Tales of Zestiria] Summary of the flame war caused by Alisha's treatment and Roze's character favoritism [TOZ

Tales of Zestiria" is said to have a low reputation among the "Tales of" series, and one of the reasons for this is the character Alisha Diffuda.
This article explains why the rating is low, the official treatment of Alisha, the suspicion that the character Rose is favored, and the Tales Channel+ and twitter flames caused by the producer's comments about the heroine riot.

Soon after Alisha leaves the group, Rosé, and Dezel, the heavenly wind tribe that uses her as a vessel, join the group.
Her actual appearance is shortly after Srei and Miklio arrive at the entrance to Lady Lake, and she also appears several times after that.
She is also depicted on the game package to the left behind Srey, and there is also a description of her character in the instruction manual, which indicates that she is a playable character.
And since joining the group, there have been episodes about her, and her character is explored in depth.
Rosé is the reason why users are very divided in their likes and dislikes, and why many of them do not approve of her as a heroine.

Rosé, a merchant and an assassin, what is her character?

Rosé is a member of the guild "Sekirei no Hane".
She has a cheerful and vivacious personality, and her own pace. She is not fond of ghosts, and at first she is not very fond of the Heavenly Tribe either.
She is also a bit withdrawn when Srei and Miklio are excited about the ancient ruins, and her personality makes her a mood-maker among Srei's group.
She is actually the front face of a guild called "Sekirei no Hane," but behind the scenes she is the head of an assassination organization called "Kaze no Kone," of which Rose is the head.

Unsullied assassin with a pure heart

Roze in assassin's outfit

Rosé seems to have about the same level of spiritual stress as Srei, and Laila suggests to Srei that he should invite Rosé to join him on the trip.
Miklio and Edna both agree that it would be good to have a companion who can see and hear the same things.
Dezel says that Rosé was his vessel and that he possessed her because she was near him, an absolutely untainted being, in order to take revenge on a certain person so that he himself would not be defiled.
According to Lila, "A person with a pure and clean heart does not produce defilement. Therefore, Rose can be said to be an "Unsullied Assassin.
However, it is also true that there are those who say that it is scary to kill so many people without suffering or feeling guilty, and that it is an obstacle when considering the setting of defilement.

Character favoritism? Numerous setting elements favored by the producer

Rosé's setting seems forced, and why is that?
In fact, Rosé is the producer's favorite character.
Hideo Baba, producer of the Tales of series, says of Rosé.

She's a character with no quirks that anyone would like."
She's a lot like me.
I love Rosé."
'I also love the voice actor for Rosé.'

In addition, as an official character setting, the merchant guild is a temporary form, and in reality it is an assassination group, and since he is a chieftain at a young age, his ability is well-known.
As for his spiritual power, while Alisha's low ability caused a backlash against her squire contract, Roze has no such backlash and has an extremely high ability to use the "divine robe," a technique that should only be used by Suray, the master of the guild. She has completely eclipsed both Alisha and the main character, Suray, who is also a master.

Why is Rose unacceptable as a heroine?

The heroine on the official side would be Rosé, but many users do not accept her as a heroine.
Rosé has a policy of killing any evil that affects the people, whether it is a dignitary, king, or imam.
And to the priests who were committing mass murder to eliminate the unholy because of their faith in the heavenly race but were not unholy because they had no sense of guilt, she says, "You can never fool yourself into thinking that you are only guilty. Murder is a sin...That guy who was killing without feeling that guilt for any reason was a monster," he said.
However, many users said that they could not accept the contradictory values and setting of Roze, and that there were many differences between his personality as described in the character introduction and his actual personality in the game, which they could not accept. The reason for this is that there are many differences between the personalities described in the introduction of the characters and those in the actual game.

Tales of Zestiria's firestorm

This firestorm started from a dispute over whether Alisha or Rose was the heroine of the game, and as a result, many users were not given satisfactory explanations or responses to the issues of the DLC episode sales method of Alisha, which is called the DLC business, the way Alisha is treated in the main story and in the DLC episode, and the producer's comments. As a result, the community of Tales Channel+, the official portal site, was ablaze with flames.

Flame and official response regarding the sale of additional DLC episodes

Alisha had been treated badly in the main game, but two days after its release, a DLC featuring Alisha as the main character was decided to be distributed, causing a stir among users.
However, three days later, when the DLC was released, it was priced at 1,300 yen, which was one-tenth the price of the main game, while the software was priced at 7,000 to 8,000 yen.
The production team must have been impatient, because on the same day, the official announcement was made that the DLC would be distributed free of charge for a limited time to commemorate the 400,000 shipments.

Problems in setting up and the repercussions of follower contracts

In the main story, when Alisha made a squire contract with Suray, she left because of a backlash that caused Suray's body to malfunction due to low spiritual stress. In the DLC episode, Roze becomes her mentor and makes a squire contract with her.
But in the DLC episode, Roze becomes the guiding spirit and makes a squire contract with her.
In the ending, people's spiritual stress increased because Srei went to sleep with "Maoteras," who used the continent as a vessel and protected the entire Glynwood. It is set up that because of this, the recoil is gone.
However, with the exception of Srei, the new members of the group, including Alisha, begin their journey, but due to Roze's role as a guide, it is not clear who is the main character, Alisha or Roze.

Is the treatment of Alisha, who became the main character, better?

There is also an argument between the two in the episode.

Alisha is the main character in the DLC episode.
So, has she been treated better?
Roze continues to treat Alisha badly.
And despite the fact that Roze is being lifted up and she herself is being put down, Alisha praises Roze.
Furthermore, the volume was spectacular and thin, as users who were pessimistic expected, with a total play time of about 1.5 to 2 hours with smooth progression and endless walking through dungeons with interiors that were appropriated from the main story.

Producer's Statement

One of the factors that caused the furor about the heroine to flare up so violently was the fact that there was no comment from the producers or any other members of the production team.
Baba, who initially made no statement in Japan, responded in an interview in Taiwan about the spread of the matter in that country as well.

I didn't say who the heroine was, and I revealed the characters in the order in which they appeared in the game.
I apologize for the controversy and speculation about the heroine, but basically it is up to the player to decide who the heroine is.

The flames became even more intense because of the escape stance that it was solely the user's responsibility to decide who the heroine was.

Statements and claims against each media outlet that would be discrepant in an interview with Famitsu

keeper
keeper
@keeper

Related Articles

Tales of Zestiria (Tales of Zestiria) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Zestiria (Tales of Zestiria) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Zestiria" is a role-playing game developed by Namco Bandai Entertainment. It is the 15th title in the Tales series and the 20th anniversary title, with the catchphrase "Lore will someday become 'Hope'". In addition to a magnificent worldview and the freedom to roam the fields, the game uses a new system and allows players to enjoy familiar skits. Suray, a human raised by the Heavenly Tribe, was a boy with pure and big dreams. After an encounter with a young girl, he decides to become an imam to save the world from disaster.

Read Article

Tales of Arise (Tales of Arise) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Arise (Tales of Arise) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Arise" is a role-playing game released by Namco Bandai Entertainment Inc. It was scheduled to be released in 2020 as the 25th anniversary of the Tales series, but its release was postponed to September 9 of the following year. The official genre name of the game is "RPG for the Dawn of the Heart. Set in the two worlds of Dana and Rena, the world-shaking journey begins when Alfen, a young man who feels no pain, and Sion, a girl who causes extreme pain to those she touches.

Read Article

A thorough explanation and discussion of Norse mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

A thorough explanation and discussion of Norse mythology! Interesting and easy to understand!

Norse mythology is a mythological system that was believed by the Norse people before the spread of Christianity. It is also called Scandinavian mythology because the Norse had the Scandinavian Peninsula as their sphere of influence. The myths were passed down orally, but around the 13th century, the Icelandic poet Snorri Sturluson compiled them into a book titled Edda. The story depicts the rise and fall of gods whose "doom of destruction" has been decreed, and many of the episodes have a dark overall impression. The story as a whole is highly accomplished, and it is often used as a subject in modern creative works such as comic books.

Read Article

Tales of Symphonia (Tales of Symphonia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Symphonia (Tales of Symphonia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Symphonia" is an RPG game released by Namco for the Nintendo GameCube. It is the fifth title in the "Tales of" series. It is a popular work that was later ported to other consoles, and has been widely developed into OVAs, drama CDs, and other media. Four thousand years after the ancient war in which the hero Mythos sealed the evil Dzian race, the source of all warfare, the world is once again on the path of decline due to the resurrected Dzian. Together with Colette, a young girl who is the divine child who will save the world, the hero, Lloyd, sets out on a journey of world rebirth to seal off the Dzaians and restore the world to peace.

Read Article

Tales of the Abyss (Tales of the Abyss) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of the Abyss (Tales of the Abyss) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

This is the 8th full-length work in the RPG "Tales of" series and commemorates the 10th anniversary of the series. Character design is by Kosuke Fujishima. Luke, the only son of the Duke of Kimuraska, is suddenly transported to an unknown place with Tia, a mysterious assassin who has trespassed into the mansion. Luke, who works with Tia to return to the mansion, meets many people on his long journey, experiences many things, and comes to know the meaning of his birth.

Read Article

Tales of Xillia (Tales of Xillia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Xillia (Tales of Xillia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Xillia" is an RPG released by Namco Bandai Games Inc. for the PlayStation 3 in 2011, celebrating the 15th anniversary of the series. Kosuke Fujishima and Mutsumi Inomata, well-known character designers of the series, are in charge of character design for this title. Set in Liese Maxwell, a world created by the spirit Maxwell where humans and spirits coexist, the film tells the story of Mira Maxwell, a mysterious woman who shares the same last name as her creator, and Jude Mathis, a young man who aspires to become a doctor, and how they save the world.

Read Article

Tales of Berseria (Tales of Berseria) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Berseria (Tales of Berseria) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Berseria" is an RPG released by Namco Bandai Entertainment, Inc. and is the 16th mothership title in the "Tales of" series. The genre name is "RPG for you to live as you are". It was the first mothership title to feature a single female protagonist. Velvet's brother-in-law, whom she trusted, killed her brother in front of her eyes. Her left hand was turned into a karma demon, and she sets out on a journey of revenge to kill her brother-in-law, who became the savior of the world.

Read Article

Tales of Destiny (Tales of Destiny) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Destiny (Tales of Destiny) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Destiny" is an RPG game for the PlayStation released by Namco. It is a popular work, and remakes and director's cut versions were later released for the PlayStation 2. The main character, Stan, leaves his hometown and stows away on a flying dragon bound for the great country of Seingard. However, a horde of monsters attacked the flying dragon. Stan is in desperate straits, but his fate changes drastically when he encounters Dimroth, an intelligent sword found in the dragon's warehouse, and becomes a Sodian Master.

Read Article

Tales of Destiny 2 (Tales of Destiny 2) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of Destiny 2 (Tales of Destiny 2) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of Destiny 2" is an RPG game released by Namco for the PlayStation 2 and is a sequel to "Tales of Destiny". In addition to the game, it has been developed into other media such as drama CDs and comics. Eighteen years ago, there was a disturbance over a giant lens, the "Eye of God. The main character, Kyle, is the son of Stan and Lootie, two of the four heroes who saved the world from the threat of the God's Eye, and he longs to be a hero like his parents. One day at the ruins, he meets a mysterious girl named Riala who says she is "looking for a hero," and Kyle's journey to become a hero begins.

Read Article

Tales Of Xillia 2 (Tales Of Xillia2) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales Of Xillia 2 (Tales Of Xillia2) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

It is about a year after the boundary shell separating Liese Maxia and Ellenpios disappeared. Ludger Will Krusnik is a young man living in Triglav, the capital of Ellenpios. On his first day at work, he and a young stranger named Elle are caught up in a train terror attack. He struggles to solve the case, but ends up with a large amount of debt and a mission to destroy a world of partial history. This is the 14th full-length work in the "Tales of" series.

Read Article

Tales of Phantasia (Tales of Phantasia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Phantasia (Tales of Phantasia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Fantasia" is an RPG game released by Namco for the Super Nintendo Entertainment System. It was later ported and remade for various consoles, including the PlayStation version. The main character Cress, who lives in the village of Totis, goes hunting in the nearby forest with his best friend Chester, but when they return to the village, they find that it has been destroyed. When they return to the village, they find that the pendant given to Cress by his father is the cause of the attack on the village, and Cress leaves his best friend who remains in the village to mourn the villagers.

Read Article

Tales of Vesperia (Tales of Vesperia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Vesperia (Tales of Vesperia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

About the game Tales of Vesperia (Tales of Vesperia, TOV) for XBOX and PS3. This game is the tenth installment in the popular Tales series. It has been developed into a manga, a movie, and a drama CD. Yuri sets out on a journey for the sake of peace in the downtown area. During his journey, he meets various friends and forms a guild, Brave Vesperia. Together with his friends, he fights against a conspiracy that threatens the survival of the world.

Read Article

Tales of Symphonia - Knight of Ratatosk (TOS-R) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of Symphonia - Knight of Ratatosk (TOS-R) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of Symphonia: Knight of Ratatosk" is an RPG for Wii released by Namco Bandai Games as a sequel to "Tales of Symphonia", which was also published as a novel and manga. The two worlds have become one and peace has been restored to the rebirth of the Gods of Rebirth. However, the world has become one, and there is no end to the clashes that occur due to changes in the natural environment and differences in civilization levels. Two years after the rebirth, the story opens with an incident known as the "Blood Purge.

Read Article

Tales of Graces f (Tales of Graces f) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of Graces f (Tales of Graces f) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of Graces F" is an RPG game for PlayStation 3 released by Namco Bandai Games Inc. as a port of the Wii version with new episodes and costumes. It is a work that has been developed in a wide range of media, including drama CDs and comics. The main characters, Asbel and her brother Hubert, meet an amnesiac girl named Sophie in their childhood. Seven years later, Asbel returns to her hometown and finds a girl who looks exactly like Sophie, who disappeared in an incident.

Read Article

Tales of Legendia (Tales of Legendia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Legendia (Tales of Legendia) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of Legendia" is an RPG exclusively for PS2 released by Namco Bandai Games Inc. and is the seventh mothership title in the "Tales of" series. The genre name is "RPG where bonds create legends. The story follows the siblings Senel and Shirley, who are washed up on a huge ship called the "Ruins Ship" and become involved in a battle for the fate of the world. The game is developed by a different staff from the production team of the previous series, and the system and design have been completely renewed.

Read Article

鉄拳8(Tekken 8)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

鉄拳8(Tekken 8)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『鉄拳8』(Tekken 8)とは、バンダイナムコエンターテインメントより2024年1月に発売された格闘ゲームである。リアルなグラフィックとダイナミックなバトルシステムがさらに進化。『鉄拳』シリーズを象徴するキャラクターや技が、新たなアクションとともに復活し、緊張感あふれる対戦が展開される。初心者から上級者まで楽しめる多様なシステムが搭載され、オンライン対戦機能も大幅に強化されているのだ。

Read Article

SCARLET NEXUS(スカーレットネクサス)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

SCARLET NEXUS(スカーレットネクサス)のネタバレ解説・考察まとめ

『SCARLET NEXUS』とは2021年にバンダイナムコエンターテインメントから発売された3Dアクションゲーム。舞台は脳とテクノロジーを融合し、高度な文明を築いている近未来の世界。人間の能力が拡張され超能力が使えるようになっていた。一方で、人間を襲う異形の存在「怪異」に脅かされていた。怪異を討伐する怪異討伐軍に新入隊員として入隊したユイトとカサネ。2人は世界を巡る戦いに巻き込まれていく。

Read Article

New Pokemon Snap (game) spoiler commentary and discussion

New Pokemon Snap (game) spoiler commentary and discussion

New Pokémon Snap" is a completely new title and sequel to "Pokémon Snap" for the Nintendo 64, a spin-off of the "Pokémon" series. The main character investigates Pokémon ecology and the mystery of the "Illumina Phenomenon" in the uncivilized Lentil region. The appeal of the game is the ability to observe and photograph approximately 200 Pokémon that have appeared up until "Pokémon Sword Shield" with beautiful graphics. Sales exceeded 2 million units worldwide, much to the delight of fans, as this was the first new title in 22 years.

Read Article

Idolmaster One for All (OFA) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Idolmaster One for All (OFA) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

THE IDOLM@STER ONE FOR ALL (OFA) is an "idol training simulation game" released in 2014 by Namco Bandai Games Inc. The hardware is "PlayStation 3". The story of this game is that a producer and 13 idols join forces and aim to win the "Idol Extreme (IE)," which is the proof of a top idol, by increasing their fame through "work," "live" and "festival" events. The appeal of this title is the experience of overcoming idol setbacks and struggles together.

Read Article

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology 3 (MySolo 3) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology 3 (MySolo 3) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology 3" is a PlayStation Portable RPG released by Namco Bandai Games Inc. in 2011. The main character in this title is born from the World Tree as a "descender" and goes on adventures with characters from the "Tales of" series. The series' characters co-star across titles, and 77 controllable characters appear in the game. The story progresses as the player dives into dungeons and completes quests from his airborne ship, the "Vanqueltier".

Read Article

Tales of the World: Radiant Mythology (Tales of the World: Radiant Mythology) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of the World: Radiant Mythology (Tales of the World: Radiant Mythology) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology" is a PlayStation Portable RPG released by Namco Bandai Games on December 21, 2006. The game features 19 characters from the "Tales of" series, who appear together across different works. In this title, the main character, a "descender," a guardian created when the World Tree is in danger, is led by "Mormo," a descender from another world, to fight to protect the World Tree from the invasion of demons that devour the world.

Read Article

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology 2 (MySolo 2) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology 2 (MySolo 2) Spoiler Commentary and Discussion Summary

Tales of the World Radiant Mythology 2" is a PlayStation Portable RPG released by Namco Bandai Games on January 29, 2009. This title features more than 50 characters from the "Tales of" series, who appear together across works. The main character of the game has lost his memory, and in order to regain it, he dives into dungeons and goes on quests on the pirate ship "Van Ertia" to progress through the story.

Read Article

Tales of the Heroes: Twin Brave (Tales of the Heroes: Twin Brave) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of the Heroes: Twin Brave (Tales of the Heroes: Twin Brave) Spoilers and Discussion Summary

Tales of the Heroes Twin Brave" is an action game for the PlayStation Portable released by Namco Bandai Games in 2012. This game is a fan disc game featuring characters from the popular "Tales of" series, transcending the boundaries of the series. Players fight together with their "bonded" pairs in "Welt Lung," a world that thrives on "mana" produced by the World Tree, and battle a large number of enemies as they advance through stages.

Read Article

Summary of "Tales of Zestiria" flames! 'Tales of Berseria' Presentation Still Causes Unrest [TOZ].

Summary of "Tales of Zestiria" flames! 'Tales of Berseria' Presentation Still Causes Unrest [TOZ].

The following is a summary of the flames of "Tales of Zestiria. The various problems, such as heroine fraud and alleged scenario modification, combined with the poor official response and lack of remorse on the part of the producer, have resulted in a situation that has attracted many harsh opinions. Naturally, there were voices of concern about "Tales of Berseria," a work that was announced without the turmoil having been resolved.

Read Article

Tales Series] A compilation of images that are unintelligible to non-fans.

Tales Series] A compilation of images that are unintelligible to non-fans.

The "Tales series" is the generic name for RPGs produced by Namco Bandai Entertainment, starting with "Tales of Fantasia" in 1995. Almost all of the games have a completely independent worldview, and each game is characterized by adventures in a completely different place, so that without individual settings or specialized knowledge, you may find yourself asking, "What is this? Without knowledge of the individual settings and expertise, you may sometimes find yourself scratching your head and wondering, "What's this? The history and popularity of the series has also led to the creation of a variety of fan art. Here we introduce some of them.

Read Article

Contents