her to get sick, but the next moment, Merida realizes that it can be used as a contraceptive. This is one of the reasons why authors with this idea are evaluated as' The idea is disgusting', and furthermore, by making Merida say this line, it is evaluated as' It is not Shin but Merida that is putting it up.'

Tony, "Ball?" Maria, "What do you use that for?"

It is written in comic books, but the original novel does not have this statement.

There is recognition of the ball, but the question of what it is used for is strange. In the comic book, there is a scene in which Shin says, "I tried making a float," and someone says, "Wow, what a breakthrough!" But in the novel, it is explained as a tool for people who can't swim. Both of these lines appear only in the comic book version, and are often featured on the Internet.

May: "Ellie, your sister's chest. is the weapon."

A line from May in which May is sandwiched between Elisabeth and Augustus to welcome Augustus when Ultimate Majischamps, who was heading for relief after the スイード Kingdom was attacked by a genie, safely returns to his country. This line reveals that Elisabeth's heart is Toyomitsu.
In the novel version, after May's line, it is written from the Shin point of view, "Murder weapon. it is difficult to understand from the top of the dress, but is it so great?", so it is clear that she was not dressed like in the comic book. In the comic book version, May is overwhelmed by Elisabeth's heart even at the training camp in Rittenheim territory.

The Monologue of a Baby Shin Saved by Merlin

His memory of his last life is so vague that he probably had an accident. He seems to have died without knowing it.
It's not that I don't think about it, but my parents have already passed away, and I don't have a lover. On my way back and forth between work and home, my only hobbies were reading manga and ranovers, watching anime, and sometimes going touring on my motorcycle. I was always worried about my future, and I wasn't so sad about my death.
I felt a little sad that I had a life that made me think so.
More than that, they are reborn in a world with magic, and they are experiencing "If I could return to my childhood with my present memories," which everyone would have thought at least once.

Source: ncode.syosetu.com

A famous scene that has been forgotten. In the monologue of Shin, who is a baby, in the second episode of the novel, you can see that the memories of the previous life remain firmly in place except for the last moment. Furthermore, you can see that you were an adult in the previous life from the sentence that says that you are experiencing if you could return to your childhood with your current memories. However, this setting becomes the source of various contradictions in the development of the story, and leads to a negative opinion about making childish remarks or falling in love with minors even though there should be memories of adults.

Students' reaction after defeating a demonized cart

NOW THAT I THINK ABOUT IT, YOU KILLED A MAN FOR THE FIRST TIME. IT'S PARTLY BECAUSE HE WAS A GENIE, BUT. YOU DO N'T FEEL GUILTY.
That's what I thought, isn't it? Because you've been hunting a lot of animals in the woods? Have you gotten used to the act of reaping life?

Source: ncode.syosetu.com

After he beheaded and killed Kurt, he saw the body of Kurt and said that Shin's feelings were complicated. Although he was a genie, he felt upset that he had killed a human being.

Excited classmates.

At this point, the genie is considered to be the second genie in the cart, and he is not used to seeing the genie being killed; Merlin and others who killed the first genie still remain as painful memories; nor is it a worldview in which students are exposed to the killing of genies and the death of people on a daily basis.
However, although the classmates here are genies, they have bright faces and lines that make it hard to believe that a human had his head cut off in front of them. The fact that Shin's magic and swordplay are outstanding is emphasized, but the fact that Kurt and some of his classmates from junior high school are delighted with Shin's magic and sword in front of the dead body is a scene that makes you feel strange in a world view that you are not used to human deaths or genies. Therefore, among the readers, it is often treated as' a production to praise the main character and flatter the main character rather than the fact that a person was killed.' In addition, the fact that Alice's line was changed from' I cut off the arm of a genie with a sword' in the novel to' I cut off the head of a genie with a sword' in the comic book is also a factor that makes it a topic as an unpleasant scene.

Shin hiding Kurt's body.

In the comic, Shin borrows a cloak to hide the body so that it won't be seen by the students. This depiction of Shin's consideration stands out in the bright reactions of his classmates. This scene does not exist in the novel.

The moment Ultimate Magicians was born

(And think of of a name for the team. The name of the study group leaves me worried.)
(Now?)
I have a microphone, so I pull up my ears and whisper.
WHAT DO YOU MEAN!
". DO N'T WORRY, EVERYONE. I'VE ALREADY FOUGHT AGAINST THE GENIE AND DEFEATED IT WITHOUT A PROBLEM. EVERYONE HERE IS STRONG ENOUGH TO FIGHT IT. WE ARE."
Well, what shall we have? It's the Ultimate Magic Research Association. No! This is all I can think of!
WE THE "ULTIMATE MAGICIANS" WILL NEVER FAIL TO SUBDUE THE GENIES.

Source: ncode.syosetu.com

The team was named Ultimate Magicians because of Augusto's recklessness.
In this scene, Shin, who has ridiculed magic chanting as' Kuriya Jibyo' (Two Diseases of Kuriya), gives the ultimate magician (magician) a name that is a literal English translation. In a monologue, Shin says, "It's a literal translation! Above all, it hurts!" The fact that Augustus is laughing at the team name that Shin instantly gave suggests that people other than Shin also have a sense of Kuriya Jibyo. However, since there were so many people at the time of the announcement that no correction or change could be made, the members of the Ultimate Magic Research Group became active as Ultimate Magicians.

The Secret Story, Trivia, and Small Stories / Episodes and Anecdotes of "The Wise Man's Grandson"

There are too many Tsukkomi points. The reason why it is evaluated as a stupid anime.

adumina465
adumina465
@adumina465

Contents